3 ms·
An excellent article and summarizes why I'm drifting away from the left as time goes on. "If the smug [liberal] style can be reduced to a single sentence, it's
by GrumpyYoungMan 10y ago
An excellent article and summarizes why I'm drifting away from the left as time goes on.
"If the smug [liberal] style can be reduced to a single sentence, it's, 'Why are they voting against their own self-interest?' But no party these past decades has effectively represented the interests of these dispossessed. Only one has made a point of openly disdaining them too.
Abandoned and without any party willing to champion their interests, people cling to candidates who, at the very least, are willing to represent their moral convictions. The smug style resents them for it, and they resent the smug in turn.
...
The smug style, at bottom, is a failure of empathy. Further: It is a failure to believe that empathy has any value at all. It is the notion that anybody worthy of liberal time and attention and respect must capitulate, immediately, to the Good Facts.
...
Make no mistake: I am not suggesting that liberals adopt a fuzzy, gentler version of their politics. I am not suggesting they compromise their issues for the sake of playing nice. What I am suggesting is that the battles waged by liberalism have drifted far away from their old egalitarian intentions.
I am suggesting that open disdain for the people they say they want to help has led them to stop helping those people, too.
...
I am suggesting that they instead wonder what it might be like to have little left but one's values; to wake up one day to find your whole moral order destroyed; to look around and see the representatives of a new order call you a stupid, hypocritical hick without bothering, even, to wonder how your corner of your poor state found itself so alienated from them in the first place. To work with people who do not share their values or their tastes, who do not live where they live or like what they like or know their Good Facts or their jokes."
- gnarbarian 10y agoThis is a great article that strikes many chords with me. unfortunately, though it has been submitted many times it will never reach the front page.
- Futurebot 10y agoThe person who wrote this is a member of the socialist Left. This is a critique of the style among establishment Liberals (who support right-of-center Neoliberal economics / very weak social democracy and social liberalism), not the Left (who support the spectrum of leftist policy from strong social democracy to socialism to communism as well as social liberalism): Mother Jones and Slate, not Jacobin and Dissent. The distinction is extremely important now that the rift between the two is as large as it is. If you're disgusted with the smugness and support Nordic or Euro style taxation and proper redistribution, then it'd be toward, not away from the Left (not to say there are no smug Actual Leftists, just that they have no voice in our current media.)