3 ms·
To me, I think this represents a failure of the currency. Either the code is the final word on the contract or not. This process seems to give a cartel of peo
by empath75 10y ago
To me, I think this represents a failure of the currency. Either the code is the final word on the contract or not. This process seems to give a cartel of people the power to revoke transactions on a whim. Who would commit to building anything in an environment like that?
- TheRealPomax 10y agoThat description fits current banking systems just as much.
- bdcravens 10y agoSo if it's not an improvement, why bother?
- matthewbauer 10y agoFrom what I understand, it's much worse than any human legal system. Theory and precedent have all been thrown out and everyone is at the mercy of whoever can convince 51% of stakeholders. There's no concept of "equal protection" like in a modern legal system.
- zwischenzug 10y agoExactly - what happens when the next freedom fighter/terrorist/Kanye uses Ethereum, and a hysterical majority freeze them out. Where is your open distributed cryptocurrency then? Worse - as far as I can tell - than a properly regulated banking system working under the rule of law.
- DannyBee 10y agoExcept, uh, no. Almost everywhere, there is a ton of legal (and other) recourse, as well as a theoretically neutral arbiter who will listen to you and make a decision. There is some due process. You can argue about the neutrality, the laws, whatever. There's something, and it's recourse for plenty of people/etc. Here, if all your neighbors get together and want to steal your money, they can steal your money, and you have no recourse.
- matthewbauer 10y ago> Here, if all your neighbors get together and want to steal your money, they can steal your money, and you have no recourse And this was always possible even before the hard fork. The difference now is that there is an actual precedent for it and apparently at least 51% of Ethereum stakeholders are okay with doing that sort of thing. Anyone actually holding a significant amount of Ethereum should seriously question the original claims that the Ethereum team made on its value.
- Normal_gaussian 10y agoThe majority of the planet apparently. Of course that cartel has a better track record than this new one, so I also see it as a failure of the currency.
- factorialboy 10y agoWith fiat, there are legislative and legal recourses. Those aren't perfect, but they are something. With ETH, it's a handful of inexperienced individuals with possible case of conflict of interest.
- drcode 10y ago> I think this represents a failure of the currency Yes, this proves ethereum is a failure- Everyone reading this thread might as well just send their now-worthless ether to my wallet at 0x6B4a61a3Fdc2596427A25F79D7b3b78e164da308.
- PeterisP 10y agoOn the contrary, this represents a success for the currency - it represents a failure of the concept "the code is the final word on the contract", which the Ethereum community judged as incompatible with a good future of their currency and threw out this concept. Apparently when considering "Who would commit to building anything in an environment like that?" in practice, then an environment where the code is the final word on a contract is even less desirable than a suboptimal environment where, as you say, "a cartel of people the power to revoke transactions on a whim".
- int_19h 10y agoBut that approach was what made Ethereum unique. If it is abandoned, then why should anyone use it, rather than the more popular and better established alternatives?
- PeterisP 10y agoThe concept of smart code-enforced contracts is valid, interesting and useful for practical applications even if (and IMHO especially if) there is some non-technical override possible above them.