8 ms·
Is Facebook Ready to Be the World’s Live News Network?
- mark_l_watson 10y agoMy god, what a bad idea. The concentration of power in controlling what news people see is one of the huge problems of modern times. Personally, I like following a few diverse news feeds on Gnu Social, and if a story interests me, then go on google news and read a story from a few sources in different countries. I live in the USA and our news is very much controlled/censored.
- dudul 10y agoI also live in the US, but migrated there only 7 years ago. And, the news is one of the things that shocked me the most. They are not news, they are echo-chambers designed to please viewers and sell time slots to ad-publishers. Every single story has to be sensational, has to be "crazy", or "unbelievable". Everything has to be a show with music, sound effects and cool teasers.
- alanwatts 10y agoWhere did you migrate from? And what was the news like there?
- dudul 10y agoI migrated from Western Europe. The main difference I see is that there is no breaks to show TV-ads in the middle of the news. Traditionally the news is from 8pm to 8.40pm, uninterrupted, followed by 5 to 10 minutes dedicated to the weather, and then a 90 to 120min movie with one break in the middle. Nowadays, there are more options: some news program air earlier (7pm for example), some are shorter (20minutes), etc. But the key is that there is no ads either in the middle or around the program. From my point of view, this is the difference that is driving this race to the sensational.
- jarjoura 10y agoPBS would be the equivalent here but as you said, no where near as interesting to watch.
- alanwatts 10y agoInteresting. So there are no 24/7 news channels?
- programLyrique 10y agoDepends on the country in Europe. I know about BBC News in the UK, and in France, there are now 4, and soon, 5 (BFMtv, ITele, LCI, France 24, France Info).
- dudul 10y agoThey started doing it yeah. But I believe that there are still very little commercials. The reason being that they are part of all the standard channels everybody gets, so they get money regardless of the viewer count and don't rely on ad-income.
- blakesterz 10y agoThat's interesting, I never thought about what news might be like elsewhere. It's better in other countries? I guess I just kind of assume it's like this everywhere. (this may make me sound like an ignorant American, but honestly I've no idea what the news is like everywhere else, I barely follow it here for dudul's exact reasons)
- speps 10y agoTry this : http://www.bbc.co.uk/worldserviceradio http://www.bbc.co.uk/worldserviceradio You don't have images, but you'd surprised how many things happen in the world at once...
- soundwave106 10y agoAgreed. BBC World News is also available on some cable networks apparently (https://bbcnewschannelfinder.com/ https://bbcnewschannelfinder.com/). (Live streams also exist, both "unofficially", and legally but geo-restricted on Livestation, apparently.) PBS and NPR are the only American sources on TV I considered fairly comparable in tone and depth to news programs in other countries.
- herbst 10y agoSwitzerland represent. Our news are just boring news. Yes i've seen a news report about a cat beeing in a tree. I've also seen a news report about kids painting their mofas. If nothing interesting happens right now, that is the kind of content we get to see. Currently there is a lot "lulz Trump", "wtf hillary" and "trololo brexit" in between. So it is a bit more sensationalized then else.
- coliveira 10y agoWhen I moved to the US I was shocked that the news cycle is so editorialized. Only a few main stories surface in the media, usually things that have some commercial interest. Brazil has one of the worst national media anywhere, but at least they allow more variety of views and you can make your mind about what matters or not.
- Broken_Hippo 10y ago
- droopybuns 10y agoThe stream of Pokemon Go packages masquerading as news on local news programs has been mind blowing this week.
- feklar 10y agoThe written news is even worse, a gigantic live feed of what every idiot on Twitter thinks mixed in with exploding popup ads that capture your click if you're not perfectly precise 'Here's what @TotallyNotAPaidShill had to say about the latest political scandal' [Click Here to see 9 ways you can lose weight with Prolexitroll]
- exclusiv 10y agoYou're absolutely right. Our news media is terrible. We have reporters on "respected" shows sensationalizing flooding in canoes! [1] They love to divide us based on race, sex, whatever, but the data doesn't support their claims of crisis. And we gobble it up. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cgm3_jzcNm4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cgm3_jzcNm4
- tetrep 10y ago> My god, what a bad idea. The concentration of power in controlling what news people see is one of the huge problems of modern times. Which is one of the reasons I do not use Twitter. They wield a great deal of power, including the explicit disallowing of archives of deleted tweets[0], aka they will block you from using their service if you attempt to (publicly) archive information transmitted across it. It's like erasing logs from a program that has side-effects, or heck, even the "right" to be forgotten[1]. I dislike the idea that such power to destroy information is granted explicitly to any entity. [0]: https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/12/an-interview-with-the-anonymous-founder-of-postghost/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/12/an-interview-with-the-anon... [1]: I understand this is a contentious topic, but I think that society should accept that people are capable of change, rather than having us whitewash our pasts to appear as if we were always however we currently are. Those who forget their pasts are doomed to not respect or appreciate how both individuals and society can radically alter their courses of actions and ideals over time. It truly is as bad as erasing the bad things groups of people have done in the past.
- ultramancool 10y agoWriting a scraper for this is trivial and it's not like you're going to get caught if you're just scraping a few big name people. I definitely think this would be a good idea for political candidates and such, who the public should really have this sort of information about... A quick script that could do this with a few people and store the info locally might be a good idea, then we'd take this out of the hands of Twitter. Maybe a little PyQt GUI that can sit in your tray and scrape twitter accounts or watch via their websocket API and notify you when a tweet is deleted.
- pjc50 10y ago> The concentration of power in controlling what news people see is one of the huge problems of modern times. Not that the traditional news media is any better. Brexit would never have happened without News International. And in Italy Berlusconi was his own media support.
- randiantech 10y agoRemain camp also had a large support on media (John Oliver's LN just to mention one). So I asume Brexit could potentially had a lopsided victory without media support for pro EU. Anyway, back on main topic, having more options is always a good thing. Facebook could actually help make content streaming more accessible to many people.
- foldr 10y agoPeople don't watch John Oliver in the UK.
- randiantech 10y agoDo you have any reliable data that shows that none of the 1M+ average youtube viewers of its show are indeed non british?
- foldr 10y agoI'm sure a small number of British people watch John Oliver on youtube, but most British people don't know who he is. He certainly doesn't have a big influence on British politics. Also this: http://www.nytimes.com/live/eu-referendum/britain-television-john-oliver/ http://www.nytimes.com/live/eu-referendum/britain-television...
- EGreg 10y agoThat is why we need to decentralize social. It is not easy but we built the platform to do just that, the way Wordpress decentralized blogs and now powers 20% of the web: http://qbix.com/platform http://qbix.com/platform PS: is that WP figure still accurate or has it gone up?
- nickbauman 10y agoThe news people I know are all saying this now.
- teekq 10y agoNews today is such a waste of time. Live news is an even bigger waste. The reporting, the outrage, the novelty, the opinions are all so over the top one would think, the lack of value produced would actually cause the entire news system to fall apart. But instead I see more and more people just jumping in to prop these models of outrage, unqualified opinion, celebrity culture and worship up. Its all very sickening.
- ikeyany 10y agoIt does not seem like things will change until the masses (especially those with money and influence) reject such low standards and demand something better. Any ideas? I'm thinking something along the lines of intellectuals and entertainers forming a coalition along some hard-to-define shared interests. Those interests are so hard to define because success in the modern era depends on such sensationalism.
- teekq1 10y agoI think something is required to drive home the point to people who don't know better what a waste of time all this stuff is. Even sites like hacker news (where you would think things can be different) seem to send a signal that if you don't check us out everyday you are missing stuff. Nobody really needs to be checking hackernews everyday. Seriously. But for some reason we have this need too. And there is no reason to feed that need. Especially when it wastes everyones time. Even when there is something interesting on here, I feel my time being wasted wading through ever increasing unnecessary commentary. I'd like to see a system that deletes 80% of commentary just like StackOverflow works. If you don't know what you are talking about there should be a separate space for that. Probably IRC or a chat room. I also don't like these karma and upvote/downvote systems that every news related site seems obligated to implement. The kind of people who fixate on these numbers also turn into the biggest contributors on these sites. And that's artificial and doesn't reflect society at all.
- saurik 10y agoSites like Hacker News actually do force you to check every day as there is no way to see the content from previous days. Technically the content exists, but it becomes noise as the actual value of the site is the ranking that lets me see what people were interested in, not the raw list of all stories, and the ranking is live and "rots" over time.
- herbst 10y agoHow would a closed platform fit into this? Everytime i happen to land on a facebook link literally half of the screen is used by some penetrant ad that suggests that i should register for facebook and does not let me close it, and thats just the public links, most links are not even public so i just see a login screen. I don't see how such a closed environment would have any meaning for news. Edit:// Looking at the article the example makes it even worse. Wasnt that video censored away not even 24 hours after it happened? Again how would such a platform fit the phrase "news" in any way?
- aembleton 10y agoMost people have Facebook accounts, so they wouldn't see the login screen that you see.
- herbst 10y agoSeriously? i was not aware of that.
- squeaky-clean 10y agoOver a billion daily active users, 1.65 billion monthly. That's not including users who have an account but are not actively using it. Odds are very good that if someone has internet access, they also have a Facebook account. https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/2016/Facebook-Reports-First-Quarter-2016-Results-and-Announces-Proposal-for-New-Class-of-Stock/default.aspx https://investor.fb.com/investor-news/press-release-details/...
- herbst 10y agothats not even a fourth of humanity. if we exclude china who can not visit any of our news outlets anyway its still less than the half. Do you seriously suggest that all these people should create facebook accounts, including all the privacy issues, just so they can consume news without the half screen dedicated to forcing them to create a account? seriously?
- hanklazard 10y agoI've been wondering: can Facebook prevent news media from rebroadcasting their Facebook Live videos? It seems that currently news outlets can rebroadcast as they like, but if this could changed legally, it seems FB could extract subscription fees from news networks to use their video. This type of scenario would cement FBL as a core service for TV news and could be a nice recurring revenue stream for FB--at least until traditional TV news disappears completely (no tears shed here).
- gruez 10y agoProbably not, unless they add a clause in their ToS saying they have an exclusive licence to whatever is uploaded to Facebook live. I don't think they'll do that though because everyone will be up in arms about it.
- aantix 10y agoWhat's nice about Facebook Live (and Periscope) is that in tense situations, the authorities could confiscate the phone but the video has already been sent server side, so there's no way to suppress the footage. With the recent streamed shooting in Minnesota, transparency into such events has just been opened up a little more for all of us. While a lot of the HN crowd hates on Facebook, the Minnesota shooting and Dallas shooting have been eye opening and it's easy to see streaming video as the next great equalizer. Obviously Facebook could start suppressing contentious video, but so far they've seemed to be pretty liberal and that's probably a separate issue. At least the technology is in place so that people can open up to the possibilities and other parallel platforms can be built if Facebook drops the ball on content policy.
- herbst 10y agoAfaik they did censure pretty much any of those relevant videos. Also Twitter offers the very same technologie except it does not fail on higher load. Twitter is also not known for censoring critical things. We really have to be careful here. Implementing the idea that Facebook as central news portal isn't so bad is going to backfire soon enough. Think about it, some random news guys may are reading HN right now to get some "technical perspectives".
- jarjoura 10y agoFacebook just publicly said they will not censor these videos.
- herbst 10y agoThey did censure completely unreasoned before and lied several times about different relevant things, who cares what they say now. Also please source if you make such claims. Edit:// They are also breaking the law constantly (Their terms are not valid in many parts of europe, they still enforce it, they do not hand over complete data when asked (tried several times) and they also do not remove accounts when removed), so seriously who cares what they claim?
- pamelabuck 10y agoYeah bad bad bad news. Anti trust already have prob regulating media co mergers and media cos are not super smart. FB having this kind of power... shudder
- hobo_mark 10y agoFacebook no, Twitter could have been, but they focused on stickers and magic ponies instead of solving discoverability.
- davidf18 10y agoiOS 10 will have immediate direct video transmission built-in.
- suhith 10y agoThe amount of engineering that has gone into this is incredible. It's true Facebook is poised to become a huge source of news and information sharing. It would be great if they could release clear guidelines regarding the type of content allowed on Facebook Live, however doing so might reduce their control as they'd have to answer to those very guidelines.
- jsprogrammer 10y ago>so there's no way to suppress the footage What? I tried to watch one of the videos through a FB link (linked from HN) and FB returned a page saying the video was gone. FB is not anti-censorship; what makes you think that they are? Hmm: HN bug. Why did this comment go under the root post instead if the comment I replied to?
- cloudjacker 10y agoAre news networks ready to change their news reporting format? I am seriously too impatient for it when live to the point news and 10 second to the point snaps are available
- shiftoutbox 10y agoNo, it's just a cesspit!