3 ms·
What would be better than peer review? Arxiv lets preprints be published. Would be cool if afterwards they'd have reviews from credentialed users.
by EGreg 10y ago
What would be better than peer review?
Arxiv lets preprints be published. Would be cool if afterwards they'd have reviews from credentialed users.
- mcarlise 10y agoI agree with the reviews from credentialed users. People should put their names on the arguments for or against a paper, and let others evaluate them in return. I like pre-print services, and I wish they would go one step further and allow people to comment/critic the paper. This way, when you find a paper, you could see all associated thoughts and join the conversation. The really powerful idea behind pre-prints is that it would speed up academic publishing, by eliminating the ~6 month publication time. The only problem with pre-prints (currently) is they are not widely accepted for academic tenure. With academic publishing being a multi-billion dollar industry, I'm kind of surprised there are not more tech startups working on this issue.
- EGreg 10y agoSo why not make a service for arxiv papers or any other source of resources and have experts critique them? Maybe there is already a good source of experts on Quora or something. Or start a new site where experts are invited.
- mcarlise 10y ago> So why not make a service for arxiv papers or any other source of resources and have experts critique them? Yeah I think this would be a great idea. If you had the capture ability of sci-hub with the invite ability of quora to get experts to critic papers. Then add on-top of that some simple blog features like top highlight, sharing, subscribe to citation links, and comment/discussion (that matches HN's no counter productive comments/etc). The large obstacle would be paywalls - like sci-hub; any attractive paper would be illegal to have on the service; if you simply pulled from pre-prints (arxiv; plos pre-print, etc..) you will probably lose academic disciplines that do not value these services (biology primarily comes to mind). On the other hand, CS would probably embrace it as a complement to their conference publishing culture.
- EGreg 10y agoIf someone wants to partner with me on this, I'd be happy to do it. We have the underlying platform for it already. Find me on http://qbix.com/about http://qbix.com/about (click to email me)
- drauh 10y ago"Published" in scare quotes. By definition, preprints are not reviewed. It's like a Wordpress for scientific papers. It was created so that researchers could get their work out to their peers quickly rather than waiting for the necessarily long review process. Or mass mailing PDFs. Unless the author(s) of something on the arXiv is established, and the paper says something like "submitted to so-and-so journal", you should take everything in arXiv with heaps of salt.
- mcarlise 10y ago> Unless the author(s) of something on the arXiv is established, and the paper says something like "submitted to so-and-so journal", you should take everything in arXiv with heaps of salt. This implies the broad sweep that anything that passes peer review is more valid than anything that does not. I do not feel comfortable with such an argument.