5 ms·
In the long run, the more dangerous criminal is the government itself if unchecked. Yes, it is frustrating to have criminals go free because police or prosecuto
by tremon 10y ago
In the long run, the more dangerous criminal is the government itself if unchecked. Yes, it is frustrating to have criminals go free because police or prosecutor fucked up -- but government holds both the power of law and the power of (sanctioned) violence. If even they cannot be expected to follow their own law, why are they expecting others to follow it?
Your hypothetical is clear: the defendant's counsel would ask the judge to throw out the case, and the judge would comply. To make it a bit less hypothetical: what if the compelling piece of evidence was obtained through torturing a witness?
(edit: also, a "dangerous serial killer" is not so until a judge has convicted him/her. You are begging the question by presuming guilt)
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> what if the compelling piece of evidence was obtained through torturing a witness? The standard reply is that evidence obtained from torture can't be compelling because it is by definition unreliable. I've never been happy with that, since some claims can easily be independently verified. (For example, if I wanted credentials for a bank account belonging to Bill Gates, and I tortured him for those credentials, I wouldn't be too worried over the fact that someone under torture will be willing to say anything to stop it, and thus I can never really know if he was telling the truth about his credentials -- I can just try to take money, and if it doesn't work I'll keep torturing him.) Once we stipulate that the compelling evidence obtained from torture is known to be true, I think you'll find that a lot of people still consider this a tough question. > edit: also, a "dangerous serial killer" is not so until a judge has convicted him/her. You are begging the question by presuming guilt No, a dangerous serial killer is one regardless of conviction. It's fair game to have whatever facts you want in a thought experiment.
- joncrocks 10y ago> No, a dangerous serial killer is one regardless of conviction. True enough, but the point he raises is at what point do you justify illegal actions. In your example, torture may or not bear fruit, depending on if your suppositions are correct. The point is generally that in order for extreme measures to be taken, extreme justification must be given. And in general the justifications needed for torture would be so high that you would probably be able to convict without it, i.e. You can only torture someone if you knew beyond any doubt they dunnit. The point of restricting the collection of evidence is to ensure that law enforcement go through a process with justification at each stage. This is to protect innocent/law abiding from law enforcement itself, as a lot of the acts they go through in the course of their business would be illegal if they were not law enforcement.
- tremon 10y agoYou can only torture someone if you knew beyond any doubt they dunnit. I asked about torturing a witness though, not the suspect.
- hx87 10y ago> And in general the justifications needed for torture would be so high that you would probably be able to convict without it It's so high that IMHO the only possible place for torture in a civilized legal system is as punishment for torture by someone acting in a position of authority; if you're at the point where the moral calculus favors torture, you give absolutely zero fucks about what happens to yourself afterwards.
- pjc50 10y ago> a dangerous serial killer is one regardless of conviction. But how do you know whether the person presented in the dock is a dangerous serial killer? > It's fair game to have whatever facts you want in a thought experiment. The whole point of a trial is to establish facts. In reality, we cannot ever guarantee things like this; we can only ever say how convincing the evidence is for a particular history of events.
- maxerickson 10y agoBut how do you know whether the person presented in the dock is a dangerous serial killer? For the thought experiment you could go with clear video evidence that had been tainted by a bad search.
- pjc50 10y agoTBH, if we want an example, OJ Simpson is good: he was eventually found to have wrongfully killed his wife in civil court, but at his initial murder trial he was acquitted due to (among other things) poor evidence handling by the LAPD. There were widespread accusations of attempts to 'frame' OJ and of police racism. It was both right and necessary to discard the questionable evidence, otherwise a large part of the public would have believed that he was wrongly convicted. Evidence is not just for the courtroom, it's to rule out allegations of improper conviction and unfair treatment by the general public.
- mikeash 10y agoKeep in mind that the standard of proof in a civil trial is a lot lower. Being found liable in a civil trial doesn't mean he should have been found guilty at the criminal trial. I agree that OJ probably did it based on what's known, I'm just nitpicking that one bit.
- hx87 10y agoFor thought experiments that are applicable to real life, you should not presume knowledge that nobody in the experiment has access to.
- mseebach 10y ago> The standard reply is that evidence obtained from torture can't be compelling because it is by definition unreliable You're conflating the reason evidence from torture is inadmissible with one of the arguments against torture. Evidence from torture can't be admitted because we won't condone torture, ever (or, that's the theory, the real world is more, erhm, nuanced). The fact that intelligence from torture is unreliable is just one of a suite of arguments against torturing people in the first place, not a universal fact which is true for any information obtained through torture. > since some claims can easily be independently verified That's basically the Jack Bauer school of torture: You have a bad guy, and you know for a fact that he knows where the bomb is, and if/when he tells you, you can confirm immediately. If that situation occurred in the real world, I would assume that most people would bite their tongues and accept torture. But there is no evidence that it does. It's "What was your role in planning the attack? Who is the person in this picture? Who knows where Osama is hiding?" [source: Zero Dark Thirty] -- Sure, eventually, you can sort-of confirm these things, but torture really isn't effective if you have months-long feedback cycles.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago>> The standard reply is that evidence obtained from torture can't be compelling because it is by definition unreliable > You're conflating the reason evidence from torture is inadmissible with one of the arguments against torture. No, I'm complaining that in much of what I read on this topic, the argument I stated is presented in the terms I stated it in: no evidence given under torture can ever be trusted, because people under torture will say whatever you tell them to say. I find that aggravating, because it is clearly wrong. It's misleading to say it's one of a suite of arguments presented against torturing people in the first place; it is one of two, the other being that we shouldn't torture people because it is invariably morally wrong. I don't think it's a coincidence that arguments that we should never torture people no matter what rely so heavily on different premises of invariability. But while the moral-incorrectness invariability claim can be defended, the untrustworthiness invariability claim can't be.
- vermontdevil 10y agoAgreed. I fear the government more than a serial killer.
- joering2 10y agoBeautiful answer, tremon. +1