4 ms·
Quote from the arstechnica article: > This suggests that preference for consonance over dissonance isn’t baked into universal human auditory processing, but is
by weinzierl 10y ago
Quote from the arstechnica article:
> This suggests that preference for consonance over dissonance isn’t baked into universal human auditory processing, but is rather something we develop by being exposed to certain kinds of frequency relationships in the music that we hear.
No, that is not a conclusion that can be drawn from the experiment and not the conclusion the paper draws.
Quote from the paper:
> The results indicate that consonance preferences can be absent in cultures sufficiently isolated from Western music [...]
From what I understand the experiment shows that there are peoples that have not developed harmony until now. They make music, but they only play notes in a sequence never simultaneously.
This is not surprising, western music developed real harmony only in the modern era, music of the middle ages was mostly melodic.
That they have no harmony does not mean that preference for consonance over dissonance isn’t baked into universal human auditory processing because if they would develop harmony they might end up with the same preferences we have because we share the same human auditory processing.
- gluelogic 10y agoI agree with your your feelings about the article. I am a musician and I have been interested in music theory since I was a teenager, so I have almost always read writing about this topic. In my experience, it seems like, generally, the people who write about and study musicology are very reluctant to take the position that the music of some cultures can be more primitive than others, but to me it seems to explain a lot of the apparently paradoxical aspects of what we regard as consonance and dissonance.
- eyelidlessness 10y ago> That they have no harmony does not mean that preference for consonance over dissonance isn’t baked into universal human auditory processing because if they would develop harmony they might end up with the same preferences we have because we share the same human auditory processing. Or they might develop the same preferences because they're exposed to the same stimuli. Or they might not develop the same preferences at all. Or they might prefer alternation between both.
- solidsnack9000 10y agoThe paper -- its experiment -- doesn't really tell us. It would seem that proof of the assertion in question would require finding people with a notion of musical harmony that is genuinely dissonant.
- coldtea 10y ago>cultures sufficiently isolated from Western music This doesn't translate to "they don't have harmony". Tons of those cultures do have harmony AND it's different than the traditional western harmony.