7 ms·
I think this would have been a good question to answer. I recognize that Nick might be uncomfortable answering it. There are always questions around how "succe
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I think this would have been a good question to answer. I recognize that Nick might be uncomfortable answering it.
There are always questions around how "successful" employees are versus founders, and the situations all are a bit different. For example, in my experience I was employee #9 at GolfWeb (a startup in 1995) and my stock was worthless when CBS Interactive acquired the company, I was employee 1990 at Sun and at Sun's peak valuation in 1998 the total stock I had owned would have been worth over $10M (I didn't have it all at that point :-), having sold much of it for mundane things like down payments on houses and cars and such, but the point was the equity from Sun was much higher than it was from the "startup" and I wasn't a founder in either case) People who joined Google (or Apple!) in 2009 and are still there, probably did quite well on their stock if they held it.
To answer your more basic question, when you exercise your option at a non-publicly traded startup, your shares will be covered by the purchase contract that is included in the option. That contract can (and often does) restrict to whom you can re-sell those securities. As the company keeps the books on who actually owns the shares, they have a lot of control over them. For example they can refuse to transfer them to a buyer when you and the buyer approach them to settle your transaction.
And since there aren't a lot of liquidity events where employees can sell stocks these days, its an interesting question to explore.
- pm90 10y agoWhy are there such restriction on who can sell and to whom? And these sound really arbitrary: seems like the company can deny the sale of shares for any reason whatsoever.
- mooreds 10y ago> Why are there such restriction on who can sell and to whom? Why? Power and incentives. Power because when you have equity you are an owner, and founders and investors of private companies (and public companies for that matter) are concerned with who shares ownership. Incentives because if they restrict your options, you might stay longer and work harder to have a liquidity event.
- Retric 10y agoThere is a way around this where you sell options on the future sale of your stock. But as you might guess this lowers your sale price.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoIf your securities are not publicly traded there is no legal way to sell options on them. About the closest you could come would be some sort of proposition bet which is illegal in pretty much every state of the USA. And as I mentioned before, at the end of the day your "stock" in a privately funded company, is simply a ledger entry on a spreadsheet somewhere. And without the active participation of the CFO/Controller/accountant/and-or/Counsel there is no way to durably transfer ownership to anyone. That said, I don't doubt that you might find someone with excess cash who would be willing to front you the money to exercise your stock and pay the taxes and a perhaps a premium on the stock, for a promissory note to hand them over the stock at the time it becomes publicly traded. That too it illegal under securities law but would be fairly difficult to prosecute.
- otterley 10y agoI think you interviewed me at GolfWeb! You made me an offer there but I declined and went to iPass. Small world.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThe SF Bay area is exceptionally small in many ways.