4 ms·
Participating in the Cold War at all, however, was not. "Interests" are not self-justifying.
by rhizome 10y ago
Participating in the Cold War at all, however, was not.
"Interests" are not self-justifying.
- throwanem 10y agoI eagerly await your argument for how unconstrained Soviet imperial expansion into Western Europe would've advanced US interests.
- fit2rule 10y agoIt would have further allowed the continued justification of western imperialism as a 'reaction' ..
- throwanem 10y ago...which, if true, would have resulted either in Soviet domination of Europe, or, when Soviet and American ambitions bluntly collided, a hot war instead of a cold one. It may be possible to regard either of these outcomes as preferable to the one which actually occurred, but I have to confess myself unable to imagine how.
- fit2rule 10y agoActually, this is what happened. Western imperialism ran rampant, we have human rights violations and heinous, heinous conditions for significant parts of the world, all because the West wants its way. 6 of one, half a dozen of the other. The only reason you're arguing is because its your team that is doing all the damage.
- throwanem 10y agoDon't mistake me for being particularly starry-eyed about American imperial ambitions, or America in general; I'm a nationalist by default, because I'd rather live in a strong country than a weak one, not because I'm especially in love with its frankly rather adolescent national mythos. That said, based on all the historical evidence I've seen, if I had to choose between living in an American satrapy or a Soviet one, I'd take the former without a qualm. US history isn't without its stains, but in all things there are degrees, and to claim there's nothing to choose between the two powers is arrantly ahistorical.
- pjc50 10y agoThat was what the nukes and large tank forces were there to prevent. There's a big difference between parking them in friendly countries which have asked for them as part of mutual defence against said invasion, versus destabilising other countries in order to install compliant governments so you can park your tanks there. There is always the question of how much the cold war created its own reaction: on the other side there would have been generals talking up the risk of "unconstrained US expansion into the western USSR".
- mikeash 10y agoWhat was the alternative to participating? Are you suggesting that abandoning Europe to its own devices in the late 40s would have been in the interests of the US?
- rhizome 10y agoI don't know, I'm not a professional statesman, but I don't believe Machiavelli and Sun Tzu have to define the terms of our existence nowadays.
- throwanem 10y agoNeither of those authors wrote anything that's relevant in this context, so I'm not really sure where you're going with this.
- mikeash 10y agoIf you don't even have a proposed alternative to participating in the Cold War, then how can you say that doing so was not in the interests of the US? The worth of an action can only be judged in comparison to its alternatives, because you always have to make a choice. Even doing nothing is a choice.
- throwanem 10y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12123670 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12123670 for what appears to be a strongly conspiracy-theoretical view of the matter. (I realize that "conspiracy theory" bears a strong negative connotation, but I'm not really sure what else to call it - "cybernetic", in the sense of that discipline, is the closest neutral adjective I came up with, but that doesn't really seem to capture it.)
- mikeash 10y agoHmm, yes, I guess if you're of the opinion that the Soviets were never a threat anyway then the US's role in the Cold War would look pretty silly. I sense that a lot of people think about MAD as spring into existence one day as "if war, then all die" without any buildup. There seems to be poor understanding of the fact that it started with great Soviet military superiority, evolved through vast American nuclear superiority, and only eventually settled on mutual deterrence around the mid to late 1960s. I often see people talk about the Cuban Missile Crisis as narrowly averting the end of humanity, so clearly there is a general lack of appreciation of how this stuff evolved.