3 ms·
There is no morality in international relations. The international stage is ultimately an anarchy, and it's a dog-eat-dog world. Countries which make decisions
by mikeash 10y ago
There is no morality in international relations. The international stage is ultimately an anarchy, and it's a dog-eat-dog world. Countries which make decisions based on morality rather than self-interest lose out to countries that focus on results.
- vikiomega9 10y agoSo why don't people call it as it? Anything that has to do with foreign politics always sounds like propaganda to me or some weird sense of moral superiority.
- mikeash 10y agoBecause it works to sway the masses. If you think you should take some action, telling your people that it's moral will help get support for it. If you think some other country shouldn't take some action, telling their people it's immoral will hurt support.
- dTal 10y agoSounds like there'd be a fair amount of morality in international politics, if democracy were given a chance instead of unilateral action by shady oligarchs with psychopathic ideas about how "it's a dog-eat-dog world".
- mikeash 10y agoI object to calling that psychopathic. Acknowledging the nature of reality is never wrong. It would only be psychopathic if you not only acknowledged it, but celebrated it.
- Symmetry 10y ago"The nature of reality" is that one must act in a certian way? You're confusing the normative with the descriptive.
- mikeash 10y agoI'm saying that countries do act this way. I'm also saying that countries which don't tend to lose out to those that do. That's not the same as saying that countries must act this way, it merely explains why they all do.
- Symmetry 10y agoYou're saying that they do act that way but you're also objecting to calling leaders who act that way psychopathic. Choosing to do what is necessary for the continued victory of one's country even to the extent of assisting genocide is psychopathic. Good people, even if they "recognize the nature of reality" should allow themselves to be defeated rather than assist in genocide.
- mikeash 10y agoNo, I object to calling the idea that countries act this way psychopathic. Call the leaders whatever names you want, I'm not fond of any of them. But I saw that "psychopathic ideas" business as being aimed straight at me, not merely the people involved in international relations.
- Symmetry 10y agoOk. I interpreted the remark differently but I think both interpretations are credible.
- dTal 10y agoI'm sorry, I did not intend a personal slight. I understand that world leaders really do think like this, and I even think I somewhat understand why; I just think it's not an acceptable state of affairs because it's a horrible way to relate to the rest of the world, and what's worse it doesn't even match up to how the actual citizens of those countries feel. I would love to think that if we asked regular people their opinion more instead of isolating our leaders in ivory towers away from normal daily life and feeding them scary realpolitik stories, we'd have a higher-trust global society, but (as you say) possibly this only works if everyone does it...
- vikiomega9 10y agoI feel like that might not be true. Morality is relative and by extension the democracy it embodies.
- Symmetry 10y agoThis view seems utterly at odds with what I've read of history. The individuals making the decisions about the actions of states take action for moral reasons all the time. Look at, I don't know, all the wars the UK got into in the 19th century through trying to stop the slave trade, half the decision making of the powers getting into World War I, the US's conspicuous failure to annex the territory it captured in WWII or countless other things. I certainly wouldn't say that any country is entirely selfless, that doesn't happen either. And there's a wide range of how different factors affect a country's balance between the two. But even Nazi Germany and Japan did things for racist, anti-communist, and (in Japan's case) anti-colonialist things at times that weren't in the interest of furthering the power of their states.
- mikeash 10y agoThe US's good treatment of conquered territories following WWII set it up for the global hegemony it enjoys to this day. The Nazis and Japanese lost the war in a devastating fashion in part because they behaved so stupidly due to their ideology. I'm not too familiar with the UK's fight against slavery, but I'd wager that their enemies were the ones who suffered the most from shutting down the slave trade.
- pjc50 10y ago> I'd wager that their enemies were the ones who suffered the most from shutting down the slave trade. This is .. not a position supported by historical evidence, and in fact it was the UK which suffered (stopped benefiting from) the slave trade.
- tomjen3 10y agoThats how I would expect it to happen to, but then I live in a tiny country in Scandinavia which would have no chance at all of defending itself if didn't have an alliance with the US. An alliance the US gets almost nothing out of. The US is committed to defending Taiwan as if it was its native soil, despite it being basically on the other side of the planet and posing no significant strategic benefit. The US has such treaties with a ton of countries (http://www.state.gov/s/l/treaty/collectivedefense/ http://www.state.gov/s/l/treaty/collectivedefense/). Despite this the US "wins" the international relations game completely (if we go with the KvK definition that war is politics by other means and its aim is to enforce its will on somebody else).