5 ms·
1) farmers everywhere are allowed to use last line/new antibiotics routinely in food production. This is utterly fucking stupid. Basically, it's exactly the wo
by stcredzero 10y ago
1) farmers everywhere are allowed to use last line/new antibiotics routinely in food production. This is utterly fucking stupid.
Basically, it's exactly the worst thing you can possibly do, with regards to what the theory of evolution by natural selection tells us. Then add in what we know about bacteria exchanging genetic material, and it's like we're trying to inactivate all of our antibiotics on purpose.
- trhway 10y ago>Basically, it's exactly the worst thing you can possibly do, with regards to what the theory of evolution by natural selection tells us. from the half-full glass POV we are just speeding up the natural selection of bacteria resistant humans (it has been going for millenia and got, probably only temporary, delayed for the last 80 years). Also, as a side effect, it can help solve (at least temporarily) the overpopulation issue until the much more smart (wrt. health and Earth resources usage) humans evolve. Basic dialectics at work.
- stcredzero 10y agofrom the half-full glass POV we are just speeding up the natural selection of bacteria resistant humans) Often, what's good for species evolution is really bad for some individuals. What good is a half-full glass to you if you're dead? Also, as was noted elsewhere in the discussions, evolutionary pressure for bacteria to attain an immunity is high, but pressure to lose one is usually much lower. However, bacteria are small, and such pressure is higher than in more complex celled creatures. "Shelving" antibiotics does work, but would require widespread cooperation and the curbing of feeding antibiotics to livestock.
- pmalynin 10y ago>What good is a half-full glass to you if you're dead? What bad is it if you're dead?
- stcredzero 10y agoYou first!
- taneq 10y ago> from the half-full glass POV we are just speeding up the natural selection of bacteria resistant humans Bahaha that's one way to look at it. I guess we have plenty of humans to spare.
- vacri 10y agoHaving antibiotic failure as the method for arresting the massive human population (7B people) would require carnage that makes World War II (~70M deaths) pale in comparison, even if you correct for the lower global population of the day.
- dredmorbius 10y agoDisease has typically killed more than wars. The Spanish Flu epidemic of 1918 killed 50-100 million people, several percent of the total world population. By comparison, total military and civilian dealths in WWI were about 16 million.
- vacri 10y agoOh, I agree - I just used WWII as it's a more commonly-understood datapoint. The Spanish Flu epidemic only took a couple of years as well, as opposed to the half-decade of WWII.
- trhway 10y agowhy carnage? just some sterilizing effect of some bacterial infection would do it.
- fweespeech 10y ago> from the half-full glass POV we are just speeding up the natural selection of bacteria resistant humans (it has been going for millenia and got, probably only temporary, delayed for the last 80 years). Also, as a side effect, it can help solve (at least temporarily) the overpopulation issue until the much more smart (wrt. health and Earth resources usage) humans evolve. Basic dialectics at work. Bacteria evolves resistance at about the same rate as people develop defenses. So yeah, if you don't mind killing off a huge segment of the population and having women die in childbirth regularly.
- hinkley 10y agoAnd then we raid the animal kingdom looking for other natural antibiotics so that when we all go down together...