4 ms·
I want familiar before with the concept of analytic continuations and so this part really confused me: ("The" is the appropriate article to use because the ana
by xg15 10y ago
I want familiar before with the concept of analytic continuations and so this part really confused me:
("The" is the appropriate article to use because the analytic continuation of a function is unique.)
Let f: N -> N, f(x) = x be a function on the natural numbers.
Then I could define two functions g(x) and h(x) on N u {foo} that behave just like f for natural numbers. However, g(foo) is 42 while h(foo) is 666.
Wouldn't g and h both be valid analytic continuations of f in N u {foo}, according to the definition of analytic continuations explained in the article?
I'm wondering about that as the uniqueness seems to be an important property for the rest of the explanation, yet it is simply assumed here without any further explanation.
- Bahamut 10y agoUniqueness requires proof - it relies on a theorem/lemma having to do with if an analytic function is constant in a region, then it is constant everywhere. Uniqueness then arises as if there are two analytic continuations that are the same in that region, then the difference is 0 there, and thus 0 everywhere, resulting in the two being the same. That is a non-trivial theorem/lemma though, and the proof is typically gone through at a graduate complex analysis course.
- derkha 10y agoTo clarify Bahamut's point: The functions must be analytic - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analytic_continuation#Initial_discussion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analytic_continuation#Initial_.... Regardless of the actual value of foo, at least one of g or h won't be differentiable at foo, so they can't both be analytic (assuming you choose some open superset of N u {foo}, otherwise the theorem breaks down even sooner).