4 ms·
The Real Cost of Seattle's Next Transport Bill Would Come from Not Passing It
- chris_va 10y agoNot necessarily wrong, but not a well thought out piece. I'm all for public transit, but this doesn't cover the issue in sufficient depth to actually be informative. Assuming $30/hour opportunity cost? Pulling 20 minutes a day out of a hat? Ignoring the alternative forms of public transit? Commutes are complex beasts. The article ignores the demand curve of commuting, and dynamic responses like people moving closer to their work. If we are going to look at opportunity cost, what is the expected gain by investing $53B in existing public transit? Or rezoning density downtown?
- techsupporter 10y ago> Or rezoning density downtown? You can't really get any more dense in Seattle's downtown core. There aren't any single-family houses left and everything between Denny and, say, Yesler is zoned much, much more dense than pretty much anywhere else in town. I completely agree that there needs to be more dense zoning, especially around the light rail stations. (I also read somewhere that the new Roosevelt station will have less density zoned for it, because of neighborhood opposition, than already exists in areas of Seattle not getting light rail. The math seems to bear that out, at least from the zoning maps I have read.)
- maherbeg 10y agoSeattle still has a long ways to go for densification. Lower Queen Anne is not dense at all if you walk through it. There are also still a lot of surface lots in downtown and throughout the city that should ideally be buildings with parking garages instead. If we converted some of those garage spots to paid public parking (similar to the pearl apartments on 15th), we'd get the best of both worlds.
- danjayh 10y agoThe article also conflates the tax increase with the cost of the plan, which are two entirely separate things. Whether the government immediately raises taxes enough to cover the whole tab or does it at some later point doesn't really matter -- the people will eventually pay (this is also the case for our massive federal debt). In this case, Seattle is covering under a third of the cost with their up-front tax increase, so for the article to suggest that the tax increase should be the number that folks consider is disingenuous at best.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoOne of the pluses of living in Seattle instead of the Bay Area is the significantly lower taxes (especially given that Washington has no state income tax); this could be a trend in the wrong direction. I'd really hate to see Seattle become the next Bay Area (except without the nice weather to justify the higher costs of living).
- techsupporter 10y ago> this could be a trend in the wrong direction Some, like myself, argue that Puget Sound's taxes (and those in Seattle, specifically) are too low to both pay for the infrastructure we have and that which we need. Our property tax rate inside Seattle is in the bottom half of the country and our sales tax is relied upon too heavily and fluctuates too much to be used for funding things that need a long-term stable tax source. I'm perfectly willing to pay taxes on transit, schools, roads, water-and-wastewater, social services, and even a municipal fiber optic network. Voters usually agree with me since almost all of these levies have been put to a public vote and are approved in, generally, at least 2:1 margins.
- Hydraulix989 10y agoI still remember how miffed everyone was about the toll bridge...
- erispoe 10y agoWhat are the alternative forms of public transit?
- techsupporter 10y agoJust watching the staggering change that has happened now that Capitol Hill and University Link stations have opened makes me both thrilled for the next ones (U-District, Roosevelt, and Northgate) and insanely jealous of the handful of areas inside the city that are going to get real, grade-separated mass transit over the next two or three decades. It is already far too late for me to afford to buy housing in any of the coming-very-soon areas that is walkable to the new train stations and the new stations (Ballard and West Seattle Link) are going to areas that are already priced out of most affordability. Though I understand the political and infrastructure reasons why we have to build light rail to the suburban areas before filling in the urban core[0], that doesn't stop me from being sad that, in my lifetime, already-dense areas like Georgetown or the Central District or Lake City or even Greenwood[1] won't see real high-capacity transit. (Having a single station in the CD's Judkins Park doesn't really count, not when Interbay and Ballard are getting five stations between them, or when West Seattle has four.) I read somewhere, probably on Seattle Transit Blog[2] from someone who likes to rant about this stuff like I do, that route 48 through the CD has more daily riders now than the train to Issaquah is supposed to have five years after it opens in 2035. But Goldy makes the most salient point: Voting against Sound Transit 3 doesn't accomplish anything except, maybe, make Sound Transit more cautious in a second vote and less willing to put out a big package to build for the next generation. Voting for it doesn't get a perfect system, but I think that it helps more than saying no. 0 - Because Sound Transit is a regionwide taxing district so the region has to pass it and selling voters in Everett on a transit package that builds only in Seattle will not fly; because we should have been building Ballard Link 30 years ago so, by that same logic, we need to build Redmond and Issaquah Links now instead of waiting 30 years... 1 - Yes, I realize that "85th St Station" is marked as "provisional" and that 85th is the southern boundary of Crown Hill and that having a light rail stop west of IH-5 with easy bus and RapidRide access from west Greenwood and Crown Hill would be a good compromise...but nothing would beat having a station parked right at NW 100th and Holman. 2 - It's a good blog, you should read it: http://seattletransitblog.com http://seattletransitblog.com
- drewrv 10y agoI've decided recently that I'm voting against ST3. It bums me out because I've always been a big transit supporter (I know how republicans voting for Hillary must feel). The thing is, ST3 builds a ton of crap to the outer suburbs and 50 billion dollars and 20 years later it will still be a pain to get from the University District to Ballard. But at least the taxpayers of Bothell will have an easy way to get to Totem Lake!
- Hydraulix989 10y agoAt first, this seemed like a politically-motivated editorial that I would consider out-of-place on HN, but then I realized this skunkworks guy has a point. Seattle's public transit runs around the Bay Area's in circles right now. The Link light rail is clean, modern, and actually useful. Buses come EVERY TEN MINUTES, and they take you anywhere in the entire Puget Sound. There's even ferries and trains. As tech companies hire more people, you're going to be looking at more gridlock. Think about how packed the 101 has gotten since 2011 when FB and Apple went on their hiring frenzies. This transit packing is about to happen in Seattle (in fact, I consider in many ways the Bay Area to be a leading indicator for what is about to happen in other cities), which is already bottlenecked by two bridges, and Redmond already has the greatest daytime population shift in the US during commute hours. It's a shame that the companies that are causing the problem (Amazon, especially) in Seattle can't help pay for solving the problems they are creating.
- loeg 10y agoBuses come every 15 minutes if you're lucky and they're on time. Most of the time during commute hours one gets bogged down and they stack up (2 come every 20-30 minutes… great). That said, ST3 is better than the alternative.
- techsupporter 10y agoThe bus that runs outside my house (route 48, in the CD) comes every 10 minutes almost like clockwork for several hours of the day and drops to 15 minutes from end of peak (6pm) until 10pm and then 30 minutes after that until after 1am. That's a vast improvement prior to Seattle's Proposition 1 vote in 2014--wherein we voted to pay for a metric ton of service hours--and the restructure around University Link. I've noticed a marked improvement in other routes I use daily, like the 3/4 pair, route 11, and even the puny 65 up to Lake City. Your point about bus bunching stands, though, if only as an example of how polarized the use of curb space is in this city. "BAT lanes" that aren't well enforced (though I have seen a lot more towing of parked cars out of them as of late) and a dearth of bus-only lanes in favor of preserving on-street parking are just two of my complaints. But service, at least in town, has gotten better in my experience. Hopefully the additional station openings in 2021-2023 will free up even more service hours to fill in gaps and extend the span of service (dare I dream for 24-hour bus[0] service?). 0 - Sound Transit has already said that 24-hour train service is very unlikely until the second train tunnel is online.
- yummyfajitas 10y agoI'd be willing to take transit activists more seriously if rather than advocating for more money, they advocated for reforms to get costs under control. US costs are insanely out of control relative to, well, everywhere. Construction costs are 2x-10x more than everywhere else in the world. https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/06/03/comparative-subway-construction-costs-revised/ https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/06/03/comp... https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2011/05/16/us-rail-construction-costs/ https://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2011/05/16/us-r... Labor costs per ride are 3x more than Paris, 4x more than London. http://www.wsj.com/article_email/mtas-costs-loom-large-1468803446-lMyQjAxMTE2OTE0ODAxODg5Wj http://www.wsj.com/article_email/mtas-costs-loom-large-14688... Yet transit activists always ignore the fact that we could get 2-10x more transit for the same money. It almost makes you wonder if their real goal is just funneling more money to the people currently taking all the money, rather than actually getting transit.
- bane 10y agoThe U.S. is capable of building and running great things, but we seem to be able to mire every effort down so much that the costs spiral out of control. We also tend to delay delay delay so much that we lose on the very simple time-value of money principle. D.C. Metro Silver line and the 2nd Ave subway line in NYC are big reminders of this. Silver line is about $300/mi almost entirely above ground on existing right of way. There are relatively few stops per mile as well so most of the line is just pure above ground or elevated track. 2nd Ave Subway is running something like $2.3billion per mile. When you compare to other developed economies, and their costs of line construction, these costs are basically indefensible.
- abduhl 10y agoHow do you propose we cut construction costs? Should we cap labor rates on the workers? Looking at your lists (and from my own personal experience with people who have been on the various jobs listed), it seems obvious to me that the major differentiator between jobs is the labor costs. It just flat out costs more to hire skilled labor in the US and UK versus Singapore or Japan. This is largely related to union rates and municipal regulations on wages. How do we get 2-10x more transit for the same money? Where in your mind can we actually cut costs?
- aaronbrethorst 10y agoThis is only semi-related, but if anyone here has an interest in making a meaningful difference in improving their fellow Seattleites' mass transit experiences, I'm always looking for more people to pitch in on OneBusAway for iOS: https://github.com/onebusaway/onebusaway-iphone https://github.com/onebusaway/onebusaway-iphone Well thought out PRs for any bug or feature you care about are always welcome. Also feel free to email me at aaron@brethorsting.com if you'd like to discuss more details.
- kfor 10y agoI'm not an iOS dev but as a Seattleite I really appreciate your work - thanks!
- witten 10y agoHere's a plug for OneBusAway for Pebble: https://github.com/kmwoley/onebusaway-pebbletime https://github.com/kmwoley/onebusaway-pebbletime I didn't write this, but one of my co-workers did. (And not a dev!)
- aaronbrethorst 10y agoThat's awesome! Has he emailed the main OBA developers mailing list about it? https://groups.google.com/forum/#!forum/onebusaway-developers https://groups.google.com/forum/#!forum/onebusaway-developer...
- csydas 10y agoOh wow I didn't realize this was an entirely volunteer project - I thought it was from the various transit authorities for the Puget Sound. This was an incredible app when I lived in the Seattle-Tacoma area, and I wish more places had it or at least a similar app. I lack the skill to contribute code-wise, but are finacial donations beneficial? Is the best means of donation through the UoW website as listed or do you have alternate donation channels? (i.e., does the UoW donation page slice off some of the donation for the University or is it earmarked in whole for the project?)
- 10y ago
- WalterBright 10y agoIf ST would include the Renton-Bothell train tracks, which are already there, it would form the right half of a circle all the way around Lake Washington. This would greatly increase the effectiveness of the system, at minimal cost.
- techsupporter 10y agoSound Transit wanted to run light rail on the Eastside Rail Corridor. Kirkland's city government strenuously objected: http://www.kirklandwa.gov/Residents/Community/ST3.htm http://www.kirklandwa.gov/Residents/Community/ST3.htm
- WalterBright 10y agoThere are still tracks from Tukwilla to the southern edge of Kirkland. Adding the tracks to that point would cause a lot of pressure on Kirkland that I doubt they'd be able to withstand.
- lanestp 10y agoI instantly have problem with anyone touting the opportunity costs related to an entirely made up number. 10 minutes off a fictional commute is not a convincing metric. How about instead we have say, line X needs $Y for modernizations after which line X will be Z minutes faster along its route. Or, which arterials will have new transit solutions. I'm not arguing this is a bad spend of money (quite the opposite) but this article badly needs some real numbers to make its point.