4 ms·
So does Amazon. What's the big deal? Anybody ever believe Google results are not skewed? That's kind of the whole point - the results are customized per individ
by JoeAltmaier 10y ago
So does Amazon. What's the big deal? Anybody ever believe Google results are not skewed? That's kind of the whole point - the results are customized per individual. Of course that includes skewed toward items Google considers more important.
- jacquesm 10y agoThe big deal is - in case that wasn't clear to anybody - that having a de-facto monopoly on search changes things. If google had a 2% market share in search nobody would care about them pushing their own products but with the market share that google currently has they control what internet users see and can push other parties offering the same or better services out of business (or at a minimum hurt them disproportionally). Search should be a level playing field, and Google - in spite of their motto - is pushing their own products even when they are not superior and that's a dead giveaway that they are abusing their position.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoMarket share is voluntary. I use DuckDuckGo. Its there for everybody to use. I didn't pay for either one. So I'm not even sure 'market share' is meaningful, when there is no actual market to begin with. And as I already noted, search is deliberately not a level anything. Its all about tilting the results to suit an agenda. Always was. Whether its pleasing me by finding stuff I agree with (politically or culturally), or showing me stuff I might be convinced to buy. That's the whole industry right there.
- ThomPete 10y agoIt's not that simple. Most people never made a conscious choice to use Google they ended up using it for a number of reasons hell most people think that google is the internet.
- jacquesm 10y ago> Market share is voluntary. No, it really isn't. The fact that you can change does not mean that people will change. Defaults and all kinds of tie-ins have led to google being the way in which people navigate the web. > I use DuckDuckGo. Its there for everybody to use. That's an illusion. DuckDuckGo works at the scale that it currently has achieved. If it were to serve even 20% of all search traffic it would collapse. There currently is only one viable technical contender to Google and that's 'bing' and it has a fraction of Google's market share. > And as I already noted, search is deliberately not a level anything. It is perceived as such. > Its all about tilting the results to suit an agenda. This is quite possibly true today. > Always was. And that's true at all. > Whether its pleasing me by finding stuff I agree with (politically or culturally), or showing me stuff I might be convinced to buy. That's the whole industry right there. This is confused. If it finds the stuff you need then it is 'good', if it finds you stuff to buy then that's also good if you were looking to buy something. It certainly isn't good when you're searching for a product offered by party 'B' and party 'G' and you're only shown the product by party 'G' who happens to own the search engine market then that's simply wrong.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoStraw man? It never 'only shows' anything. It shows an ordered list. Its all in there. This 'skew issue' is all a bunch of hot air over almost nothing.
- rayalez 10y ago> No, it really isn't. The fact that you can change does not mean that people will change. Defaults and all kinds of tie-ins have led to google being the way in which people navigate the web. "The fact that you can change..." - Isn't this the very definition of "voluntary"? I don't understand this logic. People are too lazy/ignorant to switch to a different search engine, and that gives them right to tel google what to do with their product?
- fixermark 10y agoThe threshold for antitrust really ought to be higher than "it's the default" in an ecosystem where the alternative is as easy to reach as the original. I'd be more concerned if it were impossible to use an iPhone to search with Bing., or a chrome browser to search with DDG.
- abrezas 10y agoAnd Google participating in EU market is voluntary. If it doesn't like the laws or the power of the EU investigators, it can choose to take its business elsewhere.
- wslh 10y agoMarket share is voluntary but our will is limited by many factors. Even if someone invents a better search engine you will not discover it if the "promotion game" is very unfair.
- Sylos 10y agoHow is there not a market just because you didn't pay with money? You pay with your personal data and your attention to ads. Not that this would be in any way relevant. Whether you call it "market share" or "user share" or whatever, fact is that Google has a lot of it and can abuse that. And no, search is supposed to be a level playing field. If something is an ad, then you are required by law to inform your users about that.
- bduerst 10y agoThat's still not a monopoly on web ads. There are available competitive and substitute services (Facebook and Twitter, for example).
- raldi 10y agoDo you disagree with the first paragraph of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly ? Because I don't see how you can consider Google a "de facto monopoly" by that definition.
- ar0 10y agoSince the original article is about an EU investigation, I would believe the relevant Wikipedia article is this one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_competition_law#Dominance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union_competition_law... In fact, it is not about being a "monopoly" but about having a "dominant position", which is presumed given Google's market share.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> In fact, it is not about being a "monopoly" but about having a "dominant position" While there is a (apparently nonconclusive) presumption raised by market share, the test for "dominant position" seems to be a power-to-take-action test very similar to the pricing power test for "monopoly" -- "A firm is in a dominant position if it has the ability to behave independently of its competitors, customers, suppliers and, ultimately, the final consumer. A dominant firm holding such market power would have the ability to set prices above the competitive level to sell products of an inferior quality or to reduce its rate of innovation below the level that would exist in a competitive market." [0] http://www.concurrences.com/Droit-de-la-concurrence/Glossaire-des-termes-de/Dominant-position http://www.concurrences.com/Droit-de-la-concurrence/Glossair...
- raldi 10y agoThe comment I was replying to claimed that Google has "a de-facto monopoly on search". That is the claim that my reply is challenging; whether or not Google has "a dominant position" is irrelevant to this subthread.