3 ms·
>In After Snowden, a book I recently edited, I recommended that Snowden be tried by a federal court in Hawaii where his crime was committed; that he plead guilt
by slg 10y ago
>In After Snowden, a book I recently edited, I recommended that Snowden be tried by a federal court in Hawaii where his crime was committed; that he plead guilty of misappropriating government property which he admits he did; that the government in a public sentencing procedure present its claims of all the damages resulting from Snowden’s misconduct (in camera if there is good cause); and that Snowden be allowed to present his claims for justification for his conduct, if not condonation of it.
>The U.S. allows no public interest defense to criminal charges, as many countries do, but it should be considered as a possible future reform, along with more protective whistleblower laws.
>The federal judge should then sentence Snowden according to prevailing standards for relevant criminal sanctions. It would be a public service for educational purposes if that proceeding were to be televised.
This seems like a perfectly reasonable approach, but I have the feeling that neither side would be satisfied with it. People are just too polarized on their view of him.
EDIT: And the multiple downvotes seem to prove me point. Most people here want Snowden to walk free on a full pardon yet even Snowden admits that he broke the law and deserves to face those charges in court. Meanwhile there are even more people elsewhere who feel he is a traitor that deserves the death penalty. Seemingly no one is open to compromise.
- tremon 10y agoMost people here want Snowden to walk free It can also mean that they don't expect Snowden would get a fair (or public) trial.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DoofusOfDeath 10y agoI'm open to compromise. If we're willing to hold everyone involved to the same standards, I would consider if fair to have Snowden face a hearing. However, that standard would also require numerous CIA agents to be tried and possibly hanged in Nürnberg-like trials, and for HRC to have a real possibility of 20-years-to-life in prison.
- rangibaby 10y agoWhat's wrong with that? Do the crime, do the time (that's what they taught us at school at least)
- rplst8 10y agoI disagree. People can be cleared fully of a crime when justified. Murder is illegal, unless it's self defense. I'd argue that what Snowden did was in defense of his country.
- chrisbennet 10y agoFrom the Wikipedia entry for Daniel Ellsberg (who leaked the Pentagon Papers). "Ellsberg was silenced before he could begin. According to Ellsberg, his "lawyer, exasperated, said he 'had never heard of a case where a defendant was not permitted to tell the jury why he did what he did.' The judge responded: well, you're hearing one now. And so it has been with every subsequent whistleblower under indictment".[21]"
- tomjen3 10y agoYou want me to drink a glass of poison, I want to drink a glass of water. We are not going to compromise on half a glass of poison.