2 ms·
>framed in terms of "why" something happened rather than "this mutation was more suited to the environment at the time." I simply read "why did turtles evolve
by wongarsu 10y ago
>framed in terms of "why" something happened rather than "this mutation was more suited to the environment at the time."
I simply read "why did turtles evolve shells" as a short form for "why did shells provide a reproductive advantage to some organisms possessing this random mutation".
- yannyu 10y agoIt's possible that some readers of the article will interpret the phrase that way. For people with a less nuanced understanding of natural selection it suggests that evolution is a directed effort towards certain ends, as though turtles had a say in how their species evolved. Alternatively, that there is some other agency that is deliberately influencing the evolution of species. Personally I feel like the idea of evolution as a directed effort is a common misunderstanding of natural selection, and I wonder if better science reporting could start to mend those kinds of misconceptions.
- delazeur 10y agoYes, technical people often use shorthand terms that ascribe agency to random or inanimate processes, and I think laypeople take that agency literally more often than we realize.