4 ms·
You did have a choice to grow the beard though. Race is something that does not involve that luxury.
by pm90 10y ago
You did have a choice to grow the beard though. Race is something that does not involve that luxury.
- tcdent 10y agoTake your analogy and apply it in the other direction; pretend for a second that people were able to choose their race. Are you suggesting that having the option to make that choice is somehow a way out? It's merely symptomatic and utter blasphemy.
- FLUX-YOU 10y ago>Are you suggesting that having the option to make that choice is somehow a way out? It's merely symptomatic and utter blasphemy. This hypothetical doesn't really go anywhere because you can make the beard choice with worldly experience vs. choosing race at birth and growing up as that race. It doesn't even compare. Even if we were to change this around and ask "What if people could change their race only once in adulthood after some life experience?" the racism chart just gets two additional hate columns for the race-changers.
- tcdent 10y agoMy point is that nobody should ever have to choose; it's de-humanizing in every regard.
- pm90 10y agoI see your point. I think it wasn't the best counter. You made me realize that its actually certain things that we as a society decide as sacrosanct and not grounds for prejudice. So it can be with race, which involves no choice, but also religion, which does involve choice. Or political affiliation, which also does involve choice.
- Retra 10y agoThe only thing that really matters is people's ability to make decisions. Their religious and political views can very easily reflect a failure to make good decisions, and that has a real social cost. Race is nothing like that. Neither is most physical disability, sexual orientation, nor suitably passive statements about political matters or religious affiliation. That's why those things are protected.
- pessimizer 10y agoI am. It's about conforming to a norm and not conforming to a norm. If the norm is whiteness, no matter how much you may want to conform as a non-white person, it's not an option for you. You can't just weigh the discomfort of conforming and the discomfort of deviating and decide ultimately to go with the flow, or switch between conforming and not conforming as the cultural climate changes. As for any sentiment about whether someone "should have" to conform or not: if many people don't have the option to conform, then that angle is a part of a different conversation. It also confuses the issue - in that it places innate characteristics (which have absolutely no functional implications other than the ability to stay in the sun longer in the case of dark skin) that are focused on within a particular culture on the same level as any expression anybody wants to take i.e. once we accept everything, we'll accept black people, therefore we should be working on general acceptance of all things rather than racism specifically. It's a cop out. We have a race problem. We have a lot of problems, but race is a very serious problem. Not everything should be accepted; people need to conform in a huge number of ways, or else we don't have a civilization. Things should be taken on a case by case basis based on the degree of human suffering and the societal costs of accepting or ignoring variations from the norm. Race, in America, is maybe the most important thing we need to deal with (second only to sexism in my estimation.) Race, especially anti-black racism, pervades and corrupts everything in the US.
- vitd 10y agoWhy should that matter? You could say the same thing to a transgendered person. He or she can wear the clothes for the gender people assume they are. They have a choice. That doesn't make it any more right for people to be prejudice against them.
- panic 10y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but isn't being transgender like being gay in that you're born that way and don't have a choice?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- zeta0134 10y agoI wouldn't even say that being gay necessarily works this way. I am a gay man, and I can look back over the timeline of my life and identify several key turning points that could have caused me to take a different path. I may have decided that being gay was a "phase" and decided to be straight. To date, despite identifying as and clearly being gay, my longest relationship was with my highschool sweetheart, a woman whom I am still friends with to this day. Gender identity is fluid, and not nearly as clear cut as something like race. I'm sure there is some genetic influence that affects ones biological tendencies (For example, I am biologically attracted to men, and I can't really change that no matter how hard I wish to "will" it away) but ultimately how one expresses gender, and whom one decides to be interested in, is influenced by so many learned behaviors, social pressures, and factors that go beyond the biological component. Relationships are much more complicated than "Gee, I would like to have sex with that person." One's preferences in this regard are far more than a simple boolean variable, and the choice of expression is ultimately up to the individual. Every person will have a unique story and their own outlook on this, so I don't think it's fair to place people into boxes and say, "This is the way things work, so this is the label I will assign you." That's not fair on any basis. Not race, not gender, not sexual orientation or any attributes that are out of the control of the individual. You must instead judge the individual based on their unique characteristics, their behaviors, and their own merits, separate from the group to which they supposedly belong.
- rhizome 10y agoYour statement is complicated by the fact that "race" is not a scientific term, and is not actually a thing. However, racism does exist, but it's a social construct premised on an imaginary distinction between humans based on the amount of melanin in their skin.
- FLUX-YOU 10y agoRace is absolutely a scientific term or else there would be no studies showing African Americans are at higher risk of heart disease and diabetes
- smsm42 10y agoEastern and Central European Jews have higher risk for Tay-Sachs, but that doesn't make them a race. Also, it would be very strange if only African Americans would have higher risk of diabetes, but Canadians or British people of similar descent wouldn't.
- FLUX-YOU 10y agoThat doesn't diminish the race part of "race/ethnicity"
- rhizome 10y agoOr so racists would have you believe. However, the fact that homo sapiens do not have phylogenetic subspecies renders your argument false.