6 ms·
Spy or whistleblower? Should Obama settle with Snowden?
- peterkelly 10y agoWhat about the crimes of the NSA - which are still ongoing? They are violating the US constitution, the universal declaration of human rights, and are breaking innumerable laws outside of the US, gaining unauthorised access to systems and information. It is the NSA, and their employees who have participated in carrying out these crimes, who we should be discussing punishment vs. pardon. Snowden is simply the messenger, nothing more.
- sschueller 10y agoWhat about Manning? Snowden is not in prison and has not been tortured.
- stephengillie 10y agoOne of the first points the article makes is how Snowden handled his data differently - working with reporters to curate a small fraction, not actually making any documents public.
- alexandercrohde 10y agoI think Obama knows history will look kindly on Snowden, and thus will look poorly on him. I think if Obama takes the 20 year view pardoning Snowden is his best chance at saving his legacy.
- argonaut 10y agoI'm pretty sure this entire affair will only be a tiny blip in Obama's historical legacy. Addendum: People on HN tend to vastly over-estimate the importance of privacy to the American populace. It's a very niche issue in politics.
- jkestner 10y agoOne of the things I've learned from this is that our security apparatus has a will of its own well beyond whoever's sitting in the White House. I doubt it will be closely tied with Obama, rather just lumped into the "Post 9/11 security state" chapter.
- adamnemecek 10y agoI feel like it's in the organization's DNAs. Take like J. Edgar Hoover.
- ralusek 10y agoIssues related to privacy in the digital era are going to be a huge part of humanity's future. Obama's historical legacy will be a small blip compared to the actions of individuals like Snowden.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoI think Obama's legacy will only be a blip.
- argonaut 10y agoYes, but this is true of most presidents.
- pbreit 10y agoI can't tell who you are referring to with your his and him.
- slg 10y ago>In After Snowden, a book I recently edited, I recommended that Snowden be tried by a federal court in Hawaii where his crime was committed; that he plead guilty of misappropriating government property which he admits he did; that the government in a public sentencing procedure present its claims of all the damages resulting from Snowden’s misconduct (in camera if there is good cause); and that Snowden be allowed to present his claims for justification for his conduct, if not condonation of it. >The U.S. allows no public interest defense to criminal charges, as many countries do, but it should be considered as a possible future reform, along with more protective whistleblower laws. >The federal judge should then sentence Snowden according to prevailing standards for relevant criminal sanctions. It would be a public service for educational purposes if that proceeding were to be televised. This seems like a perfectly reasonable approach, but I have the feeling that neither side would be satisfied with it. People are just too polarized on their view of him. EDIT: And the multiple downvotes seem to prove me point. Most people here want Snowden to walk free on a full pardon yet even Snowden admits that he broke the law and deserves to face those charges in court. Meanwhile there are even more people elsewhere who feel he is a traitor that deserves the death penalty. Seemingly no one is open to compromise.
- tremon 10y agoMost people here want Snowden to walk free It can also mean that they don't expect Snowden would get a fair (or public) trial.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DoofusOfDeath 10y agoI'm open to compromise. If we're willing to hold everyone involved to the same standards, I would consider if fair to have Snowden face a hearing. However, that standard would also require numerous CIA agents to be tried and possibly hanged in Nürnberg-like trials, and for HRC to have a real possibility of 20-years-to-life in prison.
- abraca 10y agoFor me, Hillary being let off changed how I view the Snowden affair. Before Hillary was let off without penalty, I thought that exposing or acting carelessly with classified information was a really big deal, that it seriously put American lives at risk - AND that others were doing a good job keeping that information under wraps, so breaches would be meaningful. Now it seems more like a political game. Hillary put us in more danger than Snowden. Punishing snowden is more about keeping info out of eyes of American public (i.e., Hillary's emails still need to be redacted, even though her server was likely hacked and info is almost certainly out there and America's ememies have it.) I hope that Hillary skating will set a precedent that will allow more whistleblowers to come forward to the public with information when needed without being penalized. Perhaps whistleblowers might use the strategy of releasing information 'unintentionally' and then use the Hillary defense.
- jeffdavis 10y agoAn interesting perspective, but I think the "Hillary Defense" is only available to a select few.
- 2close4comfort 10y agoWhat about Petraeus. For Snowden's acts to be still considered criminal is just hypocritical.
- adrenalinelol 10y agoHe should be in jail for the rest of his life (look at Chelsea Manning's sentence, if we are going to be consistent), but he was given a slap on the wrist: CIA directory trading secrets to his mistress? It sounds like a movie script, but now it's the public record.
- ajmurmann 10y agoWhat makes the difference even more stunning is that Snowden and Manning released information because they thought it was the right thing to do. Patreus did it knowing it was the wrong thing.
- jeffdavis 10y agoThis balanced kind of approach would have made sense for Aaron Schwarz, who did some minor things wrong that got blown out of proportion. But I don't think Snowden thinks he did anything wrong. He wasn't even reckless -- he allowed veteran reporters to handle the punblication to mitigate unintended consequences and act as a check on his own beliefs. So accepting punishment and allowing the US government to have the last word doesn't make sense to me.
- jlgaddis 10y agoSnowden has admitted he did wrong -- violating policy as well as breaking the law.
- themartorana 10y agoBy admitting he broke the law he doesn't let the counter-argument get stuck there. He'll do anything to force the debate to the information leaked and to keep it from talking points.
- staunch 10y agoHe violated policy and broke the law, but that doesn't mean he's done wrong.
- jlgaddis 10y agoRight, the former is what I meant. Whether something is "wrong" or not depends upon one's beliefs, of course. I should have been more clear.
- DoofusOfDeath 10y agoWhen you say he admitted doing "wrong", did he admit to actually making a moral transgression, or to just breaking the law? Because if you're equating breaking the law per se with a moral transgression, I think you'll need to hunker down for a pretty tough debate.
- 10y ago
- downandout 10y ago"The federal judge should then sentence Snowden according to prevailing standards for relevant criminal sanctions. The problem is that the prevailing standard in the US would be life in prison. I imagine that eventually Snowden will wind up serving a life sentence in the underground supermax facility in Florence, Colorado whether he comes voluntarily or not - Russia will eventually use him as a bargaining chip in some trade negotiation, and that will be the end of him. I think it's wrong, but that outcome is almost inevitable at some point. Obama will not pardon him, and I don't think either of the presumptive presidential nominees are big Snowden fans. From the government perspective, Snowden did a tremendous amount of damage, and he will eventually pay for that damage with his life.
- SXX 10y agoNot before Putin's regime disappear or unless Snowden himself start to become danger. I don't believe Putin will trade him under any circumstances. More likely you'll see Crimea traded. Asylum for Snowden it's wasn't just foreign policy act, but more act for Russian elites: we provided asylum for almost #1 on US list and we he is safe. Whole regime built on rule that any loyal person in elites is safe no matter if he's murderer, pedophile or any other kind of criminal. Just think about Magnitsky case. It's was just a bunch of criminals who wasn't even part of Russian elite, but Putin didn't betrayed them even after it was clear that would cause significantly damage to whole county economy. So giving Snowden would sent signal to elites that they and their capitals no longer safe. It's would be deathly for regime.
- gbuk2013 10y agoOne way to make sure this does not happen is for him to apply for Russian citizenship - extraditing a Russian citizen is forbidden by the constitution. I'm sure it is not something he really wants to do, but it's not like his US citizenship does much for him now anyway.
- schneems 10y agoAuto playing audio and an ad that takes up half the fold and scrolls with the page, how did you all read this?
- aptwebapps 10y agoPaused the video and scrolled down.
- dredmorbius 10y agouBlock origin and often opening straight to Reader Mode / saving straight to Pocket. Thanks for the heads-up though.
- simbalion 10y agoAt the risk of sounding negative... Only a complete idiot or crook would think Snowden's activities make him a spy. He is a hero. He risked his personal safety to expose the _criminal_ activities of the U.S. government. There is nothing more to the story than that. So if you want to determine if someone is an idiot and/or crook, this question is a great test.
- sintaxi 10y agoI agree. He saw the government doing illegal shit. He raised his concerns internally and only after they fell on deaf ears he released incriminating documents to veteran media to decide for themselves what the public has a right to know. Snowden is a hero.
- danieltillett 10y agoI think it is best for Snowden's cause that he stays in Russia looking down the barrel of a life sentence in a supermax. If he either ends up in Colorado or is pardoned then what the NSA was(is) doing will be quickly forgotten. Him staying in limbo keeps the issue in the public mind.
- holografix 10y agoBiggest issue for me with Snowden is what he didnt publicly disclose or withheld with the intention of bargaining with the he Chinese and Russian governments. It's no coincidence that his escape route took him through the only nations in the world that would not ask how high of the US told them to jump. Were the Chinese and Russians able to obtain significant advantage from whatever privileged info Snowden fed them? Most likely. Just as the America would do if the situation was reversed. What option did Snowden have though? I certainly can't fault him for basing the seriousness of the consequences on what happened to Chelsea Manning or on Assange's situation. Truth is if the US considers you an enemy, spy, traitor etc you no longer have any rights and will be tortured.