3 ms·
(Apologies, in advance, for so long a quotation.) Your comment that the "the pornwhackers were awesome to drink with. When you stare into the abyss for 8 hours
by mistersquid 10y ago
(Apologies, in advance, for so long a quotation.)
Your comment that the "the pornwhackers were awesome to drink with. When you stare into the abyss for 8 hours a day, you develop some excellent coping mechanisms" reminded me of an amazing article published on The Verge and written by Catherine Buni and Soraya Chemaly. [0] (The article was featured here on HN 91 days ago.[1])
The article examines the psychological cost of content moderation and reading it helped me appreciate even more the difficult work content moderators perform to make the web a better place. (Hats off to dang, sctb and others whose user handles I don't know.)
Anyway, here's a teaser from "The Secret Rules of the Internet" in case you missed it the first time it came around.
> Mora-Blanco sat next to Misty Ewing-Davis, who, having been
> on the job a few months, counted as an old hand. On the
> table before them was a single piece of paper, folded in
> half to show a bullet-point list of instructions: Remove
> videos of animal abuse. Remove videos showing blood. Remove
> visible nudity. Remove pornography. Mora-Blanco recalls her
> teammates were a "mish-mash" of men and women; gay and
> straight; slightly tipped toward white, but also Indian,
> African-American, and Filipino. Most of them were friends,
> friends of friends, or family. They talked and made jokes,
> trying to make sense of the rules. "You have to find humor,"
> she remembers. "Otherwise it’s just painful."
>
> Videos arrived on their screens in a never-ending queue.
> After watching a couple seconds apiece, SQUAD members
> clicked one of four buttons that appeared in the upper right
> hand corner of their screens: "Approve" — let the video
> stand; "Racy" — mark video as 18-plus; "Reject" — remove
> video without penalty; "Strike" — remove video with a
> penalty to the account. Click, click, click. But that day
> Mora-Blanco came across something that stopped her in her
> tracks.
>
> "Oh, God," she said.
>
> Mora-Blanco won’t describe what she saw that morning. For
> everyone’s sake, she says, she won’t conjure the
> staggeringly violent images which, she recalls, involved a
> toddler and a dimly lit hotel room.
[0] http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/13/11387934/internet-moderator-history-youtube-facebook-reddit-censorship-free-speech http://www.theverge.com/2016/4/13/11387934/internet-moderato...
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11500234 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11500234
EDIT: formatting
- apathy 10y agoWow, that's a terrific article. I don't think anyone at Xoom was in a position to make or break a revolution (maybe on Xoom International, but we'd delegated the whacking duties to the Italians on those sites, if memory serves). A lot of Xoomers moved on to Google later, and there it did start to become an issue, but all the pornwhackers had gone elsewhere (I took a detour but ended up at Google eventually anyways). It's crazy to me to think that YouTube was relearning many of the same things the pornwhackers had figured out ten years earlier. I guess there is an underbelly that Silicon Valley really, really doesn't want to talk about. When it mattered, though, YouTube did the right thing, even though it could have cost them the business. Little decisions like those can, in a small way, change the course of history. I don't think that sort of flashpoint ever happened at Xoom, because we didn't have any policies against bad taste. For all I know, Damien and his crew were gleefully promoting protest sites the whole time. If you ever have a chance to read Ted Rall's piece "A Cog In Satan's Bulldozer", do it. He touches on bits of it here and there in http://comiczine-fa.com/interviews/ted-rall http://comiczine-fa.com/interviews/ted-rall, but the real thing is mindbendingly great -- truly, almost all cynics are disillusioned idealists. When I worked for google from 2003-2004, it was as close as I've seen to a corporation with a pervasive conscience (people really did ask whether a purchasing decision was "evil"). It seems like even their ideals have slipped. I went back to school after a while. Now I design clinical trials for kids with cancer. It doesn't pay as much but at least when I die I won't say "gee, I sure sold a lot of ads!"