3 ms·
I'd like to ask the question from the other direction: what do you propose should be done to law enforcement officers who collect evidence illegally? As it sta
by mikeash 10y ago
I'd like to ask the question from the other direction: what do you propose should be done to law enforcement officers who collect evidence illegally?
As it stands today, we accept a sort of compromise. Law enforcement is typically not punished for collecting evidence illegally, but the evidence is discarded, giving them a strong incentive to follow the rules.
Do you accept the evidence but throw the responsible people in jail? That's probably going to have a major chilling effect on law enforcement in general, since they encounter a lot of ambiguous situations. But if you don't punish them, then collecting evidence illegally might as well be legal.
Think about it this way: it's not a waste to discard illegally collected evidence, it's a waste to collect evidence illegally. That ends up saying the same basic thing, except it directs the blame at the party that's actually responsible for doing it wrong.
- effie 10y agoFor illegal actions, they should be investigated, judged and if necessary, punished. Just as regular citizens would be for such actions. Being in law enforcement does not mean you get extra slack when violating a law, it means you enforce the law. But if a police officer violates the law, they diminished the rule and respect for the law. > the evidence is discarded, giving them a strong incentive to follow the rules. I don't think that is a strong incentive at all. Such absurd exception from law enforcement is so advantageous to the criminal elements in the police and the government that they will use it to their advantage. A situation where one part of government is allowed to violate the law by another part of government with no law enforcement action means the checks and balances aren't working.