4 ms·
>We hyped up college: It is your goal in life to go to send your kids to college. Everybody has to go to college. I've seen many of my friends spend all their
by dominotw 10y ago
>We hyped up college: It is your goal in life to go to send your kids to college. Everybody has to go to college.
I've seen many of my friends spend all their income on house/rent just to live in a good school district. There is no way they are going to let their kids not go to college, they have already created a narrative, a spiral for their kids, no way a kid can escape college at this point. Sunken cost bias.
They spend thousand of dollars on all kinds of things like swimming, piano, ballet, science clubs, coding clubs, robotic clubs, social work club ect. All gears towards making their Stanford application look good. There is no stopping now, wheels are already in motion, full speed ahead.
Kid's view of his life is a hero who lives up to expectations, against all odds. Each test is a battle that must be won. He has been raised on a constant diet of praises for his 'good work', his mind conditioned to keep the praises coming at all costs. The narrative has been set, love is love of success, fear is fear of failure.
- superuser2 10y agoThe tech community is sort of unique in refusing to acknowledge any meaningful difference in the quality of education and research taking place at different institutions. It may be imprudent to set up your child's life according to "all educations in a given field are created equal" if their interest turns out to be in a field that doesn't agree.
- dominotw 10y ago>if their interest turns out to be in a field that doesn't agree. I always wondered how 'interests' come into being. Would love to read more about this if anyone has pointers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- analog31 10y agoSome of my parents' interests rubbed off on me. I think it was because they treated those interests as things with inherent value, even if that value was just pure enjoyment, rather than as hoops to jump through en route to a lucrative career. A lot of my interests were due to what I might call peer pressure of the good kind, i.e., they were things that my friends talked about at school, such as music, electronics, and computers. The only thing I can suggest is to surround your kids with interesting things and interesting people. We're fortunate to live in a neighborhood where you can't swing a cat without hitting someone with an interesting occupation, ranging from academics to artists and musicians.
- wallflower 10y ago> I think it was because they treated those interests as things with inherent value, even if that value was just pure enjoyment, rather than as hoops to jump through en route to a lucrative career. That's awesome! Slightly off-topic tangent (how music is becoming a career track in China): http://www.nytimes.com/video/business/international/100000004491181/88-keys-to-her-future.html http://www.nytimes.com/video/business/international/10000000...
- analog31 10y agoI've heard that a jazz musician can make quite a bit of money in Shanghai right now.
- metaphorm 10y agoexcept you're wrong. elite institution bias is very strong in tech as in other professions. MIT, CMU, and Stanford name recognition has a huge impact and the recruiting pipelines (lucrative paid internships resulting in outrageously high pay for first-job-out-of-college) for elite companies is the way the game is played. maybe tech is mildly more open-minded than say, the law profession, when it comes to elite institution bias. let's not fool ourselves and pretend it isn't a thing though.
- scarface74 10y agoI've see starting salaries for the big tech companies that recruit from the name brand schools. It's about a wash or even negative once you consider the cost of living on the west cost and the cost of the school compared to going to a well known in state college and finding a job in a lower cost of living tech hub.
- wallflower 10y agoThat's not the most fair comparison. Living in NYC/SF is part of the lure of working for one of the top established tech companies. The career trajectory for someone with Google, Amazon, Facebook, Microsoft on their resume usually allows switching among similar top-tier companies (if one is competent and so desires). Once you have one gold-plated company name on your resume, you're set for life. For example, my friends who worked at Apple say that getting hired by Apple is easy relative to keeping up once you are thrown into the firehose there.
- scarface74 10y agoI can't speak for the other companies, but Amazon is relatively easy to get into if you have experience regardless of where your degree is from. But what is the desire for working for a "top tier" company? Looking at the average salaries for Amazon, Facebook, and Microsoft, they aren't that much higher than startups and smaller companies in lower cost areas.
- analog31 10y agoMy family bought a house in a good school district. We've spent thousands of dollars on swimming, music lessons, etc. And that's just scratching the surface. The rest of it -- the narrative, making the Stanford application look good, etc., ... Nope. Sure, I know parents who have that mind set, but I also know parents who don't. I grew up in a culture that values education as an end unto itself. Taking music lessons was just part of the normal routine.
- harroweddude 10y agoTHIS is the kind of insightful, high-quality, wise comment I come to HN for. All the upvotes to you, good sir gentleman and scholar!