5 ms·
A Saudi Arabia Telecom's Surveillance Pitch (2013)
- jaryd 10y agoPlease add 2013 to the title.
- therealasdf 10y agoWhat bothers me most is most Saudi's are aware that they are being monitored. They assume if you have nothing to hide you shouldn't care for privacy.
- tn13 10y agoAmong the things that Saudis are aware but fine with, concern for telecom privacy is at the bottom. :D
- Eyght 10y agoIt would be interesting to see how people feel about money vs. privacy. If the choice was: 1. Guaranteed employment for everyone, at middle class- or higher, living standard. But with 100% surveillance of communications and movement. 2. Privacy and democracy but with no guarantees of employment or living standard.
- tn13 10y agoFor 1. We already have that model running in North Korea and I heard the people love it absolutely. For 2. We already have that model running in USA and I hear it is the absolute worst place to live in.
- drewcrawford 10y agoShameless self-promotion, as this article is one of several that inspired me to work on this. I have been secretly working for several years on a drop-in iOS technology based on the latest peer-reviewed crypto research, pinned certificates, PFS, and implemented in a safe language that doesn't buffer overflow. It's invitation-only right now but many customers are running it in production. We have to position it as a performance technology (and it's very very fast) since security doesn't make sales. But my personal goal is to Make Things Dark Again™. Unfortunately the hardest part of security work is funding it–performance and business concerns drive a lot of the conversations which limit how much time is left to work on making bulletproof transport security dead simple for app developers. And it needs to be dead simple to get deployed in enough apps to protect the average user from pervasive surveillance. But if you believe in the problem, and your employer can create a budget for the problem, I would love to chat with you (email in my profile). There is still time to rewrite the future and keep totalitarian governments out of our communication. We just have to decide we actually care enough to make it happen.
- Canada 10y agoHow does your idea compare to noise protocol or QUIC?
- drewcrawford 10y agoNoise is not really a protocol but a toolkit to build one. It's really a symptom of the problem. We expect individual developers to take these tools and figure it out, when they won't because they don't care enough. If by some miracle they care they will probably screw it up unless they like reading crypto papers. It also has various practical problems (e.g. the 64k message limit) that you have to deal with some way, probably at the expense of performance which is a useful vehicle to sell security technology, possibly at the expense of security (e.g. early session termination). QUIC is more interesting and I'm evaluating if we can deploy a modified form of it into our transport layer. The key problem with QUIC alone is that in practice many networks block UDP traffic, so you need a TCP fallback solution so customers don't complain that every other app works except yours. But when your threat model is "government compels certificates" then you can't fallback to TLS. The government will just block UDP traffic at the router, downgrade you to TLS, and now they've got you. This is one consequence of a larger design issue: QUIC is trying to provide "equivalent" security to TLS, but if your threat model is "something is wrong with TLS" that's not enough.
- Canada 10y agoHow about something like spiped?
- drewcrawford 10y agospiped is GREAT tech, and shares a lot of the same philosophy: small implementation, simplified protocol, no negotiation, key pinning, etc. It is really, really solid for the problem it solves. However, it's designed around a simplified threat model. In spiped, you use pre-shared keys (the same key on client and server), that "somehow" you got a copy onto both systems without anyone seeing them. But you can't just drop your key into a mobile app binary, submit to the app store, and expect people not to reverse-engineer it and start reading other people's traffic. So now you need to figure out how to derive spiped keys on a per-session basis in a cryptographer-approved way™ and distribute them securely and verify the key someone told you to use is not actually from the NSA, and then on top of that think about perfect forward secrecy and certificate pinning and various other "beyond TLS" guarantees. There are solutions to all those problems, tarsnap ships really cool solutions, but we are not talking about spiped anymore, we're talking about spiped and a long list of other things, and the other things are easy to get wrong if your name is not cpervia. Another practical problem with spiped is the performance degrades for small messages. This doesn't matter if your use case is doing backups, but if your use case is "I typed the letter 'c' in the search bar and where are my search results? I thought this was supposed to be a performance technology" it matters a LOT.
- Mao_Zedang 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Council#Saudi_Arabia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Human_Rights_Co... The UN has always been a joke in my eyes because of this.
- ZainRiz 10y ago"In January 2016, Saudi Arabia executed the prominent Shia cleric Sheikh Nimr who had called for free elections in Saudi Arabia" Sounds like a perfect candidate for the UN Human Rights Commission.
- lifeisstillgood 10y agoA few things leap out - WhatsApp's TLS is insecure but twitters is ok? I assumed everyone would use the same stack. - hang on - whatsapp now uses silent protocol right? Isn't it now really secure and a billion people have it? But apart from that, I am honestly burying my head over this stuff. I have a job and family and tv to watch and now I have to "Understand a complex moving environment and make sure I am secure whilst still providing my family with access to Facebook and hang on that printer wants to send photos to where!. I give up" I think a set of good baseline practises would be good to start with. Begin by flashing your commercial Router with openWRT or building a router with RPi and then moving onwards. How can we live a connected life without polluting - it's a hard problem and one I realise I need help with. Speak up though, I have sand in my ears