3 ms·
> I was once interning for a chemist, and asked if he ever thought we would have desktop NMR machines. He said there was no way they would ever be small enough.
by jcranmer 10y ago
> I was once interning for a chemist, and asked if he ever thought we would have desktop NMR machines. He said there was no way they would ever be small enough. I then pointed at his laptop and remarked that is what people thought about computers 50 years ago.
Good-resolution NMR requires high frequencies and high magnetic fields. A 900 MHz NMR would use around 20 T--which is strong enough to pretty much require superconducting cryogenic magnets. Admittedly, a 100 MHz NMR requires only about 2-3T, which is close to what can be produced with a neodymium magnet, but you do get much, much noisier spectra.
With the larger field strengths, the need for magnetic field shielding pretty much restricts the ability to shrink it down to bench-scale machines.
- tener 10y agoPerhaps in 50 years we will have superconducting magnets at room temperature?
- MichailP 10y agoCould you recommend a good book about design and construction aspect of NMR, like design of coils, magnets? Thanks!
- soundwave106 10y agoThere is indeed actually such a thing as "benchtop NMRs" (like Picospin, Spinsolve, etc. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benchtop_nuclear_magnetic_resonance_spectrometer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benchtop_nuclear_magnetic_reso...) but as you say they operate at a much lower resolution. (My understanding is that these machines came on the market for certain applications where the low resolution wasn't as much of a problem as other things like affordability or portability.)
- ridgeguy 10y agoYou were right to use that computer as an example. Here's an MRI probe that's quite literally microscopic. Fig 1 says it's about 3.5µm in diameter. [1] [1] http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.04238v2.pdf http://arxiv.org/pdf/1603.04238v2.pdf