12 ms·
> Whenever a paper was assigned, I always started it that same day, finished later in the week, and then sent it to the professor for their thoughts. As a teac
by bsder 10y ago
> Whenever a paper was assigned, I always started it that same day, finished later in the week, and then sent it to the professor for their thoughts.
As a teacher, I would not respond to the early submission of an assignment like that. If you had specific questions or clarifications, I would be willing to answer. However I would not give you "multiple bites at the apple", so to speak, in terms of grading. It's simply not fair to the rest of the class.
That having been said, being in CS, I didn't tend to give assignments like that. I would give a programming assignment, start the automated tester, and everybody had 2 weeks to get the tester to give them a green light. During that 2 weeks, I would freely answer questions, and, generally, I would go over publicly during the beginning of the next class and questions asked privately that were particularly insightful or useful. That way everybody benefits from all of the questions.
I have two primary concerns when teaching a class: 1) getting the information across and 2) treating everybody in the class fairly. Everything else flows from that.
- munin 10y agoThis was my experience as well. You don't want to give any student an advantage. This extends to when a student brings you a proof and wants to know if the proof works. You can't actually tell them, because that would leak information about the correct solution. So in some classes, any discussion of the assignment (beyond asking if something in the assignment is a typo or not) is forbidden.
- wnoise 10y ago> "multiple bites at the apple", so to speak, in terms of grading. It's simply not fair to the rest of the class. Isn't it? If everyone has equal opportunity, how is it unfair if some don't take advantage of that opportunity? I can see a distinction with, say, paid outside tutors, as not everyone can afford to use their services. Rather than unfair, I say that it detracts from one of the (implicit, and not always acknowledged) goals of schools: certification. Teaching clearly benefits from the rapid feedback. Certification, on the other hand, is harmed by the ability to redo, because it also becomes a measurement of diligence and conscientiousness as well as skill. Even so, the consumers of grades (employers and graduate programs) are looking for diligence and conscientiousness, perhaps even more so than demonstrated skill.