4 ms·
That statement is problematic, namely this: > The infringing content was not removed within the specified period even though several notifications were issued.
by Someone1234 10y ago
That statement is problematic, namely this:
> The infringing content was not removed within the specified period even though several notifications were issued.
You don't have to remove content under the DMCA, you can also file a counter-notice which gets the content host off the hook and then the matter goes to court[0].
But that also assumes DMCA which, if memory serves, was not in play here. It was a trademark complaint, which DigitalOcean has no responsibility to resolve.
Ultimately DigitalOcean's response, even with that statement, seems at odds with how the law is actually written. The other party also claimed they did respond to DigitalOcean, they just never removed the legal parody material which is their right.
DigitalOcean's understanding of the NRA's rights is more expansive than the law itself. Effectively their trademark policy is to automatically side with the trademark holder, irrespective of fair use[1] (see page 9+).
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Act#Title_II:_Online_Copyright_Infringement_Liability_Limitation_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_A...
[1] https://apps.americanbar.org/litigation/committees/intellectual/roundtables/0506_outline.pdf https://apps.americanbar.org/litigation/committees/intellect...
- franey 10y agoIt's against DO's terms of service to "use the Services in violation of the copyrights, trademarks, patents or trade secrets of third parties", which appears to be the issue here. https://www.digitalocean.com/legal/terms/ https://www.digitalocean.com/legal/terms/
- kbenson 10y ago> Effectively their trademark policy is to automatically side with the trademark holder, irrespective of fair use[1] (see page 9+). Did you miss that? It's not infringement if it falls under fair use. They were not following their TOS because they did not confirm the content was infringing a copyright
- fweespeech 10y agoExpecting a hosting provider to wade into fair use waters hand-in-hand with you is generally unwise. The vast majority will not unless you are a large customer with your own legal staff on retainer to provide the appropriate legalese/notices/etc.
- kbenson 10y agoI don't expect that, but I do expect that a company not immediately kowtow to an infringement request if there is some ambiguity as to whether it's infringing. That said, the original reporting on this and the statement from DigitalOcean are at odds (Motherboard's update with DO's statement), and since I haven't verified either, I'll retract any specific support for either side of this particular instance.
- fweespeech 10y ago> I don't expect that, but I do expect that a company not immediately kowtow to an infringement request if there is some ambiguity as to whether it's infringing. That requires money for a lawyer to evaluate it. If the customer has their own legal staff that does this and relays that opinion to the host, as well as being large enough to cover any legal costs DO might incur, DO would be fine with it. You are basically saying you are entitled to using DO's legal staff and financial resources in addition to the hosting you've paid for.
- kbenson 10y ago> You are basically saying you are entitled to using DO's legal staff and financial resources in addition to the hosting you've paid for. No, what I'm saying is that DO must already do this to some degree if they are handling requests, as otherwise I could send letters claiming trademark/copyright infringement for any number of things and get many customers shut down. If they have internal guidelines for what they do in cases when trademark/copyright infringement, I expect they follow those. I also expect that those policies do the minimum legally required of them. That's not because it's cheaper and garners good will from customers (it does), but because to do otherwise is taking sides in a legal situation without being an appointed arbiter of the law. Not only is this excessive, but it's anti-customer. If DO is doing what they think they must by law, I have no problem with that, as long as that is clearly explained. In the case we were previously talking about, the statement from DO (at the motherboard article) is somewhat ambiguous as to why they did what they did. Per DigitalOcean’s terms of service, a final reminder was issued to our customer and, when no action was taken, access to the content was disabled. Was the take down required by law, or was DO overly aggressive in handling it? Without a statement as to why, (and I think that given some people's assertion that they went beyond what was legally required of them), their reasoning is somewhat ambiguous, and harder to call into question. If they clearly define they enforced their TOS based on what they believe is a legally required of them, then we can look at the law and their actions and evaluate whether that's true, and if it's not, DO can learn from the experience or be called out as a company that is capricious in their execution of the law. What it boils down to is that "We received a complaint infringement. We enforced our TOS and shut down access to the content in question." leaves a lot open for assumption. I would be much happier if it was "We received a complaint infringement and as we believe is legally required of us we enforced our TOS and shut down access to the content in question." It's a small change, but it allows customers (and critics) a much clearer view on how DO handles situations like this, and allows for the public to make an informed choice on whether they think DO was correct in their actions (whether they really were legally required to do so). It's subtle, but I think it's a very, very important distinction.
- abiox 10y ago> if it falls under fair use i'm under the impression that "fair use" is a defense and/or judge's assessment, rather than something "civilians" can factually declare.
- fenomas 10y agoThe same is true of "violation of the copyrights, trademarks, patents or trade secrets of third parties".
- abiox 10y agohence when a DMCA takedown is received, i don't see how DO is in a position to assess that something is or is not a violation. they simply follow the process outlined in the legislation.
- blahi 10y agoAn that process has a provision for the customer to file a dispute and this obsolves the host and sends the matter to court. Ot did you Miss that comment?
- abiox 10y agosure, a claim can in turn result in a counter claim. i'm not sure why you're asking if i missed such a comment.
- stefs 10y ago> But that also assumes DMCA which, if memory serves, was not in play here.