4 ms·
The U.S. separation of power is based on similar ideas. Congress makes laws on a day-by-day basis, but when the will of the people contradicts certain fundamen
by nostrademons 10y ago
The U.S. separation of power is based on similar ideas. Congress makes laws on a day-by-day basis, but when the will of the people contradicts certain fundamental principles enshrined in the Constitution, the courts have a right to strike down and nullify laws.
- cperciva 10y agothe courts have a right to strike down and nullify laws. And, at least theoretically, the military oath to defend the constitution could require them to overthrow a government which does not conform to the constitution. In practice, of course, issues are likely to be resolved before they reach that point.
- jwhitlark 10y agoIt's also notable that there are many different militaries in the US: the 5 main national branches, the national guard units of the various states, as well as the state defense forces, that some states also maintain.
- Spooky23 10y agoThat's pretty nominal. Good luck to the governor trying to muster the national guard to confront federal troops.
- int_19h 10y agoIt provides a framework that can be filled if and when needed. NG and SDF may very well answer the call - it all depends on what exactly it is in response to.
- nl 10y agoNote that during the Little Rock crisis in 1957[1] it wasn't inconceivable that this could have happened. The state governor initially used the Arkansas National Guard to block black students from attending Little Rock Central High. Eisenhower federalized the Guard and ordered them to protect the students and let them integrate, and also sent in the 101st Airborne. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arkansas_National_Guard_and_the_integration_of_Central_High_School https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arkansas_National_Guard_and_th...
- delazeur 10y ago> the courts have a right to strike down and nullify laws Notably, this power does not appear in the Constitution. See Marbury v. Madison [1]. (Not that it makes a practical difference, but it is interesting to see how our conception of government powers and the basic government structure changes over time, even without new constitutional amendments.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marbury_v._Madison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marbury_v._Madison
- jonny_eh 10y agoI believe that case was covered in the most recent episode of the podcast "More Perfect", from the makers of RadioLab: http://www.wnyc.org/story/giggly-blue-robot http://www.wnyc.org/story/giggly-blue-robot
- wahern 10y agoMarbury v. Madison is much more nuanced than that. Imagine that the decision in Marbury v. Madison came out the opposite way; or, more abstractly, that the Supreme Court upheld legislation that was prima facie contradictory to the text of Constitution. That would necessarily imply one of two things; either 1) the courts are choosing to enforce an illegal law, or 2) the courts are deferring to Congress's interpretation of the Constitution and thus concluding that, despite appearances, it's legal. The former would mean that there was no rule of law. The latter would mean that the Supreme Court isn't actually the _supreme_ court, but rather an inferior court in terms of interpreting the law. The logic of Marbury v. Madison says that because the American form of government is built upon on the principle of separation of powers, and that in the English tradition it's the court's role to interpret statutes (not the legislature's), that it would be a violation of separation of powers for the Supreme Court to defer to Congress's interpretation of the constitution. Also, in the English tradition of Due Process laws can generally only be enforced through court order, not independently by executive fiat. And the U.S. Constitution explicitly says that the "judicial power" rests with the courts. The academic debate about judicial review is misleading. Judicial review is often described in contradistinction to the rule in England--Parliamentary Supremacy. But we must remember two critical things: 1) the UK does not have a written constitution, and 2) until just a few years ago the highest court in the UK was composed of Law Lords from the House of Lords. The House of Lords being a constituent part of Parliament, the highest court was thus the same institution as the body writing legislation. The debate about what we now call judicial review didn't just occur at the national level; it played out in every single state. And while many contemporary jurists paid lip service to the idea of courts being inferior to the legislative body, I don't think the debate played out any differently in any of original colonies or subsequent states in actuality. It's really difficult in the Anglo-American legal tradition for courts to _not_ have the power of judicial review, while maintaining the logic the political system is built upon. We can _imagine_ a constitutional system where courts defer to the explicit or implicit decision of the legislature regarding constitutionality. But I don't think that actually exists anywhere in the world where the principle of separation of powers is enshrined in the organic law (written or unwritten). The closest I can think of is Japan where their supreme court regularly seems to uphold statutes which conflict with the written constitution, but they _have_ nullified statutes a few times, and certainly I don't think they've formally abdicated their role wrt judicial review. We do have a form of the above in the United States. There are some situations which are considered "non-judiciable" by the Supreme Court. For example, nobody can challenge through the courts some of the formal requirements the Constitution imposes on Congress regarding their proceedings. The Supreme Court has said that in some situations it must refrain from exercising it's normal power of judicial review because it would cause the court, as an institution, to become too entangled with another branch of government. This is also partly why courts are reticent to censure or make demands on high-level executive officials, e.g. regarding national security. Even if behavior is patently illegal, by getting involved the court risks injuring the very principle of separation of powers by imposing its interpretation of the law above that of the other body.
- vidarh 10y agoAlmost all modern systems of separation of power are modelled to various extent on the principles set out by Montesquieu. Montesquieu formalised the tripartite system in The Spirit of the Laws published in 1748, describing a model of separation of powers into a judiciary, executive and legislative based on the Roman Republic and the British constitution [1]. He also formulated the principle of checks and balances. In the context of the US, Montesquieu was a strong direct influence particularly on Madison. In the context of Turkey Ataturk was very inspired by aspects of established European Democracies, and the Turkish constitution included a very strong formulation of a tripartite system from the 1924 constitution onwards. What is peculiar with Turkey is that the military sees itself as having a particular strong duty to protect the constitution that if necessary requires direct intervention, and have interceded unusually often, and have been unusual in each time handing power back to elected governments in a relatively orderly manner. Couple this with a constitution that was very radical in pushing secularism onto a very religious population where there are substantial portions of the population that wants religion to play a greater role, and you get the complicated nature of Turkish politics. (Incidentally the secularism of Turkey was explicitly modelled after France) [1] Yes, the UK has a constitution; it is just not codified in a single document, but consists of a set of laws and conventions and court decisions that are well documented. Yes, it's a messy system.
- argonaut 10y agoThe courts are also the weakest branch of government. They have no power to enforce any of their decisions and the other branches of government possess numerous "nuclear" options to sideline the courts (court-packing, impeachment). The military is generally hardly weak in Turkey (although they have been weakened in the past 10 years by Erdogan).