9 ms·
>Shen, the prosecutor, said city officials received a complaint from someone who had rented one of Shatford’s properties. The woman was surprised to learn that
by unethical_ban 10y ago
>Shen, the prosecutor, said city officials received a complaint from someone who had rented one of Shatford’s properties. The woman was surprised to learn that she was renting a unit that was illegal and was uncomfortable with the situation, Shen said
Seems pretty ratty to report on something so victimless, especially after participating.
- mdorazio 10y agoIt's not victimless. Your neighbors are the victims if you illegally rent out your apartment/house on Airbnb. There are good reasons why zoning laws and rental contracts forbid these things.
- aminok 10y agoVictims of what?
- Mtinie 10y agoVictims of the type of abuses and zoning code violations that lead to Airbnb introducing a product feature to try to deal with the bad PR. http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/news/a45400/airbnb-animal-house-neighbor-reporting-button/ http://www.esquire.com/news-politics/news/a45400/airbnb-anim...
- aminok 10y agoHow can someone be a victim of a zoning code violation? That's like being victimized by a school uniform violation.
- JohnTHaller 10y agoIncrease in noise, especially at odd hours. People on vacation keep wildly different hours than most folks who work 9 to 5. So you have the group who is on vacation basically in a "hotel room" sharing a wall with you on a random Tuesday night and you have to get up in the morning. Additionally, "guests" have a tendency to do things like leave doors open or let people in they don't know to apartment buildings. And, unlike hotels, there's no one watching over the front door or security systems to make up for the increase in non-residents in most apartment buildings. There's also the issue that "guests" have a higher tendency to break things. They're on vacation, they don't live there, they don't care is the attitude of a small percentage. If an apartment is rented out on Airbnb, sooner or later you're going to get some of them. And if they break the building's front door or trash the lobby... sorry, but Airbnb's insurance policy doesn't cover that. It only covers things owned by the Airbnb user, not common areas of an apartment building. So, no thank you, I'd prefer that my apartment building was a proper apartment building where residents live here. As opposed to half apartment building, half unlicensed and unregulated pseudo hotel/hostel.
- aminok 10y ago>There's also the issue that "guests" have a higher tendency to break things. So discriminate against guests based on statistics related to members of their group? That sounds familiar...... If there is a problem behavior, that behavior should be punished. Entire classes of people shouldn't have their economic rights limited based on a blanket characterisation.
- varjag 10y agoCorporation's customer is not a protected class.
- aminok 10y agoSo because we haven't created a law designating some group, defined by the consensual behavior they have in common, a protected class, it's morally okay to discriminate against them? Also, you mention "corporation's customers", so am I correct to assume that you ascribe to a moral system that sees anything that is associated with corporations as immoral and fair game for mistreatment and discrimination?
- varjag 10y agoI said "corporation's customers" because AirBNB is a corporation, don't read between the lines too hard. Protected classes are not arbitrary, in most cases they are groups of people who are not self-selected. You can't easily change your age or skin color, but it is trival to use booking.com instead of airbnb. Likening your right to party 0300 in an airbnb rental flat to civil rights movement is disingenuous.
- aminok 10y agoYou didn't answer my question. If you believed your ideology was morally right, you would not shy away from directly answering questions about its values. Here's the question again: So because we haven't created a law designating some group, defined by the consensual behavior they have in common, a protected class, it's morally okay to discriminate against them?
- ersii 10y ago> There are good reasons why zoning laws and rental contracts forbid these things. Could you please elaborate on those good reasons or mention an example or two?
- mdorazio 10y agoYes. The big ones are noise, littering, damage to property/common areas, parking reduction, increased housing costs for residents, and decreased community benefits (ex. it's impossible to get to know your neighbors and help each other out if your neighbors are different every week). Short term rentals are often (though obviously not always) filled by visitors who want to party and have fun in the city with little regard for neighbors and care for property, as opposed to residents who want to have a nice, comfortable place to live. This results in an overall decreased quality of life for your neighbors if you start randomly renting out to strangers. See other responses in this thread for more more as well.
- unethical_ban 10y agoHow? If I rent to polite, responsible people, what's the problem? If I don't, and raucus behavior ensues, then follow the procedures in place for reporting disruptive behavior.
- Tomte 10y agoIt's victimless in the same sense as tax evasion is victimless. Come to think about it, the analogy is quite apt: someone hires a plumber to fix his leaking pipe, gets an invoice and sees no tax. He then asks the plumber to give him a correct invoice with tax because he doesn't want to be complicit in tax evasion. And you're now accusing him of ratting on the plumber who just wanted to save some money.
- douche 10y agoHelp out your local plumber. Pay in cash. edit: Seriously? These guys are elbow-deep in shit on a regular basis. Washington doesn't need to wet it's beak on that.
- douche 10y agoApparently people have no idea how the handyman economy works.
- douche 10y agoSchmikes, hit a nerve here!
- jschwartzi 10y agoWe all pay our taxes here. Taxes are necessary for having the infrastructure that we have so that we can live in a civil society.
- aminok 10y agoSo it's victimless in the sense that dogmatic authoritarian "liberals" don't like it.
- werkschuwtuig 10y agoWell, the long-term effect will be that you will only be able to get a decent plumber on an anonymous online platform, at which you will have to escrow a sizable security deposit in bitcoin first. Making that kind of threats to any of the plumbers will just lead to the customer losing his security deposit. Online platforms are several orders of magnitude more efficient at enforcing anything than governments are. So, there you are.
- dominotw 10y ago>something so victimless victims are the poor people who are forced to moved even further out of the city, shutting them out of economic opportunities.
- davidw 10y agoNo, they're victims of the NIMBY neighbors as much as anyone. Who do you think is first in line to wring their hands if someone suggests building a duplex or a few apartments, that are slightly more affordable in an area like Santa Barbara? The same people complaining about AirBnB. Look at how NIMBY's react to the construction of some apartments near a community college here in Bend: http://m.ktvz.com/news/Westside-neighbors-hope-to-stop-COCC-housing-plan/40483018 http://m.ktvz.com/news/Westside-neighbors-hope-to-stop-COCC-...
- aminok 10y agoNo being able to afford something owned by someone else is no crime.
- at-fates-hands 10y ago>>Seems pretty ratty to report on something so victimless, especially after participating. I could say most white collar crime is victimless too. Should we just let all the stock brokers who embezzle money go since the only people they harm are billion dollar companies who can afford the losses? Laws are in place for a reason. The city had a problem and is trying to curtail certain behavior. This is always the case - they find someone and make an example out of them and then hopefully it acts as a deterrent for other people thinking of doing the same thing. Time will only tell if it's truly effective though.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> I could say most white collar crime is victimless too. Should we just let all the stock brokers who embezzle money go since the only people they harm are billion dollar companies who can afford the losses? Except those billion dollar companies will keep forwarding their losses until it hits some poor schmucks at the lowest end of the chain. Victimless crimes seem to be less about "lack of victims" and more about distributing and diluting the harm until a lot of unrelated people get hurt a little bit each. The problem is that humans are not like atoms hit by photons, when you need an individual "harm" packet to exceed some threshold for it to matter. They're more like pressure in tank - every little bit of distributed harm adds up.
- aminok 10y agoEmbezzlement is not victimless.. Renting your property to a short term renter is victimless. So is selling illicit drugs to a consenting adult. You need to learn what distinguishes a victimless crime from victimful crime, because your example suggests you don't understand.