3 ms·
> That doesn't matter. The important question is not "Does this new technology solve all previous problems?" but rather "Does this technology solve a net positi
by the8472 10y ago
> That doesn't matter. The important question is not "Does this new technology solve all previous problems?" but rather "Does this technology solve a net positive number of problems while offering more opportunities for improvement?"
To play advocatus diaboli: Shouldn't it be sufficient for the autopilot to be as good as the worst human drivers that we still let on the road? Or to sharpen the point: As good as the worst licensed drivers under human supervision (compare learner's permit)?
After all the technology is still "learning", under human supervision. And similarly a teenager having a parent as co-pilot does not only endanger their own life but also those of others too.
So if those are allowed on the road with the expectation that they'll get better and that giving them a licence will eventually have net benefits, shouldn't that apply to self-driving cars too?
- tedunangst 10y agoIf there are more Teslas than worst human drivers, that would be a net negative. The threshold should be that a Tesla must be at least as good as the Xth percentile, based on the number of drivers replaced. Or higher. If autopilot is instead replacing the best drivers, that's also a net negative.