4 ms·
Any plan to reduce/remove flash needs to address the HUGE amount of small flash based web games. Just look for online playable games for kids and you'll see how
by ars 10y ago
Any plan to reduce/remove flash needs to address the HUGE amount of small flash based web games. Just look for online playable games for kids and you'll see how many there.
"Websites that currently use Flash or Silverlight for video or games should plan on adopting HTML technologies as soon as possible."
This is utterly unrealistic, these games are 10 or more years old sometimes, and still played in large numbers, with no money available for the developer to rewrite them.
Only an automatic transpiler of some kind has any chance here.
- Sylos 10y agoThe problem is that this is not easy at all. Mozilla had a project which tried to do pretty much exactly that, called Shumway [0], and development has been going on for a few years, but they didn't really get anywhere useful in all that time. [0]:https://mozilla.github.io/shumway/ https://mozilla.github.io/shumway/
- spriggan3 10y agoUnfortunately without the help of Adobe itself, this project is DOA. It won't run most flash content out there. Flash content HAS to be specifically designed to run on shumway. Adobe should have open sourced flash years ago, it didn't. Well at least that's a lesson for developers, don't use proprietary techs on the web.
- cooper12 10y agoThat's what Shumway [0] was supposed to be, but according to another comment, it's been added to the Firefox graveyard unfortunately. [1] [0]: http://mozilla.github.io/shumway/ http://mozilla.github.io/shumway/ [1]: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/describecomponents.cgi?product=Firefox%20Graveyard https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/describecomponents.cgi?product=...
- larsiusprime 10y agoI think someone with enough ingenuity could extend [OpenFL](http://www.openfl.org/ http://www.openfl.org/) to create such a transpiler. An OpenFL HTML5 app is already capable of rendering SWF animations, but it doesn't currently support the internal actionscript. With access to the games' original source they could be ported to OpenFL pretty easily (it uses Haxe, a language similar to actionscript that can transpile to many other language targets), but that's a bit short of automatic runtime transpilation of SWF content.
- khedoros 10y ago15 years ago, one of my biggest reasons to be on the internet was sharing flash animations and games with friends over IM. With how popular those things were back then, it seems like there's been comparatively little effort to preserve them.
- ars 10y agoLike this? http://www.freescreencleaner.com/monitor_cleaner.swf http://www.freescreencleaner.com/monitor_cleaner.swf :) And who can forget http://www.weebls-stuff.com/other-toons/video/magical-trevor.html http://www.weebls-stuff.com/other-toons/video/magical-trevor...
- derefr 10y agoGiven that these Flash applications you're talking about are fully "boxed"—that is, the Flash and the page don't do any IPC, the Flash is just its own independent thing sitting "in" the page like an iframe—a transpiler that compatibility-shims all old Flash+JavaScript IPC-based app behaviors is a bit beyond what's necessary. Really, what I expect to see is just an emulator specifically written for the sake of these old Flash games. Probably as a core of MESS, and thus of JSMESS, with the games then showing up in the Internet Archive's "Online Arcade" like everything else.
- egypturnash 10y agoIf they're still played in large numbers, then they should be able to figure out some way to get their user bases to help pay for the time it would take to rebuild them. Patreon, donation drives, kickstarter, ads...