4 ms·
So it's a $1300 device, and they commit to building them if they get roughly 120 pre-orders. That sounds like the sort of scale where the NSA will be intercept
by dsr_ 10y ago
So it's a $1300 device, and they commit to building them if they get roughly 120 pre-orders.
That sounds like the sort of scale where the NSA will be intercepting every delivery pro-actively in order to install hardware tapping devices or other security bypasses.
edit: I would recommend that Purism take detailed photos of the insides, front and back, and put signed copies of them on the website.
- zaphar 10y agoSo at some point paranoia becomes paralyzing. I know I at least am unable to build a laptop or tablet from scratch. I need someone else to do it for me but if I can't trust that person because their scale is too small and I can't trust the other guys because their scale is too big. Then who exactly can I trust? I suppose we could all just abandon computing entirely. But I kind of like the internet and all that.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt isn't paranoia when NSA was already proven to do stuff like this and the target market consists disproportionately out of people who might be interesting to surveil. This product feels like a (most likely unintentional) honeypot.
- jlarocco 10y agoActually, it would be hilariously ironic if the whole company was an NSA honeypot.
- zaphar 10y agoSo here's the thing: Any company that solves this problem is by definition a (most likely unintentional) honeypot. Which is about as unhelpful as you can get. The question is what can these companies do to mitigate that risk for their clients. Expecting someone who needs/wants this sort of security in a laptop to homebrew it is unrealistic. So by your logic everyone should just despair and be completely paralyzed by their inability to protect themselves. Surely there is a better way?
- wmf 10y agoAny company that solves this problem is by definition a (most likely unintentional) honeypot. Unless that company has >100M users and turns security on by default.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThat company is more likely to be a honeypot if it's a profit-motivated, US corporation who can insert a deniable software flaw. There were many such companies in the Snowden leaks. Im not worried about Purism outside same failures everyone else has. More likely to screw us by accident than anything.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI'm not worried about Purism doing something malicious to their customers; if anything, per the original comment in this thread I'd expect NSA to simply intercept all the shipments en-route and backdoor them, just like they did with other laptops in the past.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIt was apparent that they are very selective about stuff like that. You have to be a target of significant value. They could use this attack against specific buyers but I doubt they'll compromise all of them. Risk vs reward.
- sounds 10y agoI like the idea of putting a small amount of glittery fingernail polish over the screw, then taking a high res picture. The idea is from Eric Michaud and Ryan Lackey's presentation at 30C3 (2013 CCC), but this is a decent writeup: http://www.wired.co.uk/article/data-security-nail-polish http://www.wired.co.uk/article/data-security-nail-polish
- noir_lord 10y agoThat's ingenious, I like it, cheap and effective.
- brudgers 10y agoAt the three letter agency end of the will spectrum, photographing the original and printing a facsimile is the sort of thing that's all in a day's business...much like ordinary aircraft such as gaining access to and altering the originals. The glitter perhaps slows down industrial espionage but the resources and nonfinancial incentives of state actors tilt the play field.