6 ms·
Housing can’t be a good investment and affordable
- projectramo 10y agoThat is an excellent point. TL;DR: A good investment has to grow in value over inflation, and if housing grows in value at even a decent rate, it compounds out of affordability. As an example, housing in San Fran has grown at 2.5% over inflation.
- maxxxxx 10y agoIt's not desirable for house prices to grow faster than inflation. It just means that younger generations have to pay a larger and larger share of their income.
- lotyrin 10y agoIt is for the house-as-investment. If you don't expect the value of your home to outpace inflation, then it has an opportunity cost compared to investing capital in investments that will.
- VT_Drew 10y ago>A good investment has to grow in value over inflation Housing is the exception to this rule. Yes you want your investments to beat inflation, but unlike an index fund, or a stock, or a commodity, you need housing (you have to live somewhere). You have to either rent or buy (or live off the land in the woods, which can be illegal many places). When you rent you are throwing your money away, you will never see that money again, period. The one other alternative is to purchase, even if you lost a small percentage on your "investment" buying a home, isn't that better than just throwing your money in the trash and losing 100% of it? An investment that isn't great is still better than an investment that absolutely sucks.
- srtjstjsj 10y agoYou are forgetting that people don't buy houses alone, those houses come with mortgages, also known as "renting money", throwing money way, you will never see that money again, period. Those houses also come with excise taxes, property taxes, insurance premiums, and agent fees.
- GFischer 10y agoFor the U.S., you have these "rent or buy" calculators: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calculator.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calc... http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303948104579534230618539424 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527023039481045795342... Buying seems to be better in most cases but not all. Edit: relevant MrMoneyMustache article, saying how in a very expensive city (Toronto) it's better to rent: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2015/07/27/rent-vs-buy/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2015/07/27/rent-vs-buy/ For my country (Uruguay), for almost all houses barring mansions or waterfront properties, if you plan to stay more than a few years, it's better to buy. The rent vs mortgage relationship is ridiculous (and investors love it).
- sfaf 10y agoThat's not how ROI works. You can show that in San Francisco, IF you live in a rent controlled apartment, it's very possible that you get a better economic ROI from renting than owning. The factor you are forgetting is that owning a house requires a down payment and there's an opportunity cost of not investing that down payment in alternative investments (stocks average 6-8% ) which could generate a return that's significantly better than your house. I've actually done a 10 year DCF analysis for SF and in many scenarios, a rent controlled apartment whose rent becomes cheaper over time (since SF rent controls are at 1% while inflation is 3%) can be a significantly better (and less risky) investment than owning. There is this false concept that rent is "throwing money away" but that's not true in many cases; there's an opportunity cost of your down payment, property taxes, etc. with house ownership. NYTimes has a nice web calculator to help figure it out for you: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calculator.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-calc... Key reasons why renting could make sense 1 house ownership is incredible risky due to high down payments 2) rent control laws makes renting actually cheaper over time
- dragonwriter 10y ago> A good investment has to grow in value over inflation Only if you consider both the asset value plus value extracted (e.g., in the case of stocks, both market value and aggregate value of dividends.) In the case of housing, this means that the market value plus the aggregate of the value derived from owning the homes (the utility of living in it, rents derived from it, etc.) must, in total, grow faster than inflation.
- TheBeardKing 10y agoI don't care as much about my home as an investment (though appreciation matching inflation would be nice) as much as not having to pay rent or mortgage when I'm older. Retiring at 70% income means nearly full salary after the mortgage has been paid off, minus taxes and insurance.
- nomel 10y agoI think the article is simplifying things. Gaining money with a housing investment is great and all, but stoping the stream of money that goes into the void from rent is also a gain. Owning with a loss less than that from renting is, by definition, and investment. Investment: the action or process of investing money for profit or material result. Profit: money in - money out. For the bay area, that means you just have to not lose ~36k/year in taxes, fees, and any housing dips.
- gozur88 10y ago>Gaining money with a housing investment is great and all, but stoping the stream of money that goes into the void from rent is also a gain. You're just trading the stream of money that goes into rent for the stream of money that goes into taxes and interest on your loan. You can't say "owning is better than renting" or vice versa without crunching the numbers for your particular situation. When I bought my first house I was paying out more every month (by quite a bit) than I did as a renter. Then I rented for awhile and bought my current place, in which I come out ahead vs renting.
- Kinnard 10y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12134021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12134021
- whack 10y agoI'm glad someone is pointing out something that nagged away at me for a long time. With every other cost-of-living product, we celebrate when their prices go down, because we recognize that a lower cost-of-living translates to better qualify-of-life, at the aggregate. So why is it that we do the exact opposite with housing. Imagine if house prices tomorrow were to increase by 10% across the board, throughout the country. Who exactly would that help? Not the vast majority of home-owners who own a single home. They're still going to continue living in their house, and will be unaffected by the 10% increase in any meaningful way. And if they ever decide to sell the house and claim the 10% increase as profit, where are they going to live next? They will just have to buy/rent another house, where their earlier profit will be going entirely towards paying the higher housing prices for their new home. So what you really have is a situation where all the renters face dramatically higher costs of living, the single home owners are mostly neutral, and the upper-class with multiple homes suddenly find themselves with a windfall. And we think this is cause for celebration? Personally, I can't wait for the next housing crash.
- uola 10y ago"Who exactly would that help?" The banks. I don't even think they pretend otherwise at this point?
- HeyLaughingBoy 10y agoYup. I had a friend who always said that he wished housing prices kept going down so his property taxes would drop, and then went back up a month before he wanted to sell :-)
- resolaibohp 10y agoI agree with you here. It really annoys me when people tell me they hope their house continues to increase in value at an exponential rate. Houses are not like stocks, families don't buy and sell them to make money. They are places to live. The people I hear this the most from are in the middle class, the ones who are most likely not to benefit from the increases. I hope this thinking stops.
- 10y ago
- kirykl 10y agoHouses build equity, I'm not sure if they have been expected to be a good investment that beats inflation. This was pushed hard though by multiple industries during the mortgage bubble
- mamon 10y agoI wonder why no one seems to take into account that house is something that wears off with time. Shouldn't the value of the house asymptotically aproach zero, given long enough timeframe? I mean, at some point, like maybe in 100 years it should eventually rot and collapse. Or you can keep fixing and redecorating it, but that also costs money.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoWell, the land never goes to zero. The house may (or may even be worth less than zero), but not the land...
- planteen 10y agoExactly. That's why in Denver you see lots of old houses getting purchased only for their land, torn down, and then a new $800k house in their place.
- superuser2 10y agoAny sane rent vs. buy calculation is going to include maintenance, i.e. battling entropy to make sure that doesn't happen. More to the point I don't think many houses have reached that point. In my casual observation new construction tends to be either not single family homes (different economics) or on undeveloped land. Teardowns are relatively rare in old neighborhoods (though additions and renovations are quite common).
- gozur88 10y agoThere are houses that last for hundreds of years. You can make them last if you're willing to keep repairing things.
- Kinnard 10y agoA potential solution to this problem: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12122503 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12122503
- Kinnard 10y agoI'm not sure I agree. I suspect the real issue is the government supplied debt financing. I think government subsidies drive up housing prices to the extent that you NEED to take out a loan to pay for a house rather than being able to pay for housing up front out of savings. Housing prices would be a lot lower(and more affordable) were it not for all the money unnecessarily doused on it. Because prices are so high buyers must participate in credit markets which is like socio-economic ankle weights for poor people. They either get screwed or excluded(and screwed). EDIT: The Higher Prices also ensure that people need continue to work to "pay off" their mortgages. If housing prices weren't artificially high they'd already be "payed off" having been payed for with savings. cf: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12131855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12131855
- norikki 10y agoIs this author a complete idiot, or just a stooge of the banks? Investing 1/3 of your income into equity every year sure as hell beats losing it forever to rent-seeking landlords. It doesn't matter if the value of your home goes up, just that instead of being empty handed after 30 years of paying rent, you will have a huge financial asset.
- collyw 10y agoIf the value of your house goes down by more than you pay in rent, then renting is the better option.
- kmonsen 10y agoIt is not a ponzi scheme, it is a limited good in demand. At some point the price will be high enough that it is not affordable for the people that want to buy it. You cannot just treat housing like a stock, since it is also a way to get good jobs and children in good schools.
- sidereal1 10y agoIt's a ponzi scheme when Government subsidized debt and high risk mortgages (NB: free money) removes price pressures, allowing prices to inflate to unreasonable highs. It's a feedback loop where more money > higher prices = good investment > more money.
- snowwrestler 10y agoHomes do not need to grow faster than inflation to be good investments. Let's look at a couple numbers. Over the long term, on average, U.S. homes do not appreciate faster than inflation. > Home prices look remarkably stable when corrected for inflation. Over the 100 years ending in 1990 — before the recent housing boom — real home prices rose only 0.2 percent a year, on average. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/14/business/why-home-prices-change-or-dont.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/14/business/why-home-prices-c... Yet, despite that, home ownership is correlated with net gains in household wealth. > Overall, owning a home is consistently found to be associated with increases of roughly $9,000-$10,000 in net wealth for each year a home is owned. Also consistent with earlier studies, African-Americans are found to benefit less from owning a home, but each year of owning is still associated with gains in net wealth of between $6,000 and $8,000, which is substantial considering the generally low levels of wealth among African-Americans generally. http://www.jchs.harvard.edu/sites/jchs.harvard.edu/files/hbtl-06.pdf http://www.jchs.harvard.edu/sites/jchs.harvard.edu/files/hbt... So how does this make sense? Well first, home prices on average keep up with inflation, which is a strictly better rate of return than just holding cash. So even if just think of it as a vehicle for pure savings (wealth preservation), home ownership is better than no investment. But you can also easily and relatively safely leverage up to buy a home. With a 20% down payment, if the home appreciates at inflation 2.5%, your actual rate of return will be 12.5% before expenses and payments! But what about expenses and payments? Well--you have to make them anyway, even if you're renting. But aren't mortgage payments usually more expensive than rentals? At first they might be, but with a fixed-rate mortgage, the nominal monthly payment doesn't go up. So again, inflation helps out: every year the real cost of the monthly payment declines. Good luck finding an apartment with rent control for 30 years. Finally there are the tax advantages. Every one knows about the mortgage interest deduction, but potentially more powerful is the capital gains exemption of up to $250,000 per person.