5 ms·
Logical fallacy. Just because there are counterexamples doesn't mean a claim is false. If I say "humans eat meat", the claim is not false because I found a ve
by colordrops 10y ago
Logical fallacy. Just because there are counterexamples doesn't mean a claim is false. If I say "humans eat meat", the claim is not false because I found a vegetarian.
- asdfologist 10y agoErr, you're the one making the logical fallacy. The parent said "There are never any consequences for the individual government employees who break the law" and the counterexamples disprove that. "X never happens" is false if I find examples of X happening, by definition of "never". QED.
- colordrops 10y agoThat's just word play and purposefully misunderstanding the parent's likely meaning. It would make no sense for the meaning to be exacting like a mathematical proposition, in that there are literally NEVER any consequences. When speaking of an entity as large as heterogeneous as the government, you can't make such specific claims, so the obvious meaning was "for the most part" or "in general".
- nerdponx 10y agoYes, it actually does mean the claim is false.
- prutschman 10y agoIn ordinary English discourse "humans eat meat" is an existential proposition, with some possible claim of frequency, commonality, or representativeness. It's not a universal proposition; that's conveyed by "all humans eat meat" or "humans always eat meat" or some such.
- colordrops 10y agoDo you really think the OP's claim was universal, when talking about something non-monolithic like the government? The implied meaning is one of frequency, not absolutes.
- imaginenore 10y agoThe OP wrote "never", which is an absolute, and only requires one counterexample to be proven false. What was implied is just you making sh*t up.
- colordrops 10y agoInformal natural language is in most cases not literal. For example, I assume you don't mean that I'm actually creating feces.