8 ms·
Justice department 'uses aged computer system to frustrate Foia requests'
- HappyFunGuy 10y agoThey're using "aged people" to frustrate as well. If there was some more meritocracy, or better pay, we might be able to get some new, technically useful, blood in there. Personal accountability wouldn't hurt either. It works for more than business and families.
- rmason 10y agoDon't blame the people, aged or not. This is being driven from the top down.
- tanderson92 10y agoYou are implying that meritocracy or better pay would go towards better results for the FOIA requester. An equally likely interpretation is that the meritocracy is delivering the desired results from the government's perspective of interests.
- DominikR 10y agoI'd say that most energetic people with skills would never waste their time with such nonsense. They can make real money in the private sector.
- jlgaddis 10y agoNot everyone is solely motivated by money.
- douche 10y agoThe rest of us like having a roof over our heads, food in our bellies, and our student loan payments made on time.
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoIt is possible to have both.
- DominikR 10y agoIt is, but spending your energy on researching and implementing the most effective way to annoy and obstruct people that are trying to exercise their rights? Generally people that could work wherever they want and choose to not chase after money will probably go for something that has a high moral value (or is a noble cause) to them, like helping the poor. But not something like this. I'd imagine that the only thing they might get out if this is political power which should translate into money.
- zeddie 10y ago"In 2014 total federal compensation averaged $119,934, or 78 percent more than the private-sector average of $67,246." http://www.downsizinggovernment.org/federal-worker-pay http://www.downsizinggovernment.org/federal-worker-pay
- DominikR 10y agoWe are talking about the best of the best, the cream of the crop when we are talking about Meritocracy, not the private sector average. I'm saying these people wouldn't be interested in wasting their time doing such nonsense and be on top of that poorly compensated. $119,934 is ridiculously low pay for top performers.
- HappyFunGuy 10y agoYou are right, I forgot the adversarial nature of these requests. I am not sure less paid, less meritous people would work better though.
- jocro 10y agoI generally agree, but when the hiring and management of the persons processing the requests is carried out by the same parties interested in delaying the process, the principle goes untested.
- cloudjacker 10y agoI like how the replacement system costed $425,000,000 The tech company told them on site deploys would be $424,550,000 more expensive
- mungoid 10y agoYeah I find it hilarious as a contract developer how just because it's government software that means you can charge like 200 times more for essentially the same software any other client could get for like 1 million at most. I've been doing contract development for a little over 10 years now and even the most complex projects were never even remotely that expensive. And Im sure I've probably written at least 85% of the same functionality of whatever that software does. Hell, I'm sure there is probably open source software that does similar
- NobleSir 10y agoSo glad I pay taxes
- frankydp 10y agoPrices of that nature usually include 10-20 year service contracts and onsite maintainers, to include hardware. Not that the prices are not still inflated, but the reality of running a contractually 99.99% uptime, multi decade, and completely backwards compatible platform is not trivial, or anything south of multi millions of dollars at the federal scale especially.
- StanislavPetrov 10y agoThe unfortunate fact is that government officials, whether at the DOJ, the FBI, or any other agency have absolutely no incentive to follow either the letter or the spirit of the law. There are never any consequences for the individual government employees who break the law, so there is no reason for them to follow it. What's worse is that the only government officials who are ever held accountable for violations of law or policy are whistleblowers who shine light on wrongdoing. When the law ceases to be a social contract under which we all agree to operate and be equally judged it loses its moral authority. Without moral authority law carries no more weight then the threats of violence wielded by those with the most power and society falls apart.
- x3n0ph3n3 10y ago> When the law ceases to be a social contract Law has never and will likely never be a social contract. It is always enforced with violence, which encourages compliance. Give up Hobbes' misguided concept already as it will never help you make predictions about or explanations for how people behave.
- Dr_tldr 10y agoIn order to be effectively condescending, you'll need at least a 9th grade level of knowledge on the topic. That you were able to mix up two very different theorists (possibly 3 if you were thinking of Rousseau) implies you're not actually very familiar with any of them. I'm assigning you this, have it done by Friday: http://www.cresskillboe.k12.nj.us/cresskill/Schools/Cresskill%20High%20School/Teacher%20Websites/Kline,%20Stephen/World%20History/Hobbes%20and%20Locke%20Essay.pdf http://www.cresskillboe.k12.nj.us/cresskill/Schools/Cresskil...
- x3n0ph3n3 10y agoI did not mix up any theorists. Hobbes wrote about the social contract ~100 years before Rousseau did and 30 years before Locke. For all intents and purposes he invented the concept. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_contract#Thomas_Hobbes.27_Leviathan_.281651.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_contract#Thomas_Hobbes....
- Asparagirl 10y agoOh man, is this relevant to my interests. An organization I founded is currently in a state-level Freedom of Information law fight -- using the Missouri Sunshine Law -- against the Missouri Department of Health and Senior Services, asking for two database dumps as CSV files. The databases have millions of records covering decades of data, but only about four columns, so this should take a couple of hours to export, tops. Of course, we're willing to pay for the USB flash drive to put the files on, and cover any unusual labor costs to do the export. The good news is that the Department has agreed that we should have the legal right to this data. The bad news is that the Missouri Dept of Health is claiming with a straight face that they can only retrieve one day's worth of data at a time from their mainframe, and must re-run the work job for each and every subsequent day's data. They claim that it is impossible for their software to select for a date range. And therefore, they have quoted my organization a price of about one million dollars and 2.6 years to select and deliver our data. Shot: https://mobile.twitter.com/ReclaimTheRecs/status/746447360926986240 https://mobile.twitter.com/ReclaimTheRecs/status/74644736092... Chaser: https://mobile.twitter.com/ReclaimTheRecs/status/751161070513889280 https://mobile.twitter.com/ReclaimTheRecs/status/75116107051... (Don't worry, we have a good Sunshine Law lawyer and he is as outraged/amused at this bullshit as we are.)
- HappyFunGuy 10y agoHave them offline and copy the raw drive/tape to trusted 3rd party (as they must do regularly for backups anwyway) and have that 3rd party query the data. Or if the data is old enough, have them just copy the backup to the 3rd party. This should eliminate any query expense they would have had (as it's been replaced by raw data copy expense.) And the 3rd party is to protect the data you're not supposed to get.
- shawn-butler 10y agoI would spend the money to convince or "partner" with the paper of record in the region to run a story on how out of touch they are with technology. Unfortunately most journalists won't do it for fear of losing their "access". Properly embarrass the right politician near an election and you get results. Apart from changing the leadership in an actual election that's about your only hope.
- MilnerRoute 10y agoAt Slashdot someone pointed out that the student requested a search that should've pulled up his own earlier FOIA requests -- and didn't -- thus proving their system was inadequate. https://yro.slashdot.org/story/16/07/17/0224251/is-the-doj-using-obsolete-software-to-subvert-foia-requests https://yro.slashdot.org/story/16/07/17/0224251/is-the-doj-u...
- wwalser 10y agoThis was also mentioned in the linked article.
- rrmm 10y agoTo be fair, the government's computer systems really are just that crappy. Technical debt and obsolete systems that still kind-of-sorta work are always the last things to be addressed in budgets. There is also no incentive for the government to do anything other than 'try' in the most perfunctory manner possible. One solution would be to make a separate entity responsible whose performance is judged based on what they can actually dig up (of course someone has to get the funds and resources for these people to work). There is no incentive to build systems that are optimized for FOIA requests (ie enough hardware to search the data, or data indexed in ways that make it easily possible). I doubt servicing FOIA requests is super high up on the spec list when a system is designed. There are also legitimate issues concerning cost recovery: think of it in terms of paying for someone to spin up new instances to hit multi-TB databases for a couple of days, then paying someone else to see if the results are responsive, if they're actually releasable in terms of security, privacy, etc. And then you have to deal with the less legitimate requests that come along. I think serving FOIA requests is a core part of the government (both ideally and by law) and resources should be spent accordingly. Finally, there are government officials, especially at the state and local level, who use the above excuses to make it hard for people to find out what they're up to. The worst effect of the issues listed above is providing these people with cover and plausible excuses which are used to stonewall legitimate investigation by the people they serve.
- pnathan 10y agoThis is, I think, the best way to frame it: the systems are actually that bad, and bad actors can misuse the bad systems. That said, I'd be very curious to hear about people in govtech about how this plays out in your municipality.
- aestetix 10y agoI think this is less about a deliberate attempt to frustrate FOIA, and more about lazy government workers who see no reason to fix something that isn't broken (in their opinion).
- pc86 10y agoIt is departmental policy to do the most limited search possible in an attempt to return as few results as possible. That is the very definition of a deliberate attempt to frustrate both the letter and the spirit of FOIA.
- godgod 10y agoThere is no doubt in my mind. This is an out of control criminal government working against the will of the American people. I can assure you as someone who has worked on software projects sold to the federal government (FBI, CIA, Pentagon) that this is a deliberate attempt to stonewall FOIA requests. It's 2016..government systems are too big and complex to NOT have efficient search software. The big agencies NEED to be able to search through all their records quickly and more importantly, correctly. The fact that they are using antiquated systems is deliberate.