11 ms·
Purism builds a secure tablet with physical wi-fi and camera switches
- brian_herman 10y agoHow do they deal with the intel management engine in all intel chips? https://libreboot.org/faq/ https://libreboot.org/faq/
- beedogs 10y agoAMD and ARM have them, as well. It's almost impossible to avoid these hardware backdoors.
- r00fus 10y agoCite?
- drawnwren 10y agoIt's in the link this comment chain is in response to.
- anonbanker 10y agoNo. It isn't.
- drawnwren 10y agoFrom [1]: AMD Platform Security Processor (PSP) #amdpsp This is basically AMD's own version of the Intel Management Engine. It has all of the same basic security and freedom issues, although the implementation is wildly different. The Platform Security Processor (PSP) is built in on all Family 16h + systems (basically anything post-2013), and controls the main x86 core startup. PSP firmware is cryptographically signed with a strong key similar to the Intel ME. If the PSP firmware is not present, or if the AMD signing key is not present, the x86 cores will not be released from reset, rendering the system inoperable. The PSP is an ARM core with TrustZone technology, built onto the main CPU die. As such, it has the ability to hide its own program code, scratch RAM, and any data it may have taken and stored from the lesser-privileged x86 system RAM (kernel encryption keys, login data, browsing history, keystrokes, who knows!). To make matters worse, the PSP theoretically has access to the entire system memory space (AMD either will not or cannot deny this, and it would seem to be required to allow the DRM "features" to work as intended), which means that it has at minimum MMIO-based access to the network controllers and any other PCI/PCIe peripherals installed on the system. In theory any malicious entity with access to the AMD signing key would be able to install persistent malware that could not be eradicated without an external flasher and a known good PSP image. Furthermore, multiple security vulnerabilities have been demonstrated in AMD firmware in the past, and there is every reason to assume one or more zero day vulnerabilities are lurking in the PSP firmware. Given the extreme privilege level (ring -2 or ring -3) of the PSP, said vulnerabilities would have the ability to remotely monitor and control any PSP enabled machine. completely outside of the user's knowledge. Much like with the Intel Boot Guard (an application of the Intel Management Engine), AMD's PSP can also act as a tyrant by checking signatures on any boot firmware that you flash, making replacement boot firmware (e.g. libreboot, coreboot) impossible on some boards. Early anecdotal reports indicate that AMD's boot guard counterpart will be used on most OEM hardware, disabled only on so-called "enthusiast" CPUs. [1] https://libreboot.org/faq/#amd https://libreboot.org/faq/#amd
- anonbanker 10y agoyou just pasted a wall of text about AMD's use of ARM processors, and not ARM TrustZone, which is what we were talking about. While AMD's use of ARM processors (and with it, TrustZone) to fashion a security blackbox on your chip is dishonest and terrifying, it is not evidence that TrustZone is what you're saying it is. I invite you to research more into TrustZone, so you'll be less afraid of ARM.
- drawnwren 10y agoI'm sort of genuinely confused what is happening on your side of this conversation. Your account is too old to be trolling, but it surely seems like it. Here's the conversation I see: 1. How do they deal with the intel management engine in all intel chips? https://libreboot.org/faq/ https://libreboot.org/faq/ 2. AMD and ARM have them, as well. It's almost impossible to avoid these hardware backdoors. 3. Cite? and our remarks back and forth. Who is talking about ARM TrustZone? That wall of text was libre boot's explanation (from the original link) of what AMD and ARM's Intel Management Engine equivalent system is.
- anonbanker 10y agoyour wall of text only explains AMD's management engine. not ARM. again, you should probably go look at the TrustZone documentation. it isn't what you think it is. further, your "anyone that tells you your emperor is wearing no clothes is trolling" attitude is something HN'ers attempt to avoid.
- r00fus 10y agoAlmost all Intel chips have ME. Not all ARMs do - does my iPhone have an ME-equivalent (ie, TrustZone is visible from OS kernel, so not equivalent).
- makomk 10y agoARM doesn't have anything like the Management Engine. It has TrustZone, but that's basically just a hypervisor-like mode that some manufacturers use to run software above the OS level. A lot of the common hobbyist-friendly ARM SoCs give the user full control over what if anything runs in TrustZone mode.
- anonbanker 10y agoOnly non-FUD post in the chain.
- milcron 10y agoRelated, a presentation by Raptor Engineering "The World Beyond x86" (video and pdf slides) https://www.raptorengineering.com/TALOS/op_twbx86.php https://www.raptorengineering.com/TALOS/op_twbx86.php They delve into x86's freedom and security issues, then discuss the pros and cons of ARM chips versus OpenPOWER chips. For an open laptop such as Bunnie's Novena, ARM is a fine choice. For Raptor Engineering's Talos Secure Workstation, OpenPOWER was a better fit.
- milcron 10y agoNot impossible. Intel chips from 2008 or earlier still work. I like the Thinkpad X200, the most recent Intel-based laptop that can be flashed to use Libreboot instead of stock firmware. For workstations, Raptor Engineering is working on an open hardware motherboard design based on the POWER architecture, which IBM recently opened. https://raptorengineeringinc.com/TALOS/prerelease.php https://raptorengineeringinc.com/TALOS/prerelease.php In the future, RISC-V looks promising. There is also a subset of ARM chips which seem safe.
- DenisM 10y agoOne thing was suggested here earlier is a computer that can send data out but is physically unable to receive. This you would use to create and sign content. Another computer can only receive but never send. This one is used to read messages sent to you and verify signatures. This way you can have authenticated communication. It can probably be used for encrypted communication as well, though there are problems with entering keys of your correspondents into the computer that only sends data. I don't know how practical this is, but seems resilient against hardware back doors.
- pdkl95 10y ago> send data out but is physically unable to receive That's a "data diode". The chat system that uses data diodes is "Tinfoil Chat". https://cs.helsinki.fi/u/oottela/tfc.pdf https://cs.helsinki.fi/u/oottela/tfc.pdf It should be very robust against attack, but be careful to note the exact features that TFC provides, which are a bit unusual.
- beardog 10y agoThey don't. Purism is mostly a marketing gimmick.
- Taek 10y agoIt's definitely more than a marketing gimmick. Hardware switches are a big deal. Qubes out of box is really cool. Am emphasis on using as much open source hardware as possible is excellent. If Intel is the only vulnerability, we're doing miles better than your average device, where any of a dozen sources can compromise you. Librem is not perfect. It's just a step forward but if we don't start somewhere the ball will never get rolling. I'm happy to support them, and hope the next 5 years sees a decent cpu without security problems. We're moving the right direction for once.
- whamlastxmas 10y agoIt is definitely a marketing gimmick on some level. They claimed an entirely open source laptop which is a complete and total lie. They are making good progress in one way, but still destroying trust in another.
- sounds 10y agoYour statement "they are making good progress in one way, but still destroying trust in another" is problematic because it omits the most important detail: what is your proposed solution? A Novena from Bunnie? https://www.crowdsupply.com/sutajio-kosagi/novena https://www.crowdsupply.com/sutajio-kosagi/novena A Lemote Yeelong? They're pretty difficult to even buy... http://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/Yeeloong-Notebook-computer-8089D-white-Linux/801318_284840643.html http://www.aliexpress.com/store/product/Yeeloong-Notebook-co... minifree.org products rely on hardware being available that does not have an Intel ME or equivalent. That hardware will only get harder to find as time goes on. When faced with a challenging problem like this, I find it saddening to see the Free Software community turning on each other and fighting instead of looking for multiple parallel solutions.
- 10y ago
- bahjoite 10y agoIt's not in all intel chips and it appears that the Intel Core M-5Y10c in the Librem 11 doesn't support the management engine: see the entry for "Intel vPro Technology" under Advanced Technologies http://ark.intel.com/products/85234/Intel-Core-M-5Y10c-Processor-4M-Cache-up-to-2_00-GHz http://ark.intel.com/products/85234/Intel-Core-M-5Y10c-Proce...
- milcron 10y agoYou're partially correct. The components which power the management engine are always present. However they lock you out of using those features unless you pay for a vPro chip. Buying a chip without vPro means the Management Engine still lives on your device, it's just that you aren't allowed to use it.
- dandelion_lover 10y agoThey created a petition to Intel: https://puri.sm/posts/intel-me-less-petition-goal-met-early/ https://puri.sm/posts/intel-me-less-petition-goal-met-early/
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoHow did Intel respond to said petition?
- andrey_utkin 10y agoIn next product, Purism will add a physical kill switch for Intel ME :)
- unhammer 10y ago"You have to be a certain kind of paranoid to want a hardware kill switch for networking" – or just battle-weary from a shockpile of bad laptops where you had to suspend-resume/reboot/unplug battery to get your wifi card back up
- lmm 10y agoThose cases are usually where the driver has got confused, in which case the hardware switch doesn't help much, IME.
- fredley 10y agoAnd the microphone? I'm much more wary of microphone data being captured than camera data.
- peteretep 10y agoAm I silly for preferring the herd security provided by using vanilla iOS?
- homingbrain 10y agoIf your only worry is malware, vanilla iOS is probably OK. But malware is not the only problem they're trying to solve.
- peteretep 10y agoWhat are the other problems this will solve that vanilla iOS doesn't?
- d8421l01vv4r 10y agoThey are trying to achieve complete control over the code it runs. Which is in some ways the opposite of Apple's approach to security.
- bahjoite 10y agoWhat security do you think you get from being in the herd?
- peteretep 10y ago- No signalling effect - Quick and reliable disclosure of and turn around on vulnerabilities
- laumars 10y ago> "No signalling effect" Can you explain this point please. I've not heard it used in this context before. > "Quick and reliable disclosure of and turn around on vulnerabilities" Sadly there's only a very loose correlation between the popularity of a product and the corporations ability or willingness to disclose vulnerabilities or release patches in good time, nor even patch them at all (in the worst cases). An apt example of this is how poor many OEMs are at pushing Android updates to popular tablets and smartphones. However I do appreciate you specified iOS and Apple are generally better at supporting older devices than many Android OEMs. But I'm replying to the "herd" point more generally.
- asymmetric 10y agoI'm confused as to which OS this is running.
- bwindels 10y agoGNU/Linux distribution with wayland and gnome running on top AFAIK.
- dandelion_lover 10y agoQubes OS https://puri.sm/posts/purism-partners-with-qubes-security-focused-hardware-and-software-together/ https://puri.sm/posts/purism-partners-with-qubes-security-fo...
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoAs a libertarian, I don't like unnecessary government intervention, but with the case of physical switches, I'm willing to make an exception. We need a legal requirement that you cannot sell a computer without physical switches for camera, audio, networking, and wi-fi. I think selling gear in any other configuration is too dangerous in a non-obvious way to the average consumer. We can stop this now, or we can go on for another decade or two and try to stop it. It's easier done now, when we're first seeing how this is all going to turn out.
- jstanley 10y agoI'm a libertarian too, I don't like unnecessary government intervention, and I think this case is no different to any other "save them from themselves" kind of policy. If people truly want to buy equipment that saves cost by removing physical switches, there's no reason the government should be stopping them.
- DanielBMarkham 10y agoIf people want to engage in open and free trade and make an informed decision, I'm all for it. The problem here is that you are effectively making an open-ended, infinite choice. You have no idea what that information could be used for. You might have grandkids who could suffer. There's no reasonable exchange here that makes sense for the individual. So I just don't see how a free and informed choice could be made, since the person making the choice has no idea what they are choosing. This is a similar question to asking if people have the right to sell themselves into chattel slavery. I think the answer in that case is also "no". Indentured servitude, perhaps -- but that's a discussion for another day.
- mindcrime 10y agoWait, you want the government to require companies to sell hardware that will let people protect themselves from... the government. I don't see this happening.
- zanny 10y agoThe correct libertarian position is the abolition of IP entirely so that you destroy the market for proprietary software. If you still have some draconian FCC type organization controlling light (which is still insane, and should also be immediately abolished by any libertarian administration) you could at least mandate that the radios be open source at all levels to enable citizens to verify conformance. You could probably do an easier job forcing open source just by requiring all government contract hardware / software to provide you with all design schematics and sources that you then immediately publish for consumers to utilize. Without IP bullshit, once someone is publishing it, you can trust it if you personally verify it securely.
- dsr_ 10y agoSo it's a $1300 device, and they commit to building them if they get roughly 120 pre-orders. That sounds like the sort of scale where the NSA will be intercepting every delivery pro-actively in order to install hardware tapping devices or other security bypasses. edit: I would recommend that Purism take detailed photos of the insides, front and back, and put signed copies of them on the website.
- zaphar 10y agoSo at some point paranoia becomes paralyzing. I know I at least am unable to build a laptop or tablet from scratch. I need someone else to do it for me but if I can't trust that person because their scale is too small and I can't trust the other guys because their scale is too big. Then who exactly can I trust? I suppose we could all just abandon computing entirely. But I kind of like the internet and all that.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoIt isn't paranoia when NSA was already proven to do stuff like this and the target market consists disproportionately out of people who might be interesting to surveil. This product feels like a (most likely unintentional) honeypot.
- jlarocco 10y agoActually, it would be hilariously ironic if the whole company was an NSA honeypot.
- zaphar 10y agoSo here's the thing: Any company that solves this problem is by definition a (most likely unintentional) honeypot. Which is about as unhelpful as you can get. The question is what can these companies do to mitigate that risk for their clients. Expecting someone who needs/wants this sort of security in a laptop to homebrew it is unrealistic. So by your logic everyone should just despair and be completely paralyzed by their inability to protect themselves. Surely there is a better way?
- pgaddict 10y agoI'm a big fan of attempts to develop free hardware, despite the higher price and other problems (serviceability etc.). But I really hope they'll make a better job with the kill switches than on the Librem laptop. Firstly there are no labels, so it's unclear which switch is for what, or even the on/off position. Secondly, they've used switches that are entirely unsuitable for exposing on the edge of the laptop - after 1 week of usage one of the switches simply broke off when putting the laptop in a bag, and expect the same thing to happen for the other switches soon. And it's pretty easy to change the on/off positions this wa, which is a problem because the camera/microphone has no led indicating the position.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- puddintane 10y agoThey should offer a pick-up option to prevent any tampering in transit to make it seem more worthwhile. I mean if someone is required to be that concerned about security I'm certain they will justify the costs to go pick-up a device versus risking having it compromised.
- deftnerd 10y agoThat's a ridiculous price. I just got an older tablet and installed an aftermarket ROM without the Google frameworks. Then I put stickers over the cameras, and opened it up to disconnect the microphone and sever the electrical traces on the USB port so it only charges and doesn't allow for data communications. When I closed the case up, I put some globs of epoxy on the inside so it wouldn't be possible to open it back up without major and obvious shell damage. I do something similar with my laptops. I use older Lenovos compatible with Libreboot and just disconnect the microphones and cameras and seal up the ports with DMA memory access (firewire, eSATA, etc) and seal up the case. It makes it so I can't repair them if something goes wrong, but since they're ancient machines they're very inexpensive.
- Brakenshire 10y ago$600 for a 10" Atom tablet, 4GB RAM, 64GB SSD, including the keyboard. $1300 for a 11" Core-M5 tablet, 8GB RAM, 256GB SSD, including the keyboard. Honestly doesn't seem that bad to me, if the product is well made. It's similar in price and processor specs to the Macbook (Core-M3, 8GB RAM, 256GB SSD for $1300).
- deftnerd 10y agoOh, I agree that the $1300 tablet has great specs. It needs them to run Qubes (which I run on my desktop machine) I was just saying that if your primary goal is adding a bit of tinfoil to your desire for security and privacy, it's easy to just get an old tablet and modify it to remove some of the most common attack vectors and environmental observation capabilities.
- kovek 10y agoIf someone has access to your webcam and microphone inout, then would that data not be transmitted over the internet? In that case, would it not be possible to see if that data is being transmitted using tools like Wireshark?
- witty_username 10y ago
- ams6110 10y agoThe only way to be secure is to not be online. If the NSA is targeting you, you've already lost.
- mrfusion 10y agoWhy not just make a case that does this? It could have doors that slide out to block/unblock the camera and microphone. And make it a faraday cage to block wifi and gps until you open the case.
- arm 10y agoWow, I’m pleasantly surprised. They’re actually serious about their commitment to privacy; their website¹ amazingly doesn’t contain any third-party trackers! ―――――― ¹ — https://puri.sm/ https://puri.sm/
- Nadya 10y agoI'm curious why they make a call to fonts.googleapis.com for Arial, sans-serif though....I was also pleasantly surprised to see uBlock didn't block anything from their site. For those curious: PureOS is a Debian fork. PureBrowser is an Iceweasel fork which itself is a Firefox fork. [0] Assuming this is the official repo, there are some concerns of mine that security updates are out of date. [0] https://github.com/purism/PureBrowser https://github.com/purism/PureBrowser >PureBrowser takes Debian's Iceweasel and includes a number of the changes made for GNU's IceCat, along with some extensions that we like - privacybadger, ublock, https-everywhere, html5-video-everywhere, and decentraleyes. >DuckDuckGo's search page is the default, as well as the homepage.
- cleaver 10y agoI see Google Fonts, which I'd consider a tracking tool.