4 ms·
I am guessing it will be more like an engine rebuild on an engine for a 777 - tear down and xray of key parts. The turbopumps and compressors in a rocket engine
by walrus01 10y ago
I am guessing it will be more like an engine rebuild on an engine for a 777 - tear down and xray of key parts. The turbopumps and compressors in a rocket engine are very sensitive, high precision parts.
- Neeek 10y agoIsn't that the kind of detailed tear down that forced the shuttle in to being more expensive than traditional systems?
- mikeash 10y agoIndeed. Hopefully SpaceX can do less, since their hardware is more robust. The Space Shuttle engines were driven at the edge of failure because they needed every last bit of performance. SpaceX's designs tend to go for robustness at the cost of efficiency, so they ought to need less work.
- walrus01 10y agoPossibly of interest, the giant engines used in the Delta IV Heavy have 80% less part count than an SSME, but they were never intended to be human-rated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RS-68 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RS-68 Not that it has brought launch costs down much, considering how the ULA loves their juicy government contracts for billion dollar NSA/NRO satellite launches. IIRC the Falcon 9 engine design is the opposite of an RS-68, which is the "one huge fucking engine" design philosophy, which is why a falcon9 has a cluster of many smaller engines and is tolerant of an individual engine failure during launch.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> IIRC the Falcon 9 engine design is the opposite of an RS-68, which is the "one huge fucking engine" design philosophy, which is why a falcon9 has a cluster of many smaller engines and is tolerant of an individual engine failure during launch. Indeed! A Falcon 9 mission has lost an engine mid-flight, and the flight system adjusted the burn duration on the fly to compensate: http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/spacex-s-non-fatal-failure http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/spacex-s-non-fatal-failure
- grinich 10y agoPlus for the orbiter refurb they had to check the entire heat shield, flight control systems, crew habitats, etc. etc. Easier when it's just the rocket + fuel tank.
- mikeash 10y agoIndeed. The heat shield in particular was extremely delicate and tended to get beaten up a lot coming back, so that was a huge amount of work to get ready for the next flight.
- XorNot 10y agoThe entire spaceplane concept drastically complicated things. Capsule-based return systems are vastly simpler to operate, which is despite everything the Soyuz has been flying continuously this whole time.
- grinich 10y agoDownside is you can't capture enemy satellites and return them to ground for study/reverse engineering.
- walrus01 10y agoThis is how NASA got many billions of funding from the USAF for part of the space shuttle program - look through the list of flights in the 1980s where the payload was an unspecified national security satellite. The capability was promised and it was funded for it - but almost never used. The actual ability to grab a big thing and return it was hardly ever used, such as the LDEF mission. It doesn't help that a huge percentage of Soviet satellites that they might want to have grabbed would have been unreachable from a space shuttle launch site (IMINT satellites in 90 degree inclination polar orbits, satellites in molniya orbits, radar naval observation satellites in MEO orbits) all beyond the orbit/delta-V capabilities of a shuttle mission. And of course geostationary orbit where no human has ever gone.
- gpderetta 10y agoAlso, every shuttle flight is human-rated. I would guess that SpaceX wouldn't use "refurbished" engines for manned flights, while they could cut down on the thoroughness of checks for lower value payloads.
- mikeash 10y agoThat seems likely at first, but it'll be really exciting when that switches around and reused engines are the preferred choice for manned flights since they've been proven. After all, you never put passengers on the very first flight of a new airliner. You test it out first, and then once it's demonstrated you start using it for real. We'll know that reusable rockets have really made it when the first flight of a new one is done as a test flight without risking any lives, and only afterwards is it put into normal use.
- ceejayoz 10y ago> The turbopumps and compressors in a rocket engine are very sensitive, high precision parts. SpaceX deliberately engineered lower performance, higher reliability engines. Think minivan instead of Ferrari. The SSMEs were genuine marvels of engineering, but that came at significant cost to reusability.
- grinich 10y agoAlso I think 2 of them can flame out and Falcon can still achieve the primary mission. Minivan with an extra tire.
- JshWright 10y agoThat depends very much on what the primary mission is. For LEO missions like the CRS flights, then sure. For GTO launches, they probably don't have the margin needed.
- skykooler 10y agoFor a GTO mission the Falcon 9 can have a single engine out and still complete the primary mission.
- vanattab 10y agoIs this still true at max GTO payload weight?
- walrus01 10y agoIt might depend where in the flight the engine fails, assuming we're talking about the first stage. If I had to guess, a GTO mission (placing a payload in a 36,000 km x 350 km elliptical orbit) could still be successful with an engine failure in the first stage after 65-75% of the fuel had been burned, and the vehicle was generally lighter, allowing the burn time to be adjusted longer to reach the same velocity at the point of first stage cutoff and separation to ignition of the second stage. But this guess comes from dozens of hours spent playing Kerbal Space Program....
- dasmoth 10y agoThe first few, probably yes. But I'm pretty convinced they're trying to avoid this. The engines have been test-fired many, many, times (30 starts is a figure that has been mentioned a few times. Remember that the first recovered stage (Orbcom) was returned to the launch pad and went through a static fire just a few weeks after landing. It seems clear to me that they've got their eye on reasonably-quick-turnaround reuse.
- grinich 10y agoI bet they're less concerned with # of firings and more with fatigue/wear from atmosphere reentry. Very hard to test on ground.
- dasmoth 10y agoThey've now got 45 intact engines back, from a variety of re-entry regimes. We know they've done an all-up static fire. Several of the returned stages have had engines removed and I imagine some of these have been tested. If there's a major problem, they already know about it.