23 ms·
I don't know, I'm not a professional statesman, but I don't believe Machiavelli and Sun Tzu have to define the terms of our existence nowadays.
by rhizome 10y ago
I don't know, I'm not a professional statesman, but I don't believe Machiavelli and Sun Tzu have to define the terms of our existence nowadays.
- throwanem 10y agoNeither of those authors wrote anything that's relevant in this context, so I'm not really sure where you're going with this.
- mikeash 10y agoIf you don't even have a proposed alternative to participating in the Cold War, then how can you say that doing so was not in the interests of the US? The worth of an action can only be judged in comparison to its alternatives, because you always have to make a choice. Even doing nothing is a choice.
- throwanem 10y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12123670 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12123670 for what appears to be a strongly conspiracy-theoretical view of the matter. (I realize that "conspiracy theory" bears a strong negative connotation, but I'm not really sure what else to call it - "cybernetic", in the sense of that discipline, is the closest neutral adjective I came up with, but that doesn't really seem to capture it.)
- mikeash 10y agoHmm, yes, I guess if you're of the opinion that the Soviets were never a threat anyway then the US's role in the Cold War would look pretty silly. I sense that a lot of people think about MAD as spring into existence one day as "if war, then all die" without any buildup. There seems to be poor understanding of the fact that it started with great Soviet military superiority, evolved through vast American nuclear superiority, and only eventually settled on mutual deterrence around the mid to late 1960s. I often see people talk about the Cuban Missile Crisis as narrowly averting the end of humanity, so clearly there is a general lack of appreciation of how this stuff evolved.
- rhizome 10y agoI do not subscribe to a requirement that criticism must contain solutions. History tells us that the opportunity cost was huge, delayed social progress in the US, and enriched the same people who have benefited from battle mentalities throughout the ages. The Chilcot report is a refrain, a repeated theme.
- throwanem 10y ago> I do not subscribe to a requirement that criticism must contain solutions. The Cold War is part of the past. No solution is necessary, or indeed even possible. You're not being asked to provide one, but instead to defend the historiography you've been at some pains in this and other threads to advance. Would you like to do so?
- mikeash 10y agoI agree when it comes to criticism in general, but the statement that it didn't serve US interests is quite specific. I think you ought to be able to at least handwave what could have been better. This isn't like criticizing the plot of a movie, where they didn't even have to make that movie to begin with, and "that movie was terrible, they might as well have just kept the money in the bank" is always valid in some way. Here, a choice had to be made, even doing nothing would have been doing something. You say that the opportunity cost was huge. What are you comparing it to? "Opportunity cost" implies some other possibility that you're comparing against. How can you know the opportunity cost was huge if you have no idea what you're comparing against? Or do you know, and you just don't want to talk about it?