4 ms·
> Again, in any sane world nobody would pay any attention to the opinions of completely unqualified individuals on any given topic. There's a reason I write for
by danso 10y ago
> Again, in any sane world nobody would pay any attention to the opinions of completely unqualified individuals on any given topic. There's a reason I write for Road & Track and not Men's Health, for example, and it has something to do with the fact that I've literally had more racing wins in my life than I've eaten salads. If I started pontificating about whether a particular protein supplement built more muscle mass and got you more ripped than another one, the readers would be entirely right to point out that I am not a doctor and that I have never been seen to bench press more than 255 pounds, not even once.
Reminds me of the Tragedy of Theranos. A company valued at $9 billion, staffed to the gills with engineers and medical experts who were building a revolutionary disruptive way to draw and test blood, was taken down based on the accusations of a newspaper reporter who has never run his own startup, nevermind having not attained enough medical expertise to even competently check someone's temperature.
I'm being a little facetious here. There's a difference between a cable news reporter blabbing about something that happened 7 minutes ago to fill an hour of airtime with controversy and fear, and a 5-month investigation by a Pulitzer-winning reporter. But let's not shit on the laypersons who dare to challenge the clergy.
But in one aspect I agree with the OP. People who aren't experts and who don't bother to check with other experts should perhaps be mindful before they propagate uninformed armchair analysis. But let's make that cut both ways. These uninformed reporters should also hold their tongues when a company touts any technical feature. Maybe that would reduce the incentive for the Elon Musks of the world to name things in viral-headline-friendly ways, e.g. "Autopilot" for advanced driver assist. Tesla has benefited heavily from the press corps ignorance about technology -- you think Tesla has received $4 billion in government subsidies based on technical merit alone? And now they're paying for it. Maybe 10 years from now we'll all agree that that was a good strategic gamble. But it doesn't mean Tesla should be given kid glove treatment today, after the effort they've put in to manipulate the press to their own benefit.
- studentrob 10y ago> People who aren't experts and who don't bother to check with other experts should perhaps be mindful before they propagate uninformed armchair analysis I believe some of this controversy began with an article by Fortune [1] in which they claimed Musk overlooked some business reporting requirements. Do you agree that a financial news outlet is qualified to judge a company based on how they report to the SEC? The world of corporate finance is their wheel house, and that spans to any company, tech or not. The larger the valuation of the company, the more interesting the news would be to them. Fortune's readers are current or would-be Tesla investors. [1] http://fortune.com/2016/07/05/elon-musk-tesla-autopilot-stock-sale/ http://fortune.com/2016/07/05/elon-musk-tesla-autopilot-stoc...
- danso 10y agoThat definitely falls into the field of Fortune's expertise. But I took OP's comment to be a broadside against the alarmist headlines about the recent accidents.
- studentrob 10y ago> I took OP's comment to be a broadside against the alarmist headlines about the recent accidents. Yeah. I feel the Fortune article came out, then Musk claimed it was BS, and other headlines both critical and defensive of Tesla started popping up. Fortune's legitimate criticism has been overlooked by many who believe Musk can do no wrong. At this point, Musk has tweeted in response to the article from Road and Track titled "Leave Tesla Alone", > "We don't mind taking the heat for customer safety. It is the right thing to do" Perhaps tensions are easing between Musk and Fortune.