2 ms·
A couple of red flags here. Do people really understand their own preferences? There's a number of psychological experiments that indicate our self reports of o
by stcredzero 10y ago
A couple of red flags here. Do people really understand their own preferences? There's a number of psychological experiments that indicate our self reports of our preferences and why we prefer certain things are quite inaccurate. (There was a famous one involving socks/stockings that were preselected to be equally preferred by the general populace. It turns out, that if the things are pretty much the same, people tend to select things from a particular side of the table, yet they give all sorts of reasons that sound more socially plausible than, "it was the one on the left.")
Unless one is a musician, one probably has a very undifferentiated understanding of intervals and chords in isolation. Also, musical preferences very rarely involve listening to intervals and chords in isolation. They are part of a complex "cocktail" of auditory and other stimuli that go together. (Most often, I meet people who only understand "music" in a context that includes performers and specific recordings/performances and are really unable to discuss pieces of musical composition in the abstract.)
As an analogy, this is like presenting some aromatic compounds to people from different cultures, asking how much they like the compounds, then declaring wine preferences are mainly cultural. The conclusion, that such things are cultural, seems obvious. The construct of the experiment seems legit on the surface. However, there is a pretty poor logical connection between the two on closer examination.
There should be a name for this kind of fallacy. It's a kind of unjustified reductionism. It's virtually a trope in the social sciences.
- baldfat 10y agoWell how about: composition-division fallacy? https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/composition-division https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/composition-division > Often when something is true for the part it does also apply to the whole, or vice versa, but the crucial difference is whether there exists good evidence to show that this is the case. Because we observe consistencies in things, our thinking can become biased so that we presume consistency to exist where it does not. OR The Texas Sharpshooter https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/the-texas-sharpshooter https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/the-texas-sharpshooter > You cherry-picked a data cluster to suit your argument, or found a pattern to fit a presumption.