2 ms·
As it happens, I have a proof that 1 == 2. Of course my proof involves a step that involves division by zero, but if it's legal to define undefined results, the
by mcv 10y ago
As it happens, I have a proof that 1 == 2. Of course my proof involves a step that involves division by zero, but if it's legal to define undefined results, then why can't I do that if it helps my proof?
Because as far as I can tell (with my admittedly limited understanding of mathematics), that's basically what's going on here: they define the result of 1-1+1-1+1-1... to be 1/2, which it can of course never be. The result is never 1/2; it's either 1 or 0. Taken to infinity, the only reasonable definition for that sum is undefined. If I can say that 1/2 is fine too, then I should also be able to attach my own definition to 1/0.
Also, if string theory really relies on such questionable mathematical steps, then that would make me question string theory even more. As far as I understand, string theory makes no testable predictions, which suggests to me that no results based on this questionable mathematical trick have been experimentally verified. If there is some real, experimentally verified physics that relies on the sum of all natural numbers to be -1/12, then I'd love to be corrected (though I doubt I'll understand it).