3 ms·
Maybe it's just a matter of definition, but I think that's a very tortured argument. I would say that oppression and slander are acts of violence, and coercion
by tremon 10y ago
Maybe it's just a matter of definition, but I think that's a very tortured argument. I would say that oppression and slander are acts of violence, and coercion is typically done using threats or leveraging some form of oppression. As for extremist content: sure not all extremism is (openly) violent, but are you really arguing that most extremism is non-violent, to the point where it's just "extremism is given a bad name by a few bad apples"?
- pc86 10y ago> are you really arguing that most extremism is non-violent, to the point where it's just "extremism is given a bad name by a few bad apples"? I said nothing of the sort and it takes some impressive mental gymnastics to reach that point. Extremist speech, on its own and in isolation, is not necessarily violent and should not be a crime automatically. It obviously can espouse violence and is therefore already outlawed. It may even be the fact that 99.9% of extremist speech advocates violence in one form or another. But until it does, someone should be able to spew as much racist, hateful garbage as they want.
- tremon 10y agoit takes some impressive mental gymnastics to reach that point. It really doesn't. You used the explicit phrase "extremist content [falls] under speech which does not necessary advocate violence" as an argument to exclude "extremist content" from the list of examples of actionable material, without further elaboration.