3 ms·
> An instruction set is a language of commands given to a machine. Nobody can patent, copyright, or otherwise own a language or an instruction set. This is wro
by bitwize 10y ago
> An instruction set is a language of commands given to a machine. Nobody can patent, copyright, or otherwise own a language or an instruction set.
This is wrong. Intel owns patents which protect the Itanium ISA. Non-Intel Itanium implementations would infringe on the patents, not that anyone would want to make one.
- PeCaN 10y agoIntel also has patents on many x86_64 extensions and AMD has patents on x86_64 itself. I believe MMX expired recently, so a Pentium III level CPU could be implemented without infringing on ISA patents. Hitachi still has patents on SH4 (though they expire this year). IBM has patents on POWER8. Oracle and Fujitsu have patents on SPARC. etc. Incidentally, I believe HP also owns some of the Itanium patents.
- new299 10y agoI'd love to see a detailed write-up on how an ISA is protected. I've never really understood what protects the x86 instruction set. I'd always assumed there were patents covering implementation details which would make an effective implementation extremely difficult. Can you really patent a list of instructions?
- Taniwha 10y agoIntel's ISA is protected by fear of its army of lawyers, something from which no small company could (financially) survive a head on attack. I worked on an x86 clone 20 years back, we analysed Intel's patents in depth to make sure we were safe, the biug one for us was Intel's segmentation/MMU patent - they essentially had patented segmentation followed by (unrelated) mmu processing - there was obvious prior art (cough 360, cough) but that's a bit of crap shoot, I came up with a brilliant way around this, only to discover a patent from someone else in the process of doing an x86 clone (Exponential I think). In the end we conflated our segmentation hardware and our TLBs effectively bypassing the core of Intel's patent You can't patent a list of instructions, you can copyright a bunch of mnemnomics
- new299 10y agoThat's really interesting thanks! I wonder if the army of lawyers protection also holds for ARM. Or perhaps there licenses are cheap enough that people don't care.
- willvarfar 10y agoThe article explains: > Though you can not patent an instruction set, you can patent machines and methods that are necessary to implement a particular unusual instruction that is part of the instruction set. That legally blocks competitors from creating a fully compatible clone of your processor. The author is making a very clear and correct distinction. It continues: > There are four instructions in the MIPS-I instruction set that were protected by one US patent, 4,814,976. These instructions, lwl, lwr, swl, and swr are known as the unaligned load and store instructions.