3 ms·
With respect to oppressive effects, how well exactly has capitalism (Or, if we want to split hairs, imperialism) worked out for Cuba's Carribean and Latin Ameri
by vkou 10y ago
With respect to oppressive effects, how well exactly has capitalism (Or, if we want to split hairs, imperialism) worked out for Cuba's Carribean and Latin American neighbours?
Cuba is towards the top of that list, by life expectancy, caloric intake, GDP per capita, literacy, child mortality.
Cuba has a lot of problems... But still it turned out far better then, say, Haiti, or Honduras ever will be, despite all the benefits of open markets. This is consistently missing from the narrative.
- RockyMcNuts 10y agoIf you're at the bottom of the ladder (possibly Afro-Cuban), you're better off in Cuba than most other Latin American countries. If you're one of the educated white folks whose family lost a plantation or Havana mansion, I can understand you hate the Castros. It's like getting kicked out of Paris and 60 years later the city is literally crumbling. For a while it was like a civilization trapped in amber but infrastructure has gone over the line into complete decay. On the plus side is good education, good health care, not a lot of crime, until recently a guarantee of a job that would keep body and soul together. The Castros still have > 50% popular support, they have managed to maintain control of the country and the armed forces despite all their failures, foreign military adventures, withdrawal of Russian support, constant pressure from the USA. It's a very mixed bag but not the one-sided disaster we constantly hear about from people who make a cottage industry of selling that story (someone has got the US to spend $500m on broadcasts to Cuba no one can receive, and that's just one example). Moving to a more liberalized economy and attracting foreign investment without causing social unrest, giving up control will be a challenge, and the fact that all the educated people want to leave will not make it easier. these were interesting http://fusion.net/story/116226/historic-poll-top-25-findings-from-major-cuba-survey/ http://fusion.net/story/116226/historic-poll-top-25-findings... http://ftalphaville.ft.com/2016/03/21/2157021/the-us-and-cuba-incrementalism-reversal-risk-and-the-dictators-dilemma/ http://ftalphaville.ft.com/2016/03/21/2157021/the-us-and-cub... http://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/cuba-after-obama-left http://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/cuba-after-obama... https://medium.com/@dtemkin/spending-the-last-week-in-cuba-was-the-single-most-educational-trip-in-my-life-4d6a628760ec#.id0azu3z2 https://medium.com/@dtemkin/spending-the-last-week-in-cuba-w...
- terio 10y agoYou are just a victim of propaganda. Cuba had decent education and decent healthcare system by third world standards but the Cuban economy wasn't able to support either of them and everything came tumbling down when the soviet money stopped flowing in. It would be also very interesting to know from where you get that figure that more than 50% of the population support the Castros as that data is famously unavailable.
- RockyMcNuts 10y agopoll is linked ... read the references ... Cuba's biggest source of FX is exporting doctors, plus just look at the public health stats. I've informed myself and, sorry, not the one who's the victim of propaganda. for the record, it's an effed system and economy and a poor country, just not quite as effed as people would like you to believe. people flock to the US from Mexico too, and that's without the wet foot/dry foot policy giving Cubans automatic asylum. if they do get decent Internet it will be a pretty good tech hub due to the education. Americans might even flock there for a cheap, beautiful and fascinating place to live. Cubans actually have the full US cable/media package via el paquete and eat it up. while you're at it, read up on the Fanjuls, some of America's greatest recipients of corporate welfare, and why US sugar prices are a multiple of world prices. if you love free markets, best thing we could do for poor countries is not blockade them while subsidizing politically connected moguls. (who profit from boycott and generated the constant anti-Castro drumbeat and policy...until they decided they'd rather do business with Cuba) http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2001/02/floridas-fanjuls-200102 http://www.vanityfair.com/news/2001/02/floridas-fanjuls-2001... https://www.aei.org/publication/protectionist-sugar-policy-cost-americans-3-billion-in-2012/ https://www.aei.org/publication/protectionist-sugar-policy-c...
- andrenth 10y agoRight, all those white-ex-plantation-owners-mansion-living-elite risking their lives in the ocean to flee the country... Or asking for political asylum in every opportunity such as during Olympic Games...
- 10y ago
- andrenth 10y agoAnything approaching what could be called a capitalistic/free market economy is basically nonexistent in Latin America, with rare exceptions such as possibly Chile, which by no coincidence leads the quality of life rankings in the region. Other countries had brief experiences with more pro market governments (even if by necessity as opposed to ideology, such as in Brazil), or now in Argentina. The results have always been positive, but we seem destined to be governed by populist left wing governments.
- peterwwillis 10y agoI don't know about its neighbors, but i'm talking specifically about Cuba. Cuba was at the top of the list by the end of the 1950's, when its US-backed dictator had turned it into one of the leading developed nations in the world. Then the Castro regime comes in, and things don't go very well, but the Soviet Union floats it along for a few decades. Then things go down hill real fast. Almost any regime that didn't have such an antagonistic relationship with the US would probably have done better. But it's clear the US was intentionally hurting them in order to pressure some sort of additional revolution so they could install a new dictator. That never happened, so the US forced them to suffer the continued loss of US trade. We could have lifted it during the 90's famine (the OAS lifted its embargo 30 years prior), but still no. I don't see why anyone would downvote my parent comment; the UN has been agreeing with me for 25 years.