6 ms·
Google closes bug as WONTFIX over Creative Commons license violations
- schoen 10y agoIs it clear that CC licenses require sites to make it clear how to save a copy of a work? While there is certainly anti-DRM language in the CC licenses, is there something specific in Google's implementation of YouTube that directly conflicts with the provisions of the licenses? (I support making it easier to save copies of things, but I'm not sure about the license compliance theory.)
- shawnz 10y agoBy uploading a video to YouTube you are giving them a special license to distribute the video. The license you choose in the video description doesn't apply to them. The title is incorrect in saying there is any kind of violation here.
- schoen 10y agoWell, this is a reason why YouTube itself may not be liable (if its practices were actually inconsistent with the CC license requirements), but a CC licensor could still file takedown requests to YouTube or lawsuits against another person who reposted a CC-licensed video on YouTube. If the CC license didn't permit YouTube's practices, someone who's not the copyright holder wouldn't have been entitled under the CC license to grant YouTube the license they purported to.
- oliwarner 10y agoAnd that's the important bit here. A CC license doesn't give you the right to award Google all the rights it demands in Section 8 of the YouTube TOS. To try to do so violates the CC license, terminating your original agreement. Yeah, breaking a license term makes you liable. Just to restate it, it is illegal to upload content to YouTube under a CC license because it's instantly an infringement. Of course if you have separate permission (or its yours) that's okay but that's not a CC license, that's a dual-license to you. This is really common with user-submitted-content sites. Equally common is users not understanding this fact. Or caring. Google has safe harbour. This is their users actions... But they {c,sh}ould be doing more to interrogate uploaders about the material source and licenses. Instead they just seem happy to let the DMCA do its work.
- kevinmgranger 10y agoIn the YouTube TOS: https://www.youtube.com/static?template=terms https://www.youtube.com/static?template=terms 5. Your Use of Content ... > You shall not download any Content unless you see a “download” or similar link displayed by YouTube on the Service for that Content. Which seems contradictory with CC, and what is the next sentence: > You shall not copy, reproduce, distribute, transmit, broadcast, display, sell, license, or otherwise exploit any Content for any other purposes without the prior written consent of YouTube or the respective licensors of the Content. (I'm not a lawyer and whatnot.)
- schoen 10y agoThe CC license [looking at CC-BY 4.0 from https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode] says "You may not offer or impose any additional or different terms or conditions on, or apply any Effective Technological Measures to, the Licensed Material if doing so restricts exercise of the Licensed Rights by any recipient of the Licensed Material." Perhaps the YouTube ToS provision against downloading could be viewed as "additional or different terms or conditions". For the second sentence you quoted, I'd expect that YouTube users already have the "prior written consent of [...] the respective licensors" expressed in the CC license itself, because "[e]very recipient of the Licensed Material automatically receives an offer from the Licensor to exercise the Licensed Rights under the terms and conditions of this Public License".
- bdcravens 10y agoWouldn't the onus be on the person distributing CC-licensed material to a host with a CC-incompatible terms of service?
- schoen 10y agoI addressed this below at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12103061 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12103061 It's hard to see that someone can hold YouTube liable for this violation; presumably YouTube is protected by §512 of the DMCA for uploads that violate Creative Commons licenses just as much as it is in other copyright disputes. A copyright holder in a CC-licensed work that someone else uploaded to YouTube could file a DMCA takedown notice or seek damages from the uploader. YouTube has produced a bunch of educational material about copyrights and how to avoid violating people's copyright. I think a super awesome outcome would be if YouTube started prominently publishing educational materials that made clear that YouTube is too restrictive a place to host third-party CC-licensed videos, and that users should upload them elsewhere to avoid violating the CC licenses.
- andybak 10y agoWhilst I don't disagree with the sentiment, the post title is rather overblown and inflammatory. In case it gets modded it was "Google closes bug as WONTFIX over Creative Commons license violations"
- viraptor 10y agoNot changed yet. Sending out the dang signal!
- fhood 10y agoUmm, Is the reason they closed the bug in the title? Wut? Super confused over title.
- uremog 10y agoThe reason was not given in the WONTFIX flag. But really, youtube spends considerable effort to make its videos hard to save.
- Buge 10y agoViolations? I don't see any violations anywhere.
- empressplay 10y agoThe Creative Commons license implies redistribution, and that requires the ability to possess a copy of the file. It would be a bit like allowing people to upload code to your website and mark it GPL, but then only re-use that code yourself and not allow anyone else to download it.
- jonathankoren 10y agoBut that's not a license violation, of either the CC or the GPL. Nothing says, "must allow redistribution of original format when not modified", and in the case of the CC, it doesn't say anything about raw files. If the creator really cared about a redistribution friendly distributor, they should have used one. YouTube ain't it, and never was.
- JetSpiegel 10y agoAnd yet, YouTube advertises the CC licence. Looks like fraudulent claims to me.
- jonathankoren 10y agoI don't know why you think that. You can download the file, either using something like youtube downloader, or from the original creator's website you can still do whatever you want to with it. I can publish a book in dead tree format that's under CC, but I don't have to provide it to you in whatever format you want just because you want it.
- mthoms 10y agoYou're right, but I think the point is they're not respecting the intent/spirit of the CC licenses (whose entire purpose is about ease of sharing). So while there may not be a technical violation, some might argue there is a moral one. Whether or not Youtube (or others) see it that way is another matter.
- jszymborski 10y agoThat was rather dissmissive... not even a canned "for whatever reason, this request is out of scope" message for the WONTFIX status.
- dublinben 10y ago1. If you want to download a CC licensed (or any) video from YouTube, use youtube-dl. 2. As commenter #8 points out, if you care about this sort of thing, use a different platform. For example, Vimeo makes it incredibly easy to download videos.
- mthoms 10y ago1. Downloading violates Youtube's TOS. So there's that. 2. The argument is that Youtube shouldn't be using the CC name and licenses at all if they are not going to adhere to the spirit of said licenses.
- theli0nheart 10y ago> Downloading violates Youtube's TOS. So there's that. If downloading videos violates YouTube's TOS, but YouTube is violating the Creative Commons license by enforcing this aspect of their TOS, is this restriction enforceable?
- gingerrr 10y agoIt's certainly enforceable by banning.
- ProxCoques 10y agoContract trumps copyright. That's how the publishing industry works.
- themartorana 10y agoNot to be pedantic, but any video you watch is downloaded (even when "streamed"). Having it land in a browser cache folder instead of your desktop is obfuscation at best. It's odd to me that TOS can dictate to which folder a file is downloaded.
- random28345 10y agoI love how the comments reference the "users", when what's really important is Google's customers. If allowing use of CC licensed content helped advertisers, it would implemented post-haste.
- empressplay 10y agoI guess the point here is that if Google can't comply with the CC license provisions (in letter _and_ spirit) they should change the YouTube uploader option for CC to something more along the lines of "allow users to remix your content through one of our applications", which is more in-line with the truth.
- spullara 10y agoYouTube's license of the content (that you grant when you upload and host your content there) is broader than the CC license extended to YouTube viewers. The license Google has doesn't require them to allow downloads.
- jonathankoren 10y agoThe YouTube license doesn't trump the CC, it's in addition to it. Either way, the CC doesn't say you have to allow downloads, just that if someone does get the file they can "remix" it and you can't sue.
- ProxCoques 10y agoThat's false, I'm afraid. Enforced contract trumps copyright, and CC is no exception. If it were the other way around, there wouldn't be a music, recording or publishing industry.
- jonathankoren 10y agoWith respect, I don't think you know what you're talking about. If I have have a copyright, then I can issue a license, without transferring copyright, and more than one license can be applied in parallel.
- cperciva 10y agoThis is a non-story. CC licensing says that the copyright owner permits you to make copies of the content; it places no obligation on Google to help you do this, or even to allow you to use their service to do this.
- schoen 10y agoCC licenses are not neutral about downstream technical and policy restrictions; see section (2)(a)(5)(B) of https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode It's not clear to me whether YouTube's policy definitely conflicts with that section, but it seems plausible! I think this is analogous to the way that distributing third-party GPL-licensed software in the iTunes App Store may violate the GPL, which I think is because of the provision that "[y]ou may not impose any further restrictions on the recipients' exercise of the rights granted herein", which the App Store's policies do.
- cperciva 10y agoIt's not clear to me whether YouTube's policy definitely conflicts with that section, but it seems plausible! It doesn't matter. If you upload a video to youtube, you're doing it under youtube's terms of service, not under whatever license you may use for distributing the video to other people. If I release a video publicly under a license which says "if you distribute this video, you must pay me a million dollars" and then upload it to youtube, it just means that there are now two licenses -- not that youtube owes me a million dollars.
- schoen 10y agoSure, but plenty of people are also uploading other people's CC-licensed works to YouTube, in which case a genuine legal conflict has been created. Edit: (which doesn't mean YouTube is bound by the provisions of the CC license, but does mean it doesn't have valid permission from the uploader or copyright holder to display the works)
- 10y ago