5 ms·
Autism as a Disorder of High Intelligence
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Retric 10y agoThis is confusing genetic markers for intelligence with intelligence. Building half a bridge is not useful, and individual markers don't stand alone.
- enord 10y agoHe mentions that a: autists are dumber (i.e. do not express some or most of the markers for high intelligence) but posess the genetic markers, and b: the expression of intelligence markers of siblings/parents/higher-order relatives of autists (specifically) is understudied and recommends it for further study. [As far as I read it anyway] I do believe that the "imbalance"-hypothesis he presents is a bit vague and proposes several imbalances according to different (and possibly orthogonal) models for intelligence, making it seem a bit unfalsifiable to me. Who knows. Behavioral neuroscience based on MRI(or similar modalities) is a giant sandcastle anyway, best not stack those results too high.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoI agree that the details in some areas were vague, but this is a broad overview and could lead to something testable if the research is followed through. The short version, to me, was that general intelligence is based on several cognitive axes working together. I believe the paper lists 3-4 most of which were separable, like verbal scores, mental rotation tests, etc. And with Autism, you have 1-2 of those axes working above average but the rest not. To falsify, you could break down IQ tests for individuals with autism and compare some areas with the general population and also with each other. If they match the expected pattern, they may be onto something, otherwise the theory is incorrect.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoFrom what I read, that is exactly the point the author is trying to make. Namely that having some of the markers for high IQ, and missing others causes their overall performance to drop even if there are a few areas where they are above average.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoIt just doesn't stand up to scrutiny, especially given how many people are autistic.
- LifeQuestioner 10y agoAn estimated 1% of the population currently (including those estimated as not diagnosed). Subject to rise as the DM-4/5 diagnostic criteria adapts. Why does this fact of 1% of the population, mean the article is not viable?
- Aoyagi 10y agoI'd think the amount dropped significantly once Asperger's was removed from the spectrum in DSM-5 (although this article seems to ignore that fact).
- Aelinsaar 10y agoAsperger's was folded into the spectrum, and the actual condition was removed as a "standalone".
- RankingMember 10y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but my understanding was that references to "Aspergers" were removed, but the diagnosis was basically just rolled into the greater "Autism spectrum" diagnosis.
- scott_s 10y agoThat's not my understanding of what happened in DSM-5. My understanding is that Asperger's was removed as a separate diagnoses, as it now falls under Autistic Spectrum Disorder. The Wikipedia article seems to match my prior understanding (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autism_spectrum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autism_spectrum), "The DSM-5 redefined the autism spectrum to encompass the previous (DSM-IV-TR) diagnoses of autism, Asperger syndrome, pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified (PDD-NOS), and childhood disintegrative disorder."
- preordained 10y agoOne popular anecdote or perhaps paraphrased statistical tidbit in the last few years was that incidences of autism were unusually high in Silicon Valley and particularly children of developers. Not that all developers have "high" intelligence--but higher than average on the whole? Just wondering if there might be any strengthening arguments to be made from connected studies. Of course, could be a red herring that masks the critical factors, but if we had to bet on the likelihood of a connection...maybe something there.
- timwaagh 10y agoyou might as well check a sample of developers for this disease and check against a sample of the general population. its not just the children, you know.
- hguant 10y agoThis article reports on a study finding a link between "systems thinking" oriented parents and autism. http://arstechnica.com/science/2011/06/kids-autism-may-be-result-of-parents-talent-for-system-oriented-thinking/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2011/06/kids-autism-may-be-re...
- a_bonobo 10y agoOne possible mechanism: One of the proposed reasons for the recent rise in levels of autism is that more autistic children are sent to the psychiatrist. You need to be relatively "rich" to be able to afford sending your child to the psychiatrist. Most programmers in Silicon Valley are relatively rich. Therefore, more children are sent to the psychiatrist in Silicon Valley than in the "rest" of the population, so more children with autism are diagnosed.
- matt_morgan 10y agoAll of their markers for intelligence are suspect. > including full-scale IQ and a PCA-based measure of g (Clarke et al., 2015), childhood IQ, college attendance, and years of education (Bulik-Sullivan et al., 2015), cognitive function in childhood and educational attainment (Hill et al., 2015), and verbal-numerical reasoning and educational level reached (Hagenaars et al., 2016) I bet all those markers are more closely correlated with income levels in childhood than with occurrence of autism (or anything else).
- jackmott 10y agoKnowing, in isolation, that IQ is more closely correlated with income levels in childhood than IQ is with thing X, does not imply that IQ is not a causal contributor of X. It could just be the case that IQ is partly genetic (in fact, it is) and that IQ may be a causal factor in income levels to a stronger degree than it is for autism or other things.
- porejide 10y agoRight, and in fact this is known to be the case: http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/04/16/048991 http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/04/16/048991 My summary: https://brainslab.wordpress.com/2016/05/07/shared-genetic-correlations-of-psychiatric-and-neurologic-disorders/ https://brainslab.wordpress.com/2016/05/07/shared-genetic-co...
- hardcandy 10y agoHasn't IQ been proven to be not just partly, but mostly genetic? Barring exposure to outright toxic environmental conditions.
- skylark 10y agoIQ has the highest genetic correlation out of any trait we've observed in Psychology - r ~ 0.7 if I recall correctly from my college days.
- 10y ago
- CodeWriter23 10y agoSome background on this particular journal: http://www.nature.com/news/backlash-after-frontiers-journals-added-to-list-of-questionable-publishers-1.18639 http://www.nature.com/news/backlash-after-frontiers-journals...
- deepnet 10y agoEric Raymond's take : "Neurotypicals spend most of their cognitive bandwidth on mutual grooming and status-maintainance activity." http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=7060#more-7060 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=7060#more-7060
- clifanatic 10y agoWell, I know I'm definitely too weird to get a date. It's nice to think that means I'm intelligent.
- woodandsteel 10y agoI am not at all an expert on autism, but my understanding is that one of its features is a strong deficiency in the ability to read human nonverbal communication.