4 ms·
I really dislike this trend on putting high importance on specific words usage as a means of confronting an issue. This is hardly low hanging fruit category yet
by dmix 10y ago
I really dislike this trend on putting high importance on specific words usage as a means of confronting an issue. This is hardly low hanging fruit category yet it's given so much attention on social media. The primary reasons that I believe this is wrongheaded:
a) People understand the context of the word. This whole campaign is predicated on people not being able to understand context when words are used, which is denying a basic common sense human attribute.
Virginia Department of Transportation is right:
> The officials at the Virginia Department of Transportation that they stop using “accident,” he received a note saying that drivers are familiar and comfortable with the word. Virginia officials also wrote that drivers might not consider a minor incident to be a “crash,” and so the change could be confusing
b) As the above quote also points out, that by obsessing over specific meanings of words then words that currently have multiple degrees of meaning depending on context are then recategorized to just mean one specific thing. Then you potentially lose something as a result and have to find even more words to fill the void. So we have to spend even more time obsessing over which words we use, when everyone already understood what was meant in the first place.
c) It's almost always the case that time would be better spent on so many other things. It's just easier to sit at home and complain at peoples use of language then it is to teach people to be better drivers.
It feels good to tell someone they have been doing x wrong. It makes good headlines because it's something we all can relate to. It's surprising. It's a simple thing to add to a checklist of things to regulate/control in organizations. This is why I think it's such a popular strategy that people take. Sadly it's not a very useful one.
- m0nty 10y ago> denying a basic common sense human attribute Unfortunately, this kind of thing can end up in court where "common sense" has even less meaning than usual. "Your honour, the police have already categorised this as an accident, so clearly there is no case to answer." This has happened in court in the UK, which is why the police here talk of RTCs (road traffic collisions) rather than RTAs (accidents). "Collision" also applies to any kind of "accident", more so than "crash".
- lmm 10y agoI think it's precisely the fact that people are "familiar and comfortable" with frequent preventable deaths that's the issue here. I agree that words are not important, actions are. At the same time I hope this is a step along the path towards holding drivers responsible for deaths they cause.
- snowwrestler 10y agoEither different words have different meanings, or they don't. If the meaning of a word is delivered primarily by its context, then there should be little objection to a straight replacement of "accident" with "crash"--since the context would be unchanged. If the meaning of a word is carried by the word itself, then you have to consider what accident means to most people: something that just happens, unavoidably, despite everyone's best intentions to avert it. But that does not actually describe the vast majority of car crashes. Most car crashes actually could have been averted. > The officials at the Virginia Department of Transportation that they stop using “accident,” he received a note saying that drivers are familiar and comfortable with the word. Yes, of course they are. That's the problem. People are too familiar and comfortable with the concept of cars crashing and causing injuries and death. The whole point of changing the way we talk about things is to change the way people think about things--their expectations. > It's just easier to sit at home and complain at peoples use of language then it is to teach people to be better drivers. There's no reason to choose, here. Both can happen.