4 ms·
Don't forget that the 9th circuit is so far left it's either foul or halfway up the stands on any given decision and gets overruled at appeal very frequently.
by dsfyu404ed 10y ago
Don't forget that the 9th circuit is so far left it's either foul or halfway up the stands on any given decision and gets overruled at appeal very frequently. It's very possible that the next appeal will change things.
- rbanffy 10y agoThere is no justification for using a device that endangers animal life during times of peace.
- dsfyu404ed 10y agoI didn't make any comment on the validity of the decision, just that the 9th tends to err much farther left than the other circuits and appeals of its decisions are much more frequently successful.
- rbanffy 10y agoRight, because protecting marine life is such a commie thing...
- douche 10y agoI guess we can only mow our lawns or harvest grain during wartime, by that logic?
- emodendroket 10y agoRight. After all, neat lawns are vital to a war effort (???).
- s_q_b 10y agoOkay, but you'll have to be willing to give up the following: agriculture, power generation (both fossil and renewable), housing, clothing, and shelter. Almost all industrial scale processes, including building your house, endanger animal life in one way or another, whether it's particulate creation from fossil fuels, migrating birds in wind turbines, or simple destruction of habitat. A better argument, to me, would be that dolphins and whales exhibit intelligence on par with the great apes. Dolphins have the largest number of neurons in the neocortex of any mammal, communicate with one another, transmit culture from generation to generation, and work in tandem with humans even in the wild. There's at least a decent argument to be made that they may be sentient. Given that possibility, we would be not only cruel to damage these animals, but perhaps would also deprive ourselves of an invaluable resource in understanding the roots of consciousness.
- binarymax 10y agoApples to oranges. The processes you mentioned actively produce an end product. Sonar, at best, produces intelligence during wartime and at worst, kills intelligent marine life during peacetime.
- s_q_b 10y agoThe end products of a powerful navy are openness of the sea for commerce, protection of international peace, and national security. Intelligence, when gathered in accordance with the law, is an invaluable resource in producing those end products. Security may be something that many in the United States take for granted, but it is one of the basic requirements of human beings, perhaps even prior to food, water, and shelter on the hierarchy of needs.
- breischl 10y agoRight, because you really want to use your equipment for the first time when you're in a fight. Why would you want to see if it's in good repair, train your crews with it, find the limitations, or even see if the stuff works at all before the shooting starts?! </s> There definitely are justifications. Maybe not sufficient to justify the damage done, but it's not like the Navy is just screwing with whales for grins.
- rbanffy 10y agoYou can minimize the use of the equipment to tests that ensure its operational, made on dry land or with precautions preventing the sound to disturb marine life. Training can happen on simulators.
- zeveb 10y ago> There is no justification for using a device that endangers animal life during times of peace. If you want those times of peace to last, or if you just want to ensure peace on your terms after war, you need to practise for war.