4 ms·
I think you're mistaken. Cruise missiles, robots, and even nuclear weapons are a way to defend your home territory from other violent nation-states, perhaps at
by InclinedPlane 17y ago
I think you're mistaken. Cruise missiles, robots, and even nuclear weapons are a way to defend your home territory from other violent nation-states, perhaps at the cost of significant "enemy" civilian casualties. However, the nature of warfare is changing, if you look at the major conflicts in the last 20 years you see a lot more need for not just precision guided munitions hitting targets from afar but also smart, well-trained, well-equipped ground forces with the flexibility to respond to different situations.
The entire Russian army was fought to a stand-still in Afghanistan and later also in Chechnya by much smaller, less well equipment forces using modern insurgent techniques. The "press a button to win a war" methodology only works in the modern age if you're willing to carpet bomb the enemy and any civilians who happen to get in the way (see the horrible civil war in Sri Lanka as an example). If you're not willing to do that then you'll need more than just CPU guided munitions.
- marshallp 17y agoI always thought this "urban warfare" stuff BS. At what point is it actually just law enforcement ? The problem with the russians in afghanistan and americans in iraq/afghanistan today is what exacty is the objective ? Technically the russians and americans won easily in the first few days. The rest of the time was just pretend warfare that should have been just called law enforcement. When you send soldiers to fight civilians you've already failed. There's nothing you can achieve except slaughter.
- derefr 17y ago"Soldier" vs "civilian" is a false dichotomy. In the middle, there's "militia", which you're a part of as soon as you pick up a weapon and start pushing back on the "law enforcement"'s encroachment upon your city.
- marshallp 17y agoYou could call that "militia" the local police department and pay them money to police that local population. If the hearts of a population are not with you, sending a military in is just barbaric. That battle can never be won.
- rdtsc 17y ago> If the hearts of a population are not with you, sending a military in is just barbaric. Most countries that have been conquered were not conquered by love or friendship but by barbaric brutality. Not saying I approve, I don't. It is just what usually happens. One would just take over the hospitals, water treatment plants, power plants and news stations. Then see how long people are going to stay on their roofs with their rifles. I am guessing not too long. "Live free or die" is a good slogan. But most people would buckle and sell their country for a hot egg McMuffin if they haven't eaten in a week.
- plinkplonk 17y ago"One would just take over the hospitals, water treatment plants, power plants and news stations. Then see how long people are going to stay on their roofs with their rifles." Large parts of Afghanistan don't have any hospitals, water treatment plants, power plants and news stations. As far as I can see the US "liberation" forces are still getting shot at or blown up. You underestimate how people dislike invaders in their streets and disrupting their lives. I suspect even Americans who live in relative luxury and have all the above would fight to the death against (say) Chinese soldiers patrolling their cities.
- rdtsc 17y agoInteresting. Why did you assume Afghanistan? I had America in mind... It is much harder to take over a country where everyone is already self-sufficient. It would be hard to take over Africa, as many villages are more or less self sufficient. They are not doing great but they can survive without a Starbucks. The same in Afghanistan. If someone has a herd of goats, a well, and the ability to grow some edible plants, they might be alright and will keep fighting. Now try shutting down power, water, hospitals and grocery stores in US and see what happens. The most advanced a society is, the more dependent the people are dependent on multiple layers of private and governmental services. And I guess, that makes them in a certain way more vulnerable. (How did I even think of this? I witnessed what happened when there was a large power outage in Ohio last year). > I suspect even Americans who live in relative luxury and have all the above would fight to the death aginst (say) Chinese soldiers patrolling their cities. I think you have a very optimistic view of our fellow Americans. I saw them get desperate when they couldn't take a shower for 2 weeks. Another 2-3 month and many would have pledged allegiance to the first country providing hot showers and hot egg mcmuffins.
- Zev 17y agoThe entire Russian army was fought to a stand-still in Afghanistan and later also in Chechnya by much smaller, less well equipment forces using modern insurgent techniques. (In my admittedly limited knowledge,) I don't know if Afghanistan is the best example of the United States (I'll assume this is the state being discussed from marshallp's "the military") not being able to adapt; the Afghan mujahideen received a lot of training and weapons from the CIA, through Pakistan's IFI. OTOH, (again, in my admittedly limited knowledge,) Chechnya is a very good example of a more "modern" style of war; Russia only really gained the upper hand and managed to force a ceasefire after the Chechen rebels lost popularity (which was after they took something like 1,500 people hostage, including mothers with newborns).
- Perceval 17y agoThere were actually two Chechen wars and they were fought differently. The First Chechen War was fought with the regular Russian Army being used indiscriminately against Chechens. Instead of intelligently targeting the separatist forces, Russian tank columns simply shelled Chechen cities. Despite the heavy death toll (into the 100s of thousands), the Chechens won a semi-autonomous republic in the terms of the ceasefire. The Second Chechen War began when Putin was installed following Yeltsin. The Chechen republic was predictably corrupt and poor following the devastation of the first war. Stupidly, the top military commander of the Chechens, Shamil Basayev, launched an incursion into the neighboring republic of Dagestan. Putin was then able to 'finish the job' in Chechnya. The Russian strategy in the second war was different—they used the intelligence services and local proxies to fight the war rather than depending primarily on army conscripts. They installed a Chechen named Ramzan Kadyrov in as the head of Chechnya, and he fought the separatist Chechens working hand-in-hand with the Russian FSB (successor to the KGB). The second war was a success for the Russians—they had a reliable client in Kadyrov, the Chechen strategies got more desperate (e.g. the seige in Beslan), and the top commanders of the separatists were betrayed and killed (Aslan Maskhadov and Shamil Basayev principally). The Chechen separatists are still out there, but the fighting is very low level. Their current commander, Doku Umarov, hasn't led a major assault on Kadyrov or Russia yet. I don't think the Chechen cause rose or fell with their popularity. I think it had more to do with the anti-insurgent strategy pursued by Russia.