7 ms·
Diversity in tech will never work. You are going against reality if you think everyone has the same aptitude to be good at math/engineering. Look at the data be
by sakaloda 10y ago
Diversity in tech will never work. You are going against reality if you think everyone has the same aptitude to be good at math/engineering. Look at the data below.
SAT Math by race [1] :
- Asian/Pacific Islander = 598
- White = 534
- Mexican American = 461
- Black = 429
SAT Math by gender [2] :
- Men = 537
- Women = 503
[1] https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=171 https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=171
[2] http://www.fairtest.org/sat-race-gender-gaps-increase http://www.fairtest.org/sat-race-gender-gaps-increase
- Tcepsa 10y agoGoing by your extremely tenuous suggestion that genetics is an accurate predictor of math/engineering aptitude because of how people of certain ethnicities or sex perform on the SAT, we should have a distribution in tech that looks like this: - Asian/Pacific Islander = 29.6% - White = 26.4% - Mexican American = 22.8% - Black = 22.1% - Men = 51.6% - Women = 48.4% In other words, roughly equal numbers of all of the demographics (specifically _not_ an overwhelming majority of White Men). So even if your argument were valid it seriously undermines your point.
- buckbova 10y agoAnd I bet this would be true, if women didn't gravitate moreso to the natural sciences.
- drdeca 10y agoNot that it likely impacts your point much, but does this adjust for population sizes?
- Tcepsa 10y agoI totally misinterpreted the data; for some reason I assumed it was the number of students from each group that scored above some threshold, rather than the average score of that group. My calculations are completely garbage, and I would withdraw the comment but it looks like I can't at this point.
- tzs 10y agoAren't you making a big assumption about linearity?
- Tcepsa 10y agoI think it's more that I totally misinterpreted the data. For some reason I assumed it was the number of students from each group that scored above some threshold, rather than the average score of that group. My calculations are completely garbage, and I would withdraw the comment but it looks like I can't at this point.
- netsharc 10y agoI would say at the moment there's still a feedback loop. Little girls somehow learn that they're expected to be not as good at math, and maybe they try less hard and give up more easily. Not to mention socio-economic backgrounds when you bring race into it.
- pythia__ 10y agoWhat you are describing is stereotype threat. High-quality evidence for it is scarce to none; a recent meta-analysis: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022440514000831 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022440514....
- soundwave106 10y agoThe evidence for poverty affecting education performance, however, seems pretty high here. Example paper out of many: http://www.academicjournals.org/article/article1379765941_Lacour%20and%20Tissington.pdf http://www.academicjournals.org/article/article1379765941_La... And there's more too it, of course. I chose this link primarily because I found another observation very interesting: "In many studies, [the] mother’s education [level] had a more significant effect on children’s scores than income." Equating inborn aptitude to SAT scores alone seems very short-sighted.
- mining 10y agoThat's not just stereotype threat - to give an example, there are people I know in their early 20s who were strongly discouraged from doing higher level maths in high school, and as a result, had a much harder university level maths experience.
- kaitai 10y agoThe interesting thing about the study you cite is that it only focuses on children and adolescents. You fail to mention that the majority of research has been carried out in college student populations and the findings are fairly robust. One resource for dozens of articles is the bibliography at reducingstereotypethreat.org; since you seem to be down on it I'll just link straight to their discussion of criticisms of stereotype threat [1]. However, stereotype threat is not the only mechanism that fits the poster's description. Most Americans, upon hearing that I'm a mathematician, say, "I hate math! and I suck at it." Then they stare at me hostilely or say, "You must be really smart." There's a little subset of 40-65 year old women, though, who say wistfully, "I loved math and it was my best subject... but... in high school they said I wouldn't need it so I couldn't take the calculus class, I had to take typing instead..." Tracking in high school is used extensively and dissuades people tracked into crappy high school STEM classes from pursuing STEM degrees in college (or getting in at all). [1] http://www.reducingstereotypethreat.org/criticisms.html http://www.reducingstereotypethreat.org/criticisms.html
- grb423 10y agoWow the bigotry. What is wrong with you? These tests are created and scored by privileged white people.
- dang 10y agoPlease don't respond to a bad comment by violating the HN guidelines yourself. That just makes this place worse.
- clifanatic 10y ago... if so, then why do asians appear to dominate them?
- dang 10y agoThis is sleight of hand. Even supposing all that "data" to be accurate, you assume your conclusion by acting as if you know what the reason for it is. But, as we all know, nothing is more highly disputed. This is not the way to an open-minded and open-hearted discussion about the truth; it's a tangent to yet another generic ideological flamewar. That violates the HN guidelines. Since you've done this repeatedly before and don't appear to have any other purpose in commenting here, we've banned your account. Please stop creating new accounts to break the HN guidelines with.
- yAnonymous 10y agoYcombinator themselves are acting reverse racist by preferring to hire minority groups, so these rules are very hypocritical. Just saying. And banning for a post that provides evidence is ridiculous. You should apply for a government job in Turkey.
- smt88 10y ago> reverse racist Racism implies an overarching ideology. A true racist would say something like, "White employees are better than black employees." Y Combinator has never suggested that minorities are categorically better employees. Preferring to hire from minority groups has many benefits unrelated to race: increased diversity boosts profits[1], for starters. There's a huge difference between racism (trying to keep minorities out of your office) than what you're calling "reverse racism" (trying to have a diverse office). 1. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/03/090331091252.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/03/090331091252.h...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- clifanatic 10y agoYikes. All he did was present some data (with references) that you dispute. You banned him for that? You seem to be the one who isn't interested in an open-minded and open-hearted discussion about the truth.
- brador 10y agoWhy do you think these numbers are fixed? They can change, if there exists competency and a desire to learn. You are also ignoring the effects of changing environment which those numbers disregard. For example, we know blacks disproportionately come from low income backgrounds with higher crime and a "rough" home life, which can affect a childs ability to effectively study and learn. That's not because they're genetically black as you allude, that's because they grew up in that environment. Your data does not capture or ignores this crucial variable and you should stop pushing it.
- mark-r 10y agoThese numbers tell you where the bump is in the bell curve, but tell you nothing about who's out on the long tail. Learn to treat people as individuals, not statistics. This list also says nothing about cause/effect. Do the scores represent innate aptitude, or rather the result of a lifetime of societal biases?
- lmmlzxx 10y ago> result of a lifetime of societal biases. Not just societal biases, but simple demographic realities that are not controlled for at all looking solely at scores on a test.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ZenoArrow 10y agoEven if the data you're pointing to was accurate and wasn't influenced by upbringing, they represent averages. Not everyone in each of those groups is going to have an aptitude for maths, but enough will. Also, aptitude for mathematics and aptitude for tech aren't directly correlated, though there is likely to be some overlap.
- DannyBee 10y agoAssume for a second these tests are valid ways to prove what you are trying to prove[1]. First, you can't simply reslice the data and think you have shown anything valid. Simpson's paradox and all that. It could be that women do better than men in all but one race, for example, and that race "brings the average down" to the point where the overall gender scores look like they do. In fact, if you look at the wikipedia article on simpson's paradox, it gives the great example of .. a gender bias study :) Whoever is creating these numbers by confounding variables and grouping data from other studies is just making a mess of the original data :( (This is sadly not uncommon, and happens a ton in race and crime statistics, etc. The folks who make the original data often go to great pains to explain their methodologies, etc, and then some random org just throws it all in excel so they can produce charts that support whatever, and acts like anything they do to the data makes it still valid) Second, ignoring that serious issue for a second, The only thing this gives you is "a snapshot of the world today". This is a test of actual current performance trying to predict success, not trying to predict potential performance. The SAT gives no data on what innate ability is, nor does it try to. That means it can change, and you can improve the numbers. [1] i'm pretty sure the main correlation the SAT shoots for, and succeeds at, is predicting whether folks will be "successful the first year of college". There are a number of studies that show this. There are also newer, but less studies, that show other predictors may be just as good.