4 ms·
Isn't the plane's auto-pilot pretty much a pilot assistance system designed to keep the plane at the specified altitude and follow a straight line (heading bug
by prostoalex 10y ago
Isn't the plane's auto-pilot pretty much a pilot assistance system designed to keep the plane at the specified altitude and follow a straight line (heading bug on older systems, GPS coordinates in the flight plan on modern ones)?
It's not designed for collision avoidance, runway taxiing, emergency situations, short/soft field landings or departures. It's occasionally used for normal landings (according to https://www.quora.com/How-often-are-commercial-flights-landed-using-autopilot https://www.quora.com/How-often-are-commercial-flights-lande...) but it doesn't seem prevalent.
- detaro 10y agoI think an important difference is in the necessary reaction time. Situations in which a plane flying at altitude under automatic control suddenly requires a sub-second reaction by the pilots are extremely rare, in traffic they happen way more often. Obstacles don't suddenly pop up in mid-air, and a lot of infrastructure makes sure other traffic is nicely separated at all times. Thus a plane actually can do most of a flight automatically and it's okay if it has to fall back on not fully attentive humans in edge-cases, because there is some time for error-correction. The car equivalent might be if highways had lanes separated by walls and cars could detect obstacles a few hundred meters away, then taking the hands of the wheel wouldn't be an issue. On real-world streets, you can't be as hands-off as you could be in a plane at 35,000 feet.
- sitharus 10y agoYou are correct, but I'm constantly surprised by how many people think the pilot taxies to the runway and pushes 'go'. Tesla autopilot works like an aeroplane autopilot actually does, not how people seem to think it does.
- tmd83 10y agoAs I was saying down the thread, I think its fair to say that Tesla use the autopilot naming because it sounds catchy and better than the terms rest of the world use. I think its a conscious marketing decision to make their look better when its probably not. Everyone in the airlines industry use the same term and the people involved are too informed/trained for their to be confusion. Tesla's branding vastly different from the market is meant to confuse by making them sound better. Thats what they should be penalized for.
- tmptmp 10y ago>>Isn't the plane's auto-pilot pretty much a pilot assistance system designed to keep the plane at the specified altitude and follow a straight line (heading bug on older systems, GPS coordinates in the flight plan on modern ones)? Your plane autopilot analogy fails in a crucial manner: First, to get a license to fly a plane, you have to undergo a much more rigorous training and much more stringent scrutiny than what an ordinary Joe/Jane undergoes to get a license to drive the Tesla car. Another, a plane pilot does not ride (fly) his/her plane as much as our ordinary Joe/Jane drives his/her car. Yet another, there are assistant pilots in plane and the list goes on. The foolish management at Tesla should have labeled their assistance system just what it is 'semi automatic assistance system' and they could have been slightly more prudent by clearly mentioning the "dangerous" components of it upfront, rather than cleaning the shit now. It's a sad affair. I had/have more hopes from Tesla. But they should abandon their foolish autopilot thingy, to begin with now.
- vehementi 10y agoHow is that relevant, much less crucial?
- tmptmp 10y agoWhat is "that"? If you are referring to the parent's analogy, then yes, I said his/her analogy fails. Tesla is not making it mandatory to their buyers go through a serious and rigorous training to use their so tauted auto-pilot, which is a freaking dangerous thing as it's far from being a autopilot and it's only half-baked semi-auto-pilot potentially riddled with a lot of hidden AI bugs, that their machine learning team may find hard to even locate. The airplane autopilot analogy, the parent is making to justify Tesla's claims fails miserably, IMO, anyway. But if a lawsuit gets filed, Tesla will have a very hard time justifying this type of claim. Another important thing (from their business success point of view), is: this incidence and their shameless justification of the faults in their so-tauted autopilot will tarnish (already has tarnished to some extent) their image in the public. They can't just now show their fucking warnings they originally published in fine-print and got the unsuspecting users signed, and expect the users to happily purchase their now-perceived death-traps. Competitors just have to point this death-trap autopilot feature of Tesla to turn a potential buyer in their favor.
- dingaling 10y ago"The Avionic Flight Control System (AFCS) provides manual or automatic modes of control throughout the total flight envelope from take-off to landing." Lockheed L1011, 1972. Flight trials led to demonstration of a fully automated trans-continental flight, from rest to rest. Pilots did not touch the controls. Incidentally also the only airliner which was certified for operational Cat IIIC autoland, with zero visibility. Frequently used at London-heathrow but needed a ground-control radar to guide the pilots to the gate once the aircraft had stopped itself on the runway. Aircraft autopilots are technically capable of completely controlling the flight but are restricted from doing so by technical provision ( e.g. lack of rearward-facing ILS / MLS for departure ) or regulatory caution ( e.g. not executing TCAS collision-resolution automatically, even though every FBW Airbus can do this ).
- Animats 10y agoThe technology exists, but there's reluctance to give it too much authority. That's changing, especially in the military. Full-authority automated ground collision avoidance is now on many F-16 fighters. It's a retrofit, and 440 aircraft had been retrofitted by 2015. First avoided crash was in 2015.[1] Here's a test where the pilot goes into a hard turn and releases the controls, and the automated GCAS, at the last second, flips the plane upright and goes into a steep climb.[2] Because this is for fighters, it doesn't take over until it absolutely has to. The pilot can still fly low and zoom through mountain passes. The first users of this system, the Swedish air force, said "you can't fly any lower". It's a development of Lockheed's Skunk Works. This technology is supposed to go into the F-35, but it's not in yet. This may eventually filter down to commercial airliners, but they'd need more capable radars that can profile the ground. This is not GPS and map based; it's looking at the real world. [1] http://aviationweek.com/defense/ground-collision-avoidance-system-saves-first-f-16-syria http://aviationweek.com/defense/ground-collision-avoidance-s... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPr2LWctwYQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPr2LWctwYQ
- unclebucknasty 10y agoBut, Tesla's system is designed for collision avoidance, automatic braking, etc. There is absolutely a problem that they call it "Autopilot", as it brings to mind the airplane meaning of the term. But, it matches neither the common use case for airplane autopilot systems nor the common perception--right or wrong--of what those autopilot systems do. So, Tesla enjoys the cachet that comes with that latter perception, while relegating the true description to the "fine print" of the owner's manual.
- varjag 10y agoAre we going to fight the colloquial use at this point? The redux of "hacker" vs "cracker"? If the public consistently misunderstands the term and their life depends on it, the term has to be changed period. This is no place for semantic nazism.