4 ms·
I think the underlying question of parent is: Uber is illegal in many European countries, so why did they back out of Hungary as opposed to, say, Norway?
by wodenokoto 10y ago
I think the underlying question of parent is: Uber is illegal in many European countries, so why did they back out of Hungary as opposed to, say, Norway?
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThat's a good question. Possible answers are that Hungarian market may not have turned out profitable enough for Uber to fight for it, and/or maybe authorities in Hungary are swifter than in Norway - similar to how Poland is still struggling with Uber while Germany managed to quickly ban the illegal parts.
- niftich 10y agoHungary's current government takes a dim view on a number of topics and strongly favors the rule of law, or the appearance of enforcing those laws. In 2015, refugees and migrants were walking across the border with Serbia, so the government installed a wall topped with razor wire to corral them towards the designated entry points [1] In 2010, the country's laws for press and media were significantly changed, drawing widespread EU criticism [2]. (I'm providing context, not wishing to engage in political conversation) I think Uber made a judgement call that the Hungarian government would likely enforce the laws rather harshly, and did not want to deal with the consequences. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_border_barrier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hungarian_border_barrier [2] https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-press/2015/hungary https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-press/2015/hungary
- dzsekijo 10y agoThe background story is: in Hungary, about one year before Uber's entry, large taxi companies lobbied for a very heavy regulation on transport services that fixed the rates and raised drivers' entry level significantly. The said purpose was to kill off the "taxi hyenas", but the reason and effect was to end competition by enforcing a uniformized premium level service. "Taxi hyenas" were replaced by the "taxi maffia" -- but not just the hyenas, but small and (to some rate) innovative companies were gone out of business. The taxi drivers who remained in business were in for the trade-off of investing into compliance with new regulation but making more money than before. So old school taxi was not simply lingering in its naturally backward state as in other countries, but there was an artificially fortified status quo. In that situation, when value personal transfer reappeared with Uber, it was therefore even more sore for the taxi companies and drivers, who took their position and the protection of their investment granted by the state. So what happened is nothing else just the taxi maffia enforced this grant and the state complied. Both sticking to decisions that once made (no regard of consequences), and heavy state control is quite to the taste of the government -- thus they complied happily. And once the government puts its weight into something, there is no question it's gonna happen. The only surprise element is that Uber resisted so far.