4 ms·
> Of course, given the collective ingenuity of the cartel’s engineers and scientists, it should have been possible to design a lightbulb that was both bright an
by ars 10y ago
> Of course, given the collective ingenuity of the cartel’s engineers and scientists, it should have been possible to design a lightbulb that was both bright and long-lived.
And not energy efficient.
The article lightly touches on it, but the physical reality is that the better the electrical efficiency the less time the bulb lasts.
It's a tradeoff that has not changed in 100 years.
So yes, the cartel did mandate 1,000 hours - but they also saved untold amounts of electricity over then next 100 years.
- _ph_ 10y agoThis is the one big thing missing in most reports about the lightbulb lifetime. Even consumers profited via power-savings from this lifetime agreement.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoSeems like an important point, but I think it would also be worth to see a comparison of energy saved by end users through increased efficiency, and energy used on additional manufacturing, distribution and sales caused by the need to replace bulbs more often. This is a general point about all "eco" technologies too - a device is not "eco-friendly" if it's total manufacturing and distribution energy costs are higher than the "eco-unfriendly" alternative.
- yuubi 10y agoConveniently, the retail price includes the direct expenditures on energy to make and transport the item to the store. I recall the electricity rate being around 0.08 USD/kWh around here a while back, so 1000h of 100W consumption would cost $8. I don't remember exactly what 100W plain light bulbs cost, but it certainly was a lot less than that.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI'm talking about energy costs and environmental damage, not the dollar price. Contrary to popular opinion, the retail price rarely if ever captures the environmental impact of a product.